5 ms·
The big question to me is whether it's enabled by default, and whether it blocks requests to Google Analytics. If so, that's an interesting shot across the bow
by tyingq 9y ago
The big question to me is whether it's enabled by default, and whether it blocks requests to Google Analytics. If so, that's an interesting shot across the bow.
- magicalist 9y agoWhat would it block? The JS file? Analytics only sets a cookie on the site using it, not one that works across sites.
- tyingq 9y agoCookies are one way to track users. They are not the only one. Google Analytics is so ubiquitous...I can't see Google missing the opportunity to leverage it.
- dbbk 9y agoThis is actually really concerning to me. If they blocked Google Analytics, it would severely damage that data. It'd be bad news for site owners who just want to quantify their traffic.
- icelancer 9y ago....so? Site owners are not guaranteed this access; their script runs on the client computer. I say this as someone who does a lot of analytical research and re-targeting and would be hurt if this was rolled out on a larger scale; I just don't think I have a right to the data.
- ksk 9y agoWell, if don't care about things that prevent you from doing your job, then what exactly is the point of working in that field?
- Spivak 9y agoImagine you were a police officer with this mentality. "As someone who investigates lots of crimes, it's totally fine if someone invokes the fifth amendment, I don't have the right to compel them to answer." "I mean if you don't care about something prevents you from doing your job, why even join the force?"
- ksk 9y agoI don't have to "imagine" anything. Let me invite you to consider the context of my original comment before coming up with ridiculous comparisons.
- lovich 9y agoDoesn't seem that ridiculous a comparison to me. You don't have a right to compel something from someone else, but that doesn't meant you just have to give up at whatever task you are trying to accomplish
- ksk 9y agoWhen I read a comment, the first thing I do is read the ones above it so I understand the limited scope of the comment. I don't immediately rub my hands with glee and go about compiling a list of situations to which the comment doesn't apply. I guess that sort of thing appeals to some. Complaining about losing data is in no way the same as assuming entitlement status or forcing someone to do something. The job of a police officer is to enforce laws, and exercise human judgement. The issue with the fifth amendment would be handled by lawyers in courts, not by the officers on the ground. IT jobs have completely different parameters. The comparison with police officer is entirely irrelevant and as such I don't want to continue that discussion.
- epistasis 9y agoKind of presuming the wrong thing there. There's still work to be done, right? Just because something would make the job easier does not mean it should be done, ethics come first.
- rimliu 9y agoWell, back to log files. Which may no longer work with the latest and greatest JS framework :(
- Doctor_Fegg 9y agoThe article says (my emphasis): > segregate the _cross-site_ scripting data So if you "just want to quantify your traffic", use self-hosted Piwik (i.e. not cross-site), as many of us do already.
- majewsky 9y agoWhat's the advantage of third-party analytics over self-hosted ones (e.g. GA over Piwik), except for "someone else hosts it for me for free"? Honest question. I'm not logging anything about my websites' visitors on principle, so I don't have insight into that area.
- draw_down 9y agoWelp. Sorry.
- smitherfield 9y agoSpeaking of shots across the bow, I'm surprised they've never put an ad-blocker in Safari.
- tinus_hn 9y agoYou don't need to block Google Analytics to make it more private. You just need to make the user appear to a new user to every site. So Google may lose data because then they can't track you all over the web, but the websites don't because they still see you as one user.
- tyingq 9y agoMaybe I'm overly paranoid, but I assume Google does all sorts of fingerprinting (documented and not) via GA. Why else would it be free if it didn't provide a big upside for Google?
- jaegerpicker 9y agoOnly a limited subset is free. More advanced types of tracking requires the pro subscription.
- mbel 9y agoIsn't it like this that all data is gathered anyway, but site owner can access the more advanced tracers with paid subscriptions? I don't intent to provoke FUD, I seriously don't know. This would sound like rational choice for Google since they need this data to run their business.
- tinus_hn 9y agoWhy do they need fingerprinting? They can just give you an identifier and combine it with your login on the Google sites to connect it to your identity.
- hoschicz 9y agoDoes Analytics do some tracking by default? Or only if you enable the advanced demographics options, which enable DoubleClick?
- tyingq 9y agoThe fact that it's free for site owners suggests it has some benefit to Google, so I assume heavy fingerprinting and tracking.
- Antrikshy 9y agoI hope it's not enabled by default so it doesn't ruin analytics data for web masters. I personally don't see any reason to turn it on either, so...