3 ms·
Does anybody know where the trend is going? Do electric cars have standard buses or are they moving to proprietary (and not published) buses?
by maxxxxx 9y ago
Does anybody know where the trend is going? Do electric cars have standard buses or are they moving to proprietary (and not published) buses?
- _pmf_ 9y agoCAN will stay for quite a while, as will LIN. However, higher speed buses (esp. FlexRay and MOST) are very, very slowly being replaced by Automotive Ethernet (which uses a proprietary physical layer, called BroadR-Reach). Where CAN used checksums (additional, application layer checksum in addition to the protocol layer) to prevent tampering (modifying live data), the Ethernet based protocols will use what AUTOSAR calls Secure On-Board communication, which features ECU-to-ECU end to end protection.
- muro 9y agoOh interesting. I left the car industry when flexray was the newest bus available and MOST wast only used by Audi (for their backseat screens or some such entertainment systems). The problem with flexray was that it was supposed to be reliable with redundant cabling, but manufacturers immediately turned around to use redundancy to double the bandwidth.
- Matthias247 9y agoThat's all true. Just two few to add: While CAN and LIN are used everywhere Flexray and MOST are used in different domains: Flexray for driving/safety related functions and MOST for infotainment. CAN will have a speed improved version CAN FD, which might see a lot of use in the more driving related ECUs - some say it might replace FlexRay uses there. Afaik SecOC can and will be used for all kinds of PDU based communication (Ethernet and CAN). The amount of PDUs which will be transmitted over Ethernet vs. classical bus systems will very heavily from OEM to OEM. Some are more invested in Ethernet, others not.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Matheus28 9y agoYes, Tesla still uses CAN buses. It has 6 buses if I remember correctly.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoTrue, but bear in mind, the dashboard CAN bus port itself provides almost no access at all, and Tesla actually monitors their cars so they can call and threaten anyone who tries to connect to the actual diagnostics ports, which require a bit more work to get into. http://jalopnik.com/the-tesla-model-s-is-basically-a-good-looking-it-depart-1558372928 http://jalopnik.com/the-tesla-model-s-is-basically-a-good-lo...
- Matheus28 9y agoYou're thinking of the ODB II port, which has basically nothing in the Tesla. The CAN bus located under the cid actually has everything that goes through the car, it simply has a proprietary connector. There's also an ethernet port with a proprietary 4 pin connector, which is locked down by default. They haven't pulled that shit of calling people in a while.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoYeah, although it is wrong, I've been known to refer to the OBD2 port as a CAN port. They may not be calling people, but you'd better believe they're still monitoring them.