3 ms·
> You cannot have it both ways in this. Either you simply don't care about diversity (which is a value decision I am not denying your ability to make), or you d
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> You cannot have it both ways in this. Either you simply don't care about diversity (which is a value decision I am not denying your ability to make), or you do and physical indicators that shape how society treats people are a high quality signal of diversity. You cannot rationally suggest both that diversity is important but that people's traits and backgrounds aren't.
But that's the whole issue. It's about backgrounds, not traits. You can't tell someone's background from their skin color, it's just a proxy. And if you optimize for the proxy instead of the thing itself you end up selecting black men from affluent families in the suburbs, which minimizes the difference in perspective they have compared to white men from affluent families in the suburbs.
You would end up with more actual diversity if you had chosen someone from Russia or Japan or Germany (or even a different part of the US) who has an even more different perspective. Even if that person is also a white or Asian male. Instead of selecting for the people who add the least actual diversity to your organization but allow you to check a box.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- KirinDave 9y ago> But that's the whole issue. It's about backgrounds, not traits. You can't tell someone's background from their skin color, it's just a proxy. I think this isn't strictly true, but I want to be clear that taken as you meant this (charitably) then it's true! However, a negative version of this bias provably and observably exists in our industry. So long as that exist, we must remember that this is the case and apply a counterbalancing principle. As it stands right now, people are unfairly denied opportunity by bad actors and then potentially good actors (let's charitably say you are one) often find themselves saying, "Well isn't this unfair?"
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> So long as that exist, we must remember that this is the case and apply a counterbalancing principle. You're still balancing the wrong thing. The people underrepresented in this industry are from particular socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds. The people with those backgrounds are not racially balanced, but that does not make balancing on race a solution. It's not necessarily the case that that there even is a solution. If a particular culture discourages its members from becoming computer scientists then the members of that culture will be underrepresented in computer science. You could make efforts to change their culture, but wasn't the different perspective supposed to be the original point?
- KirinDave 9y ago> You're still balancing the wrong thing. The people underrepresented in this industry are from particular socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds. The people with those backgrounds are not racially balanced, but that does not make balancing on race a solution. If you actually balance on socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds, you will tend to regress towards the base population distribution of your hiring locality. But that's not what we see. Indeed, by selecting for white men in America you actually will amplify classist effects in America, as wealth is disproportionately distributed to white men. Ultimately this is the observation it feels to me like you're hoping to avoid. If we're genuinely seeking a diversity of perspective we'd expect to see ethinic, class and religious diversity as a natural outcome of this desire. That we don't suggests that in fact people are interested in the OPPOSITE a diversity of opinion. This particular bellwether is important because it signals a concrete group of people who are excluded just because of how they look and the preconceptions that surround that. This is exactly what you say you don't want anyone to do, but exactly what you refuse to concede might be happening given the stats. > If a particular culture discourages its members from becoming computer scientists then the members of that culture will be underrepresented in computer science. What even is this trying to say? What specific group is both discouraging its members to be computer scientists and also publicly demanding more opportunities in computer science?
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> If you actually balance on socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds, you will tend to regress towards the base population distribution of your hiring locality. If you actually balance on socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds, you will tend to regress toward the base population distribution of the qualified applicants in your hiring locality. Which is basically what we see. It's not as if there are a slew of black programmers that no one will hire because of racism. The outcome is primarily a result of the lack of qualified minority applicants. > Indeed, by selecting for white men in America you actually will amplify classist effects in America, as wealth is disproportionately distributed to white men. The causation goes the other way. In order to get into this field you have to come from a culture that encourages young people to learn math and computers, and a family that can afford to send their children to college. Those conditions create much of the racial disparity in qualified applicants. The economic problem has a plausible solution, you can subsidize higher education, the main impediment being how to finance it. But what do you propose to do about the cultural differences? If children in one culture aspire to be tech entrepreneurs and children in another culture aspire to be professional athletes, you're going to see different outcomes. > What specific group is both discouraging its members to be computer scientists and also publicly demanding more opportunities in computer science? Groups like "women" or "African Americans" are broad and internally diverse. You can trivially find contradictory opinions. One black man laments the small number of black men in computer science while another black man encourages his children to join the basketball team instead of the computer club.