3 ms·
I am wondering why for factual statements like X is Y that are provable as false can't the entity damaged by the publication ask for a retraction and/or damages
by simion314 9y ago
I am wondering why for factual statements like X is Y that are provable as false can't the entity damaged by the publication ask for a retraction and/or damages ? As a person if you denigrate other person you are in trouble.
- chasing 9y ago"A lie can travel half way around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes." -Mark Twain
- goodmachine 9y ago"Falsehood flies, and truth comes limping after" - Jonathon Swift http://www.bartleby.com/209/633.html http://www.bartleby.com/209/633.html
- teddyh 9y agohttp://quoteinvestigator.com/2014/07/13/truth/ http://quoteinvestigator.com/2014/07/13/truth/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- blowski 9y agoDaily Mail and its ilk often write statements like "Twitter users were outraged after reports that Mr Celebrity X shoved a hamster up his arse". They don't say Mr Celebrity X actually did it, just that Twitter users were outraged over reports that he had done so. I'm sure there's a legal distinction in there that means they're still in the wrong, but I don't know how the consequences differ.
- michaelt 9y agoMechanisms exist - they just don't work. For one thing, you can convert any false story into a not-provably-false story by appending 'a twitterstorm has erupted over' or 'a highly placed anonymous source has claimed' You can also host false info with impunity by allowing user-submitted content, and ensuring users can recreate deleted content faster than you respond to complaints. Another option is to run a story 'giving both sides of the controversy' but giving the false info 95% of the airtime. Yet another is to simply not run stories on up-to-date facts you don't like, in favour of restating old-but-true stories that fit the narrative you prefer. For another thing, even if a story is provably false, forcing someone unwilling to retract or pay damages can be extremely time-consuming. Court cases can go on for weeks and months; the stories about Clapper the article mentions have most of their impact while they're only a few hours old. For another, thanks to the Streisand effect, if Joe sues Newsco over their false claim that X, he can look forward to several months of stories about "Joe sues Newsco over X claims" I'm not sure there are any easy solutions here - ain't many people going to be coming out in support of making it easier for politicians to muzzle the press.
- rsynnott 9y agoThe classic tabloid approach is, blatant lie on the front page, followed by small print retraction a week later on page 17. That's assuming that someone is libelled; a lot of media lying doesn't libel anyone. For instance, "no evidence of global warming" is obviously a lie, but no one is libelled. Some media (many British tabloids, for instance) essentially considers being sued for libel part of the cost of doing business; they make more money lying than they're forced to pay out over lies.