3 ms·
In computer science, I'd say the first part is true but not really the second, at least in the areas I work in. People definitely use "did it get into a journal
by _delirium 16y ago
In computer science, I'd say the first part is true but not really the second, at least in the areas I work in. People definitely use "did it get into a journal?" (actually in CS, more often a good conference, since top conferences have more prestige than journals) as a quality filter, but they don't really get their information by browsing the latest issue of journals. For that, it's much more common to just get PDFs off the internet--- from authors' homepages, Google Scholar, CiteSeer, citeulike, mailing lists, personal suggestions, etc., and then figure out where those PDFs came from later.
In some cases, if it's an author I already know of, I don't even bother looking to see where it was published until I actually need to write out a bibtex entry to cite it. Doing things that way, I've cited papers from publication venues I've never even heard of, so they aren't really doing any sort of information-filtering work for me. In those cases, the article may as well have been a tech report for all it mattered to me, since the publication venue was really serving as nothing (from my perspective) except a fancy place to deposit PDFs. Admittedly, that works mainly when I already know something about the author (or someone I know can tell me something about the author). If they're a total unknown, I'd probably be more wary of citing stuff that didn't already get into a venue I respect.
- billswift 16y agoActually, the only real reason I maintain an ACM membership is that I think their online library is a great resource for browsing technical computer science.