3 ms·
One could just as validly make the much-overused "citation needed" call on the assertion in your second sentence - except that we can reasonably require a purel
by mannykannot 9y ago
One could just as validly make the much-overused "citation needed" call on the assertion in your second sentence - except that we can reasonably require a purely graphical response in this case.
- coldtea 9y agoWhat citation do you need? At the very least, a visual environment could always trivially display each syntax/AST node, which will be the same as seeing a plain text version of the code (but better -- closer to something like Apple's Dylan IDE or Smalltalk environments).
- mannykannot 9y agoStrip out the text and see how clear it is.
- arethuza 9y agoAbout as minimal a graphical representation as you can get would be to have a tree of application nodes with S and K combinators as leaf nodes. You can compile any lambda calculus expression down to S and K and "run" them as a graph. Doing this on real calculation probably wins a prize for non clarity though...
- coldtea 9y agoWho said you need to "strip out the text"? Text has been part of graphical representations for milennia. The cool part is that you get to decide WHAT text you get to see -- you're not just left with seeing the lower level code. It could be that, but it can also be boxes representing objects or functions, program modules, interacting programs, at any level of abstraction one likes.
- mannykannot 9y agoStripping the text out is a way to see how much information the graphical element conveys. By allowing arbitrary text in so-called graphical languages, you have turned your original statement into a vacuous truth - an empty tautology - as all text can be diagrammed.
- pbiggar 9y agoStrip out the "text" in your code and just leave the syntax - we'll see how readable that is.
- mannykannot 9y agoWell, that would certainly demonstrate the value of the text aspect of the code...
- pbiggar 9y agoExactly. A graphical representation and a syntactic representation of code will both have text in them. They just have different syntax for equivalent structure.
- coldtea 9y agoYou seem to be conflating visual programming languages/environments with pictography. They are not about that.
- mannykannot 9y agoI am suggesting that your concept of a visual language is just an enhanced presentation of one that is fundamentally textual.
- coldtea 9y agoAnd I'm suggesting the keyword is "enhanced". Movies are fundamentally photography too.