4 ms·
I don't know why everyone is blaming The Intercept for publishing a document leaked to them anonymously for that exact purpose. They always publish the source d
by dmix 9y ago
I don't know why everyone is blaming The Intercept for publishing a document leaked to them anonymously for that exact purpose. They always publish the source document. So does NYTimes and WaPo and other news orgs. It's common practice.
Assuming The Intercept detected the printer dot, how could they possibly know the printer dot wasn't some random one from a printer a library vs her work computer?
If I was The Intercept receiving a document from someone claiming to be an intelligence officer I would assume they used some very basic OPSEC - such as not printing the document out on a MONITORED WORK COMPUTER. This is basic stuff.
I don't see what more The Intercept could have done here to protect her.
She messed up, not them.
- DanBC 9y agoThe Intercept claims it's a safe place for people to leak to. It isn't if they make blunders like this.
- dmix 9y agoAre you sure this is something NYTimes/WaPo/WSJ/etc would have detected and removed? I'm not familiar with the established practices for news orgs handling leaked documents arriving the mail from intel officers. It seems a lot of people are, so I'm curious to hear more about it...
- rndgermandude 9y agoIt's not just some dots, although that's a massive failure too, of course. TheIntercept reporter contacted some random govt contractor to see if they could verify the documents. Ok so far. But the reporter also revealed the mail was sent from Augusta, Georgia, which is a major breach of confidentiality.[0] [0] https://d3vv6lp55qjaqc.cloudfront.net/items/1k2I053M3J2z0f473l3r/show_temp%20%2866%29.pdf https://d3vv6lp55qjaqc.cloudfront.net/items/1k2I053M3J2z0f47... PDF page 12, paragraph 19
- DanBC 9y ago> Are you sure this is something NYTimes/WaPo/WSJ/etc would have detected and removed? No, I'm not sure about that, and if they'd made the mistake after having claimed to be safe for whistleblowers I'd be gently complaining about them on an Internet message board too.
- jacquesm 9y agoWhether she got caught because of her own mistakes is immaterial. What matters is that if she had not made any mistakes the intercept made it trivially easy to reduce the pool of possible suspects. That´s fairly stupid if your whole reason for existence is to handle documents sent to you by vulnerable people. If this is not the last article by the Intercept based on stuff leaked to them it would highly surprise me. They totally messed this up.
- dmix 9y agoWhy did she even print it off in the first place? It seems like a unusual way to leak in 2017. Why not take a picture using a cellphone and send it digital to the encrypted dropbox on their website? Still I don't see how the Intercept could have handled this better. Maybe they should have been looking for printer dots in documents received in the mail and then block it out when they digitize it. But is this really a common practice among news orgs handling leaked docs? I see people on Reddit attacking The Intercept because, they say, the printer dot thing is 'common knowledge'. But to me this seems like an easy thing to overlook. Especially if most other leaks were digital. News organizations and leakers will certainly all be looking for this going forward (I hope). As far as I'm concerned all the 'common knowledge' stuff that was overlooked was all via the leaker.
- jacquesm 9y agoIf you are in the business of dealing with such information then yes, printer dots should be on your radar. I know about them, so the Intercept should definitely know about them and many things besides that I probably do not know. The intercept could have handled this better by describing the article and maybe a citation or two, to pass the originals back in some form to the government is about as stupid as it gets. If anything this article shows how easy it is to play 33 bits if you have help from the subject or some outsider that is just doing their job in a ham fisted way.
- dmix 9y agoFair enough. Maybe their experience with already outted leakers like Snowden, where publishing the full docs in original form was common practice, and they never fully developed a security system for handling printed documents. They are no doubt probably better experts at crypto than most of the bigger and older news orgs, I know they have some quality infosec guys, but they were ill-prepared for a traditional style leak.
- strathmeyer 9y ago> She messed up, not them. If only there were like.... some group of people who cared about the privacy of others.