5 ms·
Not wanting Ads I can understand - you've paid for Windows (and in some cases Surface hardware) and you don't want to be the product - but why do you dislike te
by nailer 9y ago
Not wanting Ads I can understand - you've paid for Windows (and in some cases Surface hardware) and you don't want to be the product - but why do you dislike telemetry? I'd rather Microsoft know what crashes the OS (and why apps die) in the real world and fix it.
- userbinator 9y agoDo you want potentially sensitive information leaving your machine? That's basically the counterargument. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Error_Reporting#Privacy_concerns_and_use_by_the_NSA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Error_Reporting#Privac...
- 8draco8 9y agoMaybe they should go back to good old days of Windows XP when they've asked if I want to send them crash report.
- v4n4d1s 9y agoThere are two main arguments: - You can't disable telemetry completey. Some people want it, some don't. Let the user decide. - Microsoft does collect an insane amount of data. https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/configuration/basic-level-windows-diagnostic-events-and-fields https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/configuration/basic...
- rileymat2 9y ago> You can't disable telemetry completey. Some people want it, some don't. Let the user decide. I would be curious how many users want telemetry sent to Microsoft. It seems the two largest buckets, by far, would be those who don't care and those who don't want it.
- basch 9y agoI want your (all yalls) telemetry data sent to Microsoft, so my Windows crashes less. As an aggregate, the worlds telemetry data has an extremely positive impact on me. The problem with opt in is that most people, where most crashes occur, would never read what the prompt says asking them to send the data, they would just press the x in the corner because a dialog box popped up they didnt ask for. "What did that box say. I dont know. Why did you close it. Because I didnt want it."
- AlexandrB 9y ago> The problem with opt in is that most people, where most crashes occur, would never read what the prompt says asking them to send the data, they would just press the x in the corner because a dialog box popped up they didnt ask for. "What did that box say. I dont know. Why did you close it. Because I didnt want it." You're describing a UX issue with the worst possible way this could be implemented. What chafes me is not that I'm not asked for permission for every crash report, but that I don't have the option to disable crash reports at all.
- type0 9y agoSo would pressing the x mean that the user agreed to this? If it's unclear, I'm drawing that conclusion from all those Windows 10 upgrades where that were the case.
- basch 9y agomaybe if the buttons said "Contribute Nothing" and "Do the Right Thing"
- alxmdev 9y ago> "What did that box say. I dont know. Why did you close it. Because I didnt want it." That's right, because all these unsolicited prompts and notifications are a waste of people's valuable time. A well-designed OS should aggressively keep quiet, stay out of the way, and err on the side of user privacy. Your Windows crashing is an issue strictly between you, Microsoft, and the makers of whatever software and hardware you were using when the crash occurred. Absolutely nothing to do with anybody else.
- khedoros1 9y ago> I want your (all yalls) telemetry data sent to Microsoft, so my Windows crashes less. I want your data sent to Microsoft too, for the same reason. I don't want my data sent to Microsoft, though.
- pmlnr 9y agoThere is nothing wrong with telemetry - if it's opt-in. That's all.
- eddieroger 9y agoThat's exactly right - I'm happy to let my OS provider know when things break with the hopes that they fix them, but sometimes I don't want to do that, and I'd rather be asked every time or have a global setting to decide than be defaulted to opt-in.
- edraferi 9y agoI think it needs to be opt out. Most users AREN'T power users. They want their computer to work consistently, like an appliance. That requires that the vendor has information about the status of the device. As long as you're clearly informed about what kind of information it's collecting and you can turn it off (and ideally tune it) it's fine with me. The opt in piece is important because you need large amounts of data to detect emerging issues. It lets you distinguish between flukes and trends. This enables the quality of service that the user expects.
- skummetmaelk 9y agoWhy does working consistently like an appliance require the OS provider to know the state of your device at all times? Our appliances have functioned well for decades without this capability and clearly don't need this senseless data collection for the sake of data hoarding. Yet every manufacturer of every product is jamming it in wherever they can. Fridges, cars, dildos, you name it, it's got telemetry or people trying to implement it. It is simple, data is becoming worth something because you now have the ability to analyze all the data you could ever collect. And so, everybody naturally jumps on the wagon because of the inherent profit motive. If a computer was an appliance, you would buy it and it would never need to phone home. Now we both know that there is some need for updates and it might therefore be a good idea to classify computers as something other than appliances.
- drdaeman 9y agoBecause telemetry is potentially not only the core dumps and performance metrics, but also all sorts of potentially sensitive information - like a data derived from the user input (keyboard , voice or pen - this data is said to be anonymized but AFAIK no one had audited this) or list of installed applications. Knowing that something is crashing or performing badly is one thing, knowing what I'm doing with my computer is another. Telemetry can be done right by letting end-user to see an example of the data that's going to be sent and then also audit the actual reports that were sent. Transcribed into a human-readable format with some comments about what the values mean - I can see the binary data myself, thanks. And a way to opt out if the data is found to be actually sensitive. Basically, an opt-out switch and "sure, but give me a full transparency report" mode that a "power user" can optionally access if they happen to care. This is rarely the case, and not the case with Windows.
- rincebrain 9y agoWhile I am (probably) just as against this kind of opaque bulk data aggregation, there is an argument to be made that they could be analyzing the data you provide on their end and storing the result (e.g. "how many users did X" is not a question you could anonymize on the end user machine, but they still might discard anything other than perhaps a hash to prevent duplicates, and thereby not be able to answer the question of who said what later.) I agree with the desire for complete transparency in data shared, but eventually this will run afoul of a number of practices which rely on cat-and-mouse games where one side doesn't have complete information (an obvious example being precisely what sorts of data Windows Defender uses/sends for malware found by heuristic, presuming it doesn't just ship the entire binary off), to say nothing of the conspiracy theories that would arise every time they ever added some kind of data collection. I don't have a good answer for this friction in general - complete transparency would only fly until a piece of malware that circumvented every heuristic and strict rule caused a major incident, whereas nearly complete opacity is where we are now. (There's also the conflict of their lack of recurring revenue for Windows 10, which is why I'd anticipate them eventually at least floating the option to disable the "end user data as payment" harvesting for an annual fee, but...)
- 9y ago
- kabdib 9y agoTelemetry is this close to being apparatus for spying; a court order (secret or otherwise) could strip whatever anonymization MS is doing, say, for specific IPs or even whole regions by geography. Poof: keystrokes in real-time, available to state actors. Wouldn't that be grand? Developed capacity may not equal intent, but if you can be ordered to do secret work and make it so anyway, the distinction is irrelevant.
- jayd16 9y agoIf a court order could do that, why do you think they couldn't just enable it remotely too?
- cuckcuckspruce 9y agoWhich is why, if you really care about privacy, you can't trust software you can't audit.
- kabdib 9y agoThey could, but it would be possible for you to notice, by looking at network traffic.