> Why "wrong"? I'm saying they're wrong to dismiss one medium just because... well, it's that medium (which is basically all they are doing). There is nothing

> Why "wrong"? I'm saying they're wrong to dismiss one medium just because... well, it's that medium (which is basically all they are doing). There is nothing intrinsically wrong about an adaptation of a book: they are just fundamentally different due to the medium. It's the dismissiveness that's wrong, specifically, not the observation of differences.