16 ms·
Harvard withdraws 10 acceptances for ‘offensive’ memes in private group chat
- Skywing 9y agoI also believe that Riot Games would fire employees for excessive offensive in-game chat.
- wnevets 9y agoWell that's a very different matter, it was excessive offensive language to their customers (the other players) in game chat.
- Coding_Cat 9y agoNoteworthy difference being that, I believe, Riot employees are identified as such and their communication is public (in the eyes of Riot) not private. In this case I think it might very well be a case of "The Aristocrats" humor like they mentioned in the article (CAH). I disagree with withdrawing the invitation based upon private communication here, but if it was publically visible and said "hey we're Harvard Students" I can understand Harvard's position and cautiously agree with them.
- DanBC 9y agoIt wasn't just a private group. > The founders of the messaging group demanded that students post provocative memes in the main group chat to gain admittance to the smaller group.
- Simulacra 9y agoWhat you do and say on social media can and will be used against you.
- std_throwaway 9y agoExtend this to any place connected to the internet or other means of collecting information and linking it to you. Social media is just the easy way in.
- Simulacra 9y agoI'm going to make my children say it like the pledge of allegiance.
- likelynew 9y agoAlso, they are private and something that is not directly implicating Harvard, for which there can be reasons to ethically withdraw/fire someone.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fdsfsafasfdas 9y agoFor such apparently intelligent people, such dimwitted use of a centrally managed communications. Not to mention bad taste, it seems.
- std_throwaway 9y agoPeople go to the toilet to get the crap out. Same for many online forums.
- 2_listerine_pls 9y agoMany do it for fun while not being racist. 4chan is an example.
- Mediterraneo10 9y agoI saw this firsthand with a former flatmate of mine. He passionately studied Semitic languages and Persian at uni, spent a lot of time traveling or studying abroad in Israel, Arab countries, and Iran. His social circle in Europe was heavy with immigrants from those countries and with them he seemed to be the best of friends. And yet he loved to visit 4chan and collect anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim memes to repost elsewhere just for the lols. Deciding if a person is "really racist" or not has become a challenge in our age.
- pyre 9y agoBut making that shit turn up everywhere just normalizes it. People start seeing those things and agreeing with them, no matter how "ironically" he intending them to be taken. Ideas like "let's get Donald Trump elected for the lulz" have real-world effects. "It was just for laughs, mate" isn't really a good excuse. At a certain point, it approaches "watching the world burn" territory.
- 2_listerine_pls 9y ago> Ideas like "let's get Donald Trump elected for the lulz" have real-world effects. Do you have statistics to back that claim?
- std_throwaway 9y agoWe'll have to create a public and a second, private, personality just like in the old days of the police state. Society is more open than it probably was ever before but at the same time, if close minded leaders of fascist political or religious color came into power they'd have their tools handed to them to create an oppressive apparatus never seen before.
- pyroinferno 9y ago>We'll have to create a public and a second, private, personality I thought this was always the case.
- frank_nitti 9y agoIf HRC is any indication...
- maxerickson 9y agoProbably even more than 2.
- lclarkmichalek 9y ago> The students in the spinoff group exchanged memes and images “mocking sexual assault, the Holocaust and the deaths of children,” sometimes directing jokes at specific ethnic or racial groups, the Crimson reported. One message “called the hypothetical hanging of a Mexican child ‘piñata time’” while other messages quipped that “abusing children was sexually arousing,” according to images of the chat described by the Crimson. You know, if that's your personality, I'm OK with you feeling ashamed enough that you feel the need to keep it private.
- std_throwaway 9y agoI don't care what they said. If it's against the law, let the law deal with it. If it's covered under freedom of speech, let them speak.
- 9y ago
- alunchbox 9y agoanother example why shenanigans shouldn't be done on Facebook. if you wanna $#!K around do it on a platform that isn't personal how is this so hard to understand ? (mind you this does seem excessive from what they are reporting)
- std_throwaway 9y agoWhat platform isn't personal? Sure, you don't use your real-name here or there, but it can and will be linked to you in the future. Any online and offline activity has a real chance of being linked to you at some point in the future.
- alunchbox 9y agotrue enough, but as long as law enforcement don't need to get involved (obv don't do stupid stuff) a username is easier to throw away then a Facebook account... But even then I suppose it wouldn't be possible - Big Brother here we come.
- meritt 9y agoHow is this excessive? They were promoting the sort of hate speech you find in the darker corners of 4chan and /r/The_Donald. Harvard is fully within their rights to require a certain level of civility and maturity of their applicants.
- akhilcacharya 9y agoSomeone at a state school would have the same thing happen to them if they pulled stuff like this. No reason why they should be treated with kid gloves because they got into Harvard.
- pyroinferno 9y agoI think the concern here is that it was private.
- bjl 9y agoNothing on FB is private, which these kids just learned the hard way. Can't say I feel too bad for them given the content of their posts.
- kelukelugames 9y agoKind of scary that nothing on facebook is ever private. High school or parents should start teaching kids about online privacy...and financial literacy. FB issue aside, I think people should be allowed to joke about whatever they want in private. However some people bring jokes from 4chan and b/ into the workplace. High school and college students probably have a harder time drawing the line between facebook and the classroom.
- bjl 9y ago>FB issue aside, I think people should be allowed to joke about whatever they want in private. They were allowed to post it, nothing stopped them. Its just that after they did Harvard made the (IMO reasonable) decision to revoke their acceptance.
- pc86 9y agoWhy? People are totally within their rights to share these things in public or in private. Private institutions, including Harvard, are totally within their rights to rescind admissions offers because of it.
- ybrah 9y agoThis is why I like 4chan. I can shit post to my hearts content without getting screwed by the morality police.
- VLM 9y agoThe critical advantage of 4chan is there's no trademark dilution. There's just /b/ or whatever, there is no /Harvard/ board to insult the image of a multibillion dollar organization. Regardless what the kids were posting, I'm not sure what they were thinking, using a name like that can't possibly end well.
- metaphorm 9y agoI'm so conflicted right now. On the one hand, yeah, that shit is offensive and I'm not too keen on elevating a person who makes jokes about sexual assault or violence against minorities. On the other hand I'm terrified at the creeping surveillance society that has institutions examining all of our utterances for "wrong speech", which is much too close for comfort to "wrong think", which is much too close for comfort to "wrong person".
- adamnemecek 9y ago> makes jokes about sexual assault or violence against minorities. At the same time it's somewhat hypocritical of the school to do this as their attitude towards sexual assault on campus is pretty lenient. http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2016/6/9/harvard-clery-stats-mass/ http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2016/6/9/harvard-clery-sta...
- tanderson92 9y agoThat's not called hypocrisy, it's called a mixed record.
- Frondo 9y agoI am perfectly fine with private organizations banning whoever they like for posting racist shit. Racist shit is "wrong speech". If I have friends who start uttering racist shit, and I can't talk them out of it, they are no longer my friends. (This has happened precisely once, no regrets. Thanks, Fox News, for poisoning an old man's mind.) Posting racist memes is wrong, saying racist things is wrong, thinking racist thoughts is wrong. How did we get here, that racism falls under the scare-quotes version of "wrong speech" and not actually wrong speech??
- nxsynonym 9y agobecause free speech is universal. You can't cherry pick what topics/views/opinions are protected based on your world view.
- esteves_ 9y agoThe new students of Harvard get the message: follow the script comrades, or else...
- g051051 9y agoConsidering how competitive the acceptance criteria are for Harvard (2,056 out of 39,506 applications), this is just another decision point. Now 10 other people are able to get in, and the entire body of current and prospective students have learned a valuable lesson about privacy and free speech.
- spyspy 9y ago> a valuable lesson about privacy and free speech That there is none?
- bjl 9y agoLast I checked they weren't jailed for posting racist shit on FB.
- nxsynonym 9y agoI wholeheartedly agree with this. As a private institution, Harvard can choose to deny acceptance to anyone for any reason. I don't agree with their reasoning, but I agree with their right to decide. Next time don't use Facebook. This is what 4chan is for.
- kudu 9y agoThat isn't completely accurate. An acceptance to Harvard is usually unconditional, and can only be withdrawn under very specific circumstances (in this case, they're invoking the circumstance relating to an admitted student's honesty/integrity/moral standing). Just wanted to clear up that there is a big difference between denying someone acceptance at the time of application and withdrawing one. (Source: also admitted to Harvard this year)
- std_throwaway 9y ago...that privacy probably doesn't exist and free speech shouldn't be used.
- 9y ago
- atroll 9y agowhy a facebook group when they have 4chan
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoI think these memes illustrate a serious superiority complex of harvard (and other "prestigious" schools) students/alumni. I think this represents just the visible tip of the iceberg...I'm sure many more Harvard students still exhibit similar superiority complexes and thoughts even though they are too wise to not share such memes in a private chat.
- aestetix 9y agoMaybe I missed it from the article: 1. Were the students given a warning before having their admissions withdrawn? 2. I'm curious why Harvard chose the nuclear option, rather than to use this as an opportunity to teach why the memes were considered offensive, and more appropriate ways to express themselves.
- cpncrunch 9y ago>I'm curious why Harvard chose the nuclear option, than to use this as an opportunity to teach why the memes were considered offensive, and more appropriate ways to express themselves. Presumably they don't want nasty, highly offensive people in their institution. Which is perfectly reasonable. I wouldn't want anything to do with people like that either.
- modzu 9y agocreepy treehouse
- modzu 9y agohttp://www.chronicle.com/blogs/profhacker/the-creepy-treehouse-problem/23027 http://www.chronicle.com/blogs/profhacker/the-creepy-treehou...
- SurrealSoul 9y agoMy fraternity got suspended because someone trash talked some administration person on our private chat page. Turns out one of our members really disliked the trash talker and the insult in general and reported the incident. The private group chat in Harvard probably either has a [for lack of better word] tattle tail, or even a shadow member who is associated with advisors to take into consideration what the new members are saying. Long story short, these young people are getting their first dose of 'what happens in Vegas, is likely to cause long-term relationship issues'
- ziggysak 9y agoI think an article such as this one is a clear example of the generational differences between older and younger people. I'm fairly close to these kids' age and I've browsed memes from /r/dankmemes and enjoyed them. The thing is, is that these memes are supposed to be self-aware of how offensive they are. That's the joke. They're meant to be so offensive and ridiculous that reactions can be drawn from outside spectators so they can get offended and you can laugh at them for being a "normie". I have no issue with these jokes unless they've been made in a sincere attempt at racism or sexism, and knowing my experience with the internet, I don't believe this is the case.
- Houshalter 9y agoIt's not a new thing. Dead baby jokes have been around forever, and popular comedians often use similar black humor. The article mentions the card game cards against humanity. Which is pretty popular and based on the same premise. I used to really like black humor. I frequently told dead baby jokes and similar stuff. Thank god that wasn't recorded. I'm alarmed to see many of the comments here outraged over the stuff the students said. I guarantee most of them have probably told a similarly offensive joke at some point in time, or at the very least have friends who have. Especially when they were younger.
- ziggysak 9y agoI agree, but what is new is that suddenly kids are having their college acceptances revoked for dead baby jokes that the administrators probably also joked about 30 years ago, when they were 18.
- kbenson 9y ago> The article mentions the card game cards against humanity. Which is pretty popular and based on the same premise. Except that the premise of Cards Against Humanity is that you are all opting in to the situation where you expect that, and usually an a somewhat private setting. The equivalent to the CAH suggestion would be where some private group of people indicated that to become members, you had to go to a public cafe and play CAH loudly in public. Were that Cafe to get mad at you and ban you from their premises, getting upset at that outcome is rather silly. You either knew that was a possibly outcome, or you should have known. In any case, that Cafe is well within their rights to decide they want nothing to do with you anymore.
- threepipeproblm 9y agoI don't want to take from the gravity of the main topic, but it seemed notable that the online group -- and this is the larger one, not the subset that got in trouble -- identify as "bourgeois". Unless Harvard has really changed, then... nope!
- jswny 9y agoI think a lot of people are missing this: > “As a reminder, Harvard College reserves the right to withdraw an offer of admission under various conditions including if an admitted student engages in behavior that brings into question his or her honesty, maturity, or moral character,” the group description states. Whether you think that this was ok for Harvard to do or not, doing this kind of stuff in the official Harvard student Facebook group (managed by Harvard employees) given that description is just downright stupid.
- anon182429 9y agoIvy league is such a joke. Who would go to a place that snoops on your communication, tells you what to think and believe, shames you for expressing yourself through humor, and has such fun policies as segregated graduation while at the same time banning people who are "racist" from attending the school. These people are insane and I can't believe they run the country.
- vinceguidry 9y agoPeople worried about free speech rights should realize that Harvard is a private university. If I held a party at my house and didn't want to invite you because you called my dog a 'mutt', you'd get laughed out of court if you tried to sue me over it. People should be allowed to organize under whatever principles they want to organize under. Disallowing Harvard to use whatever criteria they want to use to admit students, unless of course they breach civil rights laws, is ultimately decreasing the amount of intellectual diversity in the world. People that don't like Harvard can apply to any other college. There's no shortage of them to choose from. But if you tell Harvard what they can and can't do, you run the risk of destroying the individuality of Harvard. Also, there's some mumbling about the fact that it was private speech that was supposedly surveilled on. Obviously it wasn't that private if school administrators caught wind of it. If you really want a private group, keep it truly private and don't tell anyone about it. The lesson kids should be taking away from this is, don't let your friends drag you into dangerous situations. Harvard is a nationally recognized school, any screw-ups earn national attention. It's very much a "if you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen" sort of situation.
- Houshalter 9y agoI don't see anyone in the comments that genuinely believe what Harvard did was illegal. They have a legal right to do whatever they want (so long as they don't receive any taxpayer money whatsoever, which I'm not sure is true.) But we have a legal right to criticize them for it and be angry at them.
- vinceguidry 9y agoNo, but they are saying that it's a free speech issue. It is a free speech issue, but not in the way they are saying. Your anger is misplaced if it's directed at Harvard.
- metaphorm 9y agowho is "they" and what did "they" say, specifically? can you quote someone? the discussion of speech issues is often about culture and norms rather than about legal statutes.
- hprotagonist 9y agoi watched 5 people fail to matriculate at my alma mater in 2002 for similarly adolescent idiocy. they happened to do it on campus during orientation, but little else seems different.
- losteverything 9y agoWe are expecting children to grow up too fast.
- Finnucane 9y agoHarvard: We can revoke your admission if we see that you are an asshole. Students: Let's be assholes over here in the corner, because stuff is totally private on Facebook. Harvard: You're assholes, and also stupid.
- egwynn 9y agoOne issue is the prevailing idea that all/most online interactions should be shared publicly. It would still have been ill-advised to make these jokes even in private, but I’d go so far as to say there’s a big concrete difference betweeen expressing yourself privately versus publicly. Your friends have a lot of context with which to judge you and your words, but the public doesn’t. You might say something sarcastically or in jest, but someone else might conclude that you believe it earnestly[1]. And if you ARE earnestly expressing yourself and feel like your ideas deserve public platform, then you need to have thought ahead about what kinds of responses you might get. [1] See also Poe’s Law.
- cuck33 9y agoYet another SJW propaganda war against free speech i can't even grasp. Please read abut socialist culture marxism by ex kgb agent: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5It1zarINv0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5It1zarINv0 >Yet another SJW propaganda war against free speech i can't even No one talking about this, freemarket i don't care, BUT we the people have to fight and post "hate speach" edege memes, about niggers, muh 6 millions, lolcaust, feminist totalitarian stte and other. We won't be silenced, by bunch of jews and SJW: 8ch.net/voat.co/tor proud user
- bjl 9y agoHow telling that you created a throwaway to post this.
- cuck33 9y agoi hate usernames, facebook, real name, i believe in merit not a reputation. If i you want to hate/like me based on posts thats ok, but not if you judge me on reputation/points.
- vinceguidry 9y agoChoosing anonymity means that "you" don't exist, only your posts. So we can't like or dislike you, only clean up after you. You're literally a seagull swooping in to shit on everything. Stand behind and take responsibility for your words or nobody is going to take you seriously. Even pseudonymity is better than what you're doing.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't feed trolls.
- dang 9y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14488846 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14488846 and marked it off-topic.
- mgiannopoulos 9y agoDuplicate :) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14485529 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14485529
- LyndsySimon 9y agoThis isn't even really about speech - this is about a few people who exhibited shockingly poor judgement, and were rejected from Harvard as a result.
- creaghpatr 9y agoOn a similar note, it's safe to assume college admissions officers are checking social media profiles, so prospective students should make sure to scrub all high-risk (read: republican) political affiliations and statements from their profile, and maybe pile on some PC-friendly ones.
- bedhead 9y agoThe creepiest part is that Harvard goes all stalker on its admits in the first place. It's creepy AF.
- mschrage 9y agoHere are some examples of the offensive memes: https://thetab.com/us/2017/06/05/harvard-memes-rescinded-69413 https://thetab.com/us/2017/06/05/harvard-memes-rescinded-694...
- stillsut 9y agoInteresting...I'd rate these no more offensive than Sarah Silverman stand up.
- burntrelish1273 9y agoIt sends a message that boundary-free affluenza and bro culture aren't welcome at Harvard. You don't want to enable or embolden 4chan-like behavior from the next supposed batch of leaders.
- stillsut 9y agoInteresting fact: Richard M Stallman dabbles in 9/11 conspiracy theories while being 'employed' at MIT. http://www.stallman.org/articles/911-new-investigation.html http://www.stallman.org/articles/911-new-investigation.html
- googletazer 9y agoUSSR style censorship when you can't even crack a joke in private. As for Harvard admitting people of high moral character, being of high moral character meant completely opposite things 50 years ago and now.