3 ms·
I would seriously consider changing the appearance of the colored header bar. There are 9 items on this bar, but they are not all the same kind of item. The f
by edw519 19y ago
I would seriously consider changing the appearance of the colored header bar. There are 9 items on this bar, but they are not all the same kind of item.
The first 4 (Hacker News, new, threads, and comments) are different views of the same data, so they should be tabs.
Leaders, jobs, and <login id> should be links (blue underlined) because they take you to another page, not another view.
Submit and logout should be buttons.
I would change "Hacker News" to "Popular" and I would put the "New" tab first, because the Popular view is the default. I still get confused by the "threads" and "comments" tabs (now what are these, again?)
Why do I make these suggestions?
Because we are all so used to the site, it's almost impossible for us to visualize how noobies see it. We really need to think about how to better direct people to the new page more often and more easily, without making it the default page. I think the biggest problem is that too many good stories never gain enough traction to graduate to the popular page. If a good story falls to 31st on the new page without an upvote, we'll probably never see it again. This happens often because new posts come in faster than people get to vote for them.
I often read a story that I think is fascinating and wonder how people here will react to it, so I submit it, only to find it disappearing without any upvotes or comments. On the other hand, sometimes my submission takes off to the top of the front page. I realize that I probably think a little differently that a lot of people, but not THAT MUCH differently. Sometimes, I think, it's just timing. Thus, the "It fell off the new page too fast" hypothesis.
Just a thought. Of course, if the data suggests otherwise, then never mind.