4 ms·
He says, as I've heard, that those body fat scales are wildly inaccurate. But it looks like the variance is less than a percentage point, which seems really go
by jessriedel 16y ago
He says, as I've heard, that those body fat scales are wildly inaccurate. But it looks like the variance is less than a percentage point, which seems really good to me. I guess it's more of an issue of a constant error?
EDIT: Yea, I guess it is probably a constant (person-specific) error. The first google result said
>Use [the scales] to measure your progress only. Don't compare your body fat percentage to tables or to your friends score. It is probably inaccurate no matter what the manufacturers say.
I guess if you calibrated this with a one-time, accurate body-fat measurement, it would be pretty good set-up.
EDIT2: Well, maybe not. Some people apparently report that the (cheap?) scales vary several percentage points during a single day. My calibration method also seems vulnerable to the fact that people store their fat in different places on their body depending on their genetics. Maybe this can be fixed with two calibration measurements...
- swombat 16y agoWorth noting that I did the measurements at the same time each morning. When I tried measuring my weight at various times of the day, I easily got several percentage points of difference. Other things that influenced the percentage included: * eating some very salty stuff the previous day (drives down the percentage) * getting drunk the previous day (same, weirdly enough) * eating something late the previous day (same) You can get decent progress tracking so long as you keep your diet relatively steady and weigh yourself at the same time each day. Even so, there will be odd variations of up to 1.5% in a day, but as you can see from the graphs they usually melt back into an average trend.
- briancooley 16y agoYes, they vary widely. If you control for certain variables, they can give you decent directional information. One of the biggest factors in the accuracy of the older Tanita brand scales (this is the brand I have had for many years) is your hydration. For example, if you weigh right when you get out of the shower (even toweled dry), your reported body fat will be much lower than your reported body fat before the shower. They are also sensitive to callouses on your feet. My brother reports much more consistent results with a handheld body fat analyzer, but I've never tried one on a consistent basis.