6 ms·
As somebody who has been in this spot and known many more who have been there, it was a good article. But I had a hard time sorting out the political bullshit.
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
As somebody who has been in this spot and known many more who have been there, it was a good article. But I had a hard time sorting out the political bullshit. I eventually got overwhelmed by it and bailed out.
Doctors peddle their wares on a piecework basis; communication among them is haphazard; thinking is often short term; nobody makes money when medical interventions are declined; and nobody is in charge except the marketplace.
No. This is not true. If the marketplace were in charge, the people who got the service would control and be responsible for paying for it by making free and informed decisions. Instead, this is a case where regulation is in charge -- payments are made based on arbitrary rules set forth by well-meaning people. People who might read articles like this and think gee, if we only made up a few more rules, or had some really smart guys in charge of the right stuff, we could fix these other unintended consequences we made last time we mucked around. There is no need for some uber-doctor who could somehow take the place of the buyer. There is nobody who can effectively take the place of the buyer. That's one of the main structural problems of the system. It's not that the marketplace is working -- it's that we've perverted and destroyed the marketplace and instead we have a free-for-all for handouts based on policies created by whatever gets votes. Which will continue to get worse.
Wonderful writing, though. I am always amazed at the capacity of folks to see their entire life experience through their own filters (including me) regardless of what the actual facts are. I hope writing this helped her reach closure and say goodbye
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- sophacles 16y agoYes I trust the doctor, hospital, and manufacturer to provide me with completely unbiased information on what stuff I need for my health. The problem is, the only people who can interpret that information are the same people who directly profit from my choice. They will suggest unnecessary and potentially harmful things. I guess I could go to medical school to really understand things well enough to make a truly informed decision. That would be great for the concept of separation of labor! Of course I am probably just being paranoid. We should instead head back to the good ol' free market medicine days, when anyone could put anything in a bottle and sell it as a patent cure-all. Back then people lived way longer, and had way better options for medicine. Please note: I'm not saying the system isn't messed up, I'm saying you solution really isn't much better.
- mike_organon 16y agoYou're presenting a false alternative: socialized medicine or anarchy. What we need is a free market with the government protecting individual rights (including against fraud), along with intelligent consumers. Also, I suggest you should only trust them to some extent. You need to understand the information well enough to make the decisions, like the mother in the story, where at the end, she treated the doctors as expert technicians, but she knew only she was responsible for the decisions of her life. Even if you have an excellent doctor, your life is your own responsibility.
- dkarl 16y agoIt's not that the marketplace is working -- it's that we've perverted and destroyed the marketplace and instead we have a free-for-all for handouts based on policies created by whatever gets votes. When did an efficient marketplace for medical services ever exist in the United States? "Buyers" have always depended on the ethics and professionalism of doctors; very few people have the education and sophistication necessary to second-guess them. People have always tended to trust doctors, if only because it was the least bad option, and when they don't trust doctors, the result is a thriving market for superstition and quackery. So if the buyer's decision is reduced to which doctor to trust, then you need a way to compare doctors' performance. Creating a way to compare doctors' performance would be a big undertaking requiring some kind of unified, centralized push for standardization -- almost certainly by the government. There may be other ways to actively construct an efficient market, but simply removing the perverting force of regulation will not restore a previously existing efficient market, because the market for medical care has never been efficient, regulation or no.
- carbocation 16y agoHi. Future doctor here. I agree with both of you (I don't think it's paradoxical to do so). To augment your point, consider that if doctors are left to regulate themselves, you run into the additional problems of self regulation (or lack thereof, for both thoughtful and malicious reasons but generally to bad effect). Patients, even in the information age, cannot yet synthesize enough information to generally be intelligent, independent consumers of medical care. There is too much bogosity that has to be filtered out, and most people aren't good at that. (What??? Drug X killed 1 person once??? Well I'm not taking it! [Nevermind that Drug X has saved hundreds of thousands of lives.]) I don't think I'm being elitist, because physicians suffer the same problems, though perhaps to a lesser degree. While they might be more informed consumers of health care generally, a cardiologist probably doesn't have any strong, evidence-based opinions of which is the best treatment for their cancer. (I mean, besides fearing doxorubicin.) Their training in understanding the primary literature is probably their only advantage (and their training in outdated chemotherapeutic agents from medical school is probably their major disadvantage).
- 16y ago