4 ms·
So, why? Companies shouldn't have ownership of TLDs, so why did you register so many TLDs that have nothing to do with Google, and which you don't allow to be
by kuschku 9y ago
So, why?
Companies shouldn't have ownership of TLDs, so why did you register so many TLDs that have nothing to do with Google, and which you don't allow to be used freely? Profits?
This is disgusting. The fact that corporations can control TLDs in the first place is disgusting, and I'd by far prefer if every TLD would have to be controlled by cooperatives (like denic) or other kinds of nonprofits, completely independent of everything else.
Especially in the current situation, where Google is cybersquatting on entire TLDs, just because they can. And while domains are frequently removed for squatting, nothing’s done with TLDs. Open the TLD for everyone, and use it, or get rid of it. But the current situation is disgusting. (I fundamentally disagree with companies controlling any kind of infrastructure)
- an_account 9y agoHonest question: why make the distinction between top level domains and secondary level domains?
- tux3 9y agoAnyone can register a second level domain under .com or the other main TLDs. This used to be the few main namespaces shared by everyone, at reasonable prices, and it went just fine. ICANN made a de-facto distinction with the obscene pricing for top-level domains. There's a new global namespace, but you can't afford to get into that one if you're not a big fish. That seems to be what the landscape looks like nowadays.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoYou are about 5 years too late in your criticism. This whole debate was had when ICANN expanded top-level domains in 2012: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_top-level_domain#Expansion_of_gTLDs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_top-level_domain#Expan...
- 43224gg252 9y agoNot agreeing or disagreeing, but I don't see the relevance of your point.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agokuschku's comment makes it sound like he was unaware of what happened in 2012, and he is fundamentally misunderstanding the current state of gTLDs, so I was informing him. Furthermore, the ship has sailed on the debate of whether these expanded TLDs are a good thing, so it's not a productive discussion. We might as well talk about whether commerce should be banned on the internet - that was a raging debate in the early/mid 90s, and that debate is over.
- kuschku 9y ago> Furthermore, the ship has sailed on the debate of whether these expanded TLDs are a good thing Why? We could simply remove all of them again. Or we could open TLDs to be affordable for everyone. But the current situation has literally Google domainsquatting on TLDs. That’s... insane.
- CydeWeys 9y ago> Why? We could simply remove all of them again. No, we couldn't. That would break the Internet in a large variety of horrible ways. You can't remove entire TLDs once delegated and widely linked to. That's closing the barn door after the horse has escaped.
- kuschku 9y ago> You can't remove entire TLDs once delegated and widely linked to. That's closing the barn door after the horse has escaped. Why not? We can also remove domains once registered and widely linked to. The NIC of .eu just removed over 10'000 due to squatting. Why shouldn’t we just remove Google’s TLDs where it’s squatting?
- 9y ago
- CydeWeys 9y agoThat's the way it's been since the earliest days of the World Wide Web. You can read the history of .com here https://icannwiki.org/.com https://icannwiki.org/.com , but the TL;DR is that it was run by a private company as early as 1991, then acquired by Network Solutions in 1993, which was acquired by Verisign in 2000 who still run it to this day. .net has a similar history. I don't see any a priori reason why profit-driven companies should be excluded, and as you point out, there are plenty of non-profit registry operators to choose from (including Public Interest Registry, the non-profit that runs .org), if you care strongly about that. denic is a ccTLD operator, whereas what we're discussing here are all gTLDs.
- kuschku 9y agoMy issue is that there’s corporations squatting on TLDs, which no normal person can afford. Not only does this increase the advantages an established corporation can have over individuals or startups, it also ends up with Google literally domainsquatting entire TLDs just because they can. And there’s no registrar above them that could simply revoke their domains for squatting. And de is as much a ccTLD as .io – it’s not really the actual case anymore. DE is one of the largest domains overall, even counting gTLDs. And we could simply solve this – use the power of democracy (aka, governments) to force TLD ownership to be entirely non-profit. I don’t want to see large corporations buy massive amounts of TLDs (as google has done) and then sit on them. In addition to the antitrust issues that can appear with this. How should a startup ever be able to compete in a reasonable timeframe with Google if we allow these corporations to grow ever further, and gain ever more power?
- CydeWeys 9y agoI can't really comment on the rest of it, for obvious reasons, but this part is not accurate: > And de is as much a ccTLD as .io – it’s not really the actual case anymore. .de is clearly still the ccTLD for Germany. It's not at all like the situation of .io, which is run by a British company as, effectively, a two-letter generic TLD that has nothing to do with the actual Indian Ocean territories. .de clearly has a lot to do with Germany, including being widely used there (but not anywhere else), and also being run by denic, a German company headquartered in Frankfurt. I was just in Frankfurt last week talking with a bunch of denic people, actually. They absolutely do consider it a country code TLD, proudly and unapologetically.