6 ms·
VCs need one large exit to see good profits
- tdeck 9y agoThe Kauffman foundation published a study about venture capital a few years ago; we read it in my Tech Entrepreneurship class. They reached similar conclusions: http://www.kauffman.org/-/media/kauffman_org/research-reports-and-covers/2012/05/we_have_met_the_enemy_and_he_is_us.pdf http://www.kauffman.org/-/media/kauffman_org/research-report... > Venture capital (VC) has delivered poor returns for more than a decade. VC returns haven’t significantly outperformed the public market since the late 1990s, and, since 1997, less cash has been returned to investors than has been invested in VC. Speculation among industry insiders is that the VC model is broken, despite occasional high-profile successes like Groupon, Zynga, LinkedIn, and Facebook in recent years. EDIT: This is actually linked from the article but I thought it was worth calling out nonetheless.
- dxhdr 9y ago> despite occasional high-profile successes like Groupon, Zynga Are those really the definition of a VC success story?
- SkyMarshal 9y agoHaven't read your study, but did they take into account the trillions in losses the public markets would have taken in 07/08 if not for the government & Fed bailouts? VC's and their portfolios would have taken losses too, but 1) they tend to have a longer (~10yr) time horizon, and 2) at least the VC equity-based investment model doesn't cause credit bubbles.
- HillaryBriss 9y agoNice, clear statement of the fundamental theorem of VC funds: ...the only realistic way for a fund to get acceptable returns is to try to find only the companies that could be the next Ubers, Facebooks and Airbnbs. Under these rules, it doesn’t make sense for VCs to invest in anyone that can’t get to unicorn stage. There’s just no place for “average” companies...
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> There’s just no place for “average” companies Sure there is: bank loans, growth capital, corporate backers through a JV, et cetera. This is how new business was financed for centuries. If you're talking about companies that grow up to be "average" but still fail at the rate and with the recovery rates of aspiring unicorns, then ofcourse not.
- ThrustVectoring 9y ago>Invest in more startups/less cash in each. The assumption today is that VCs want to own 20-25 percent equity of any startup in which they invest, assuming they have cash to follow up. The reasoning being, if there actually is a realization event (exit/IPO), they want to score big. This isn't the reasoning behind it. The actual reasoning is more like constraints in number of worthwhile investment opportunities. If the fund has $100M to invest and a hundred startups that meet their criteria, the fund has to average $1M per investment in order to invest all the money that they want to. If they have $200M, the average investment has to go up to $2M. VCs are already talking to as many companies as they can. Investing in more opportunities means lowering their standards. Assuming that VCs are rational about their standards, this is a poor choice.
- birken 9y agoVC isn't necessarily designed to have returns that are better than the public markets, only to have returns that are different from the public markets. If you have billions of dollars to invest, you want to diversify. So the core part of the message that VC is broken because most of them don't beat the public markets doesn't really matter. > One-two years for scouting and finding 10 A-round startups, four-five years for growth. Add some non-stop pressure on the founders to sell all the way around. Holy moly. How well would this have worked for Google to sell to Yahoo or Facebook to sell to Google? You are throwing out the baby with the bathwater here. If a company blows up, the vast majority of the returns are coming after 4-5 years. I mean, look at GOOG, and only returns since it went public (~6 years after founding). Google's stock is up 1700%, the public markets are only up ~150%. You want them to sell those returns to somebody else? And obviously this post-IPO gain is just a multiplier on the returns from Series A --> IPO which is just astronomical returns you'd be not getting. > Invest in more startups/less cash in each. Just doesn't make sense. For many VCs the limiting factor is their ability to spend their time and effort trying to help their portfolio companies. Good VCs don't just give money, they give guidance, advice, strategy, etc. You can do this with 2-3 companies, not so much with 20-30. > The ancient “2 percent and 20 percent” should be killed off and replaced with something that endorses higher alignment. Let the VCs fight for their supper. What is the suggestion?
- warcher 9y agoIs there evidence of fund returns non-correlated to the public markets? Big IPOs in down markets? I see a lot of dot-bomb kinds of things, and the latest IPOs have been taking full advantage of the froth in the public markets. It's hard to imagine Snapchat making a go of it without the current stock pricing being so lenient.
- birken 9y agoThese VCs have some interesting data about that: http://blog.ttcp.com/the-inverse-correlation-between-venture-and-public-markets/ http://blog.ttcp.com/the-inverse-correlation-between-venture... I'm not sure I agree with them or their particularly analysis, but I'm very convinced they are different because the way I see it, VC and the public markets are completely different things. It's like the farm system for baseball teams. VC is investing in the upcoming prospects, and the VC is investing in the existing major leaguers. Sometimes you'll have a farm system full of A+++ prospects that pay off huge (Google, Facebook), and sometimes you won't (pick a 5 year period where there were no massive VC payouts). And obviously the returns on those prospects will only go to whatever team they happened to be on (which VC picked them), whereas public market returns can go to anybody. But they are different companies at different ages doing different things. Thus to me it would be quite surprising if their returns were all that correlated. And at some sense "froth" is irrelevant. A VC doesn't have to sell their Facebook or Google stock when it IPOs, they can hold onto it as long as they like. They are basically investing for the chance to get that amazing stock at a huge discount by getting it at the "prospect" stage, and once it goes public they can ride the public market waves as well.
- pcl 9y agoThe math in the article seems to be based on the assumption that the money committed for the fund is payed by the LP up-front. My understanding is that that's typically not the case -- instead, the LPs commit to some dollar amount, but only actually write checks when the VC round makes an investment. I haven't done the numbers to see how this changes the outcomes in the article, but it seems like it probably has a pretty big impact, considering how much the article focuses on the liquidity aspects. I wonder what the contribution graph tends to look like over the lifetime of a typical fund.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 9y agoThe problem is the market only cares about companies that have the potential to be the next Tesla, Facebook, amazon, etc., so unless you're in a this very special and exclusive niche, exiting is very hard. It's not like in the 90's when all tech sectors did well...now it's just social networking, apps, Tesla, and Uber. A very lopsided, winner-take-all market.
- mbesto 9y agoNone of this is "news", just another re-hashing of "yet another explanation of how VC works, because VC's will never admit their mode plainly". Here ya go: https://blog.wealthfront.com/venture-capital-economics/ https://blog.wealthfront.com/venture-capital-economics/ https://blog.wealthfront.com/venture-capital-economics-part-2/ https://blog.wealthfront.com/venture-capital-economics-part-... https://medium.com/startup-grind/technology-due-diligence-or-lack-thereof-fbeb46687bec https://medium.com/startup-grind/technology-due-diligence-or... EDIT: Just re-read, makes sense why this is "news"... "I recently had a meeting...talking about the macro view of venture capital and how it doesn’t actually make sense....It took me a while to understand what this really means."
- ChuckMcM 9y agoIt is important to understand that these studies really are looking at the 'post dot com' VC industry or perhaps more succinctly "what it became after that event." And it would be wrong to assume that there aren't market forces, working even as we type, to 'correct' the imbalance. If it had not been for the exceptionally anemic returns to be had in general, I expect this correction would have happened sooner. But unlike startups that post 'incredible journey' type farewells, VC firms that evaporate are rarely reported on. There are firms which are contractually following through on their existing funds, raising no new funds, and entertaining no investments in companies they aren't already invested in. These are dead venture capital companies that are waiting for the end of life support. I am curious what the next chapter will look like. A lot of people think it will be more 'integrated' VCs that look more like Y-combinator and less like Sequoia. Hard to say.
- elmar 9y agoThis 4:30m video of Mike Maples explains very simply what VC is all about. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a5nVkkk2NtA https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a5nVkkk2NtA
- rlucas 9y agoClickbait title for a naive look at a pretty well-understood, much-scrutinized topic. Digging in further: - assumptions are bad. 7-8% in RE / public equities? Hmm, dubious. - poor understanding of TVM. 12% is 3x? Except, in the real world, there are incremental cash flows on both capital calls and returns ... so IRR. - completely ignores cyclicality. Vintage year is the single biggest determinant of venture performance. One big plus: takes a bit of the wind out of the "we VCs are paid to take risks" strutting. Of course, professional VCs gauge risks and make informed bets. But as the author points out, it's mostly with other peoples' money. True. Entrepreneurs are the ones taking the real, personal risks.
- jeo1234 9y agoHistorical returns on the S&P 500 are about 10%.
- mschuster91 9y ago> I’ll clarify: Ninety-five percent of VCs aren’t actually returning enough money to justify the risk, fees and illiquidity their investors (LPs) are taking on by investing in their funds. Illiquidity? Well given the huge amount of capital in the markets, there is next to zero other way to invest your big monies while also wanting some above-inflation return... the only real exceptions are pennystocks (aka spread and hope for a unicorn, just without a VC as "middleman"), real estate (which may or may not crash soon-ish, given that the bubble in Western markets, esp. London, has been created by Chinese and Russian investors hoping to stash money away before capital flow regulations) and VC. Everything other is dead: State bonds, e.g. the German bonds, even pay negative interest, "conventional" lending is also downhill, and the market is too short-term-thinking to go long on "classic" stocks. To summarize: Yes, there is a huge amount of risk and fees involved when investing with VCs, but they are not creating illiquidity when there's next to nothing where liquidity can flow into. And only when looking via this viewpoint one can understand how Yo could get 1.5M $ VC at 10M $ valuation.
- roguecoder 9y agoThis is the natural consequences of growing income inequality, especially as fueled by our failure to tax investment income at the same rate as other income.
- tryitnow 9y ago> There’s just no place for “average” companies looking to be worth and sell less than $500 million. At least not with VCs. Ummm, yeah, that's right because those investors are called growth equity investors. They don't get the attention VCs do but they are out there.
- roguecoder 9y agoThe mythology around VC investing is so intense in the valley it is at the point where people don't know (or don't have to know) that there are alternatives that don't rely on massive growth.
- roguecoder 9y agoThe one problem with this post is the idea that past performance predicts future results. Do previously-successful VCs actually do better in the future?
- dzink 9y agoThe 2/20 model doesn't go away because it is a signaling mechanism for quality during fundraising with LPs. A16Z actually raised their carry to 30%. Since only 1/4 of VC funds actually outperformed the S&P Index in a Kauffman study, it doesn't pay to advertise yourself as the "cheap" VC.