7 ms·
One Bit Ferrite Core Memory
- RugnirViking 9y agoI really like these kinds of practical demonstrations of how technology worked. Its such a shame that an up-to-date version could need scanning microscopes to see visually
- 13of40 9y agoI've never seen "live" core memory. Anyone know how it stands up to physical shock? For example, if someone accidentally bumped the rack, could it cause some of the bits to flip?
- PopePompous 9y agoI used core memory in machines during the 1970s (primarily Data General Novas). There was no problem with physical shock, but we did get errors during strong thunderstorms. Back then, when I was in highschool, I was told that the density of core memory was limited by the dexterity of the Filipina workers who threaded the wires through the tiny magnetic donuts.
- VLM 9y agoFor some engineering scaling reasons small things tend to be pretty tough in proportion to their size; supposedly the core arrays in the space shuttle Challenger survived ocean impact and were readable once recovered. core was relatively sensitive to temperature and the currents had to be varied to match the temp for optimum performance. Which can be worked around as OP did by not optimizing for minimum power or minimum error rate. Also the more cores the sense wire ran thru the more temperature sensitive the core became.
- flavio81 9y agoThe value is stored magnetically, so physical shock is not a problem, but other environmental conditions might be a problem.
- cr0sh 9y agoActually, some of the later versions of core memory were very difficult to see with a "naked eye"; almost grains-of-sand kind of thing. I own a couple of examples of core memory; one is a very old core assembly (I swear the frame is made of bakelite). It's highly damaged, missing several frames, and some of the existing "outside" frame have damage (but the inner frames are "ok"). Those cores are readily visible, and each measure a few millimeters in diameter (the wires of the grids are very thin magnet wire). There are around 10 or so layers in this core assembly (and I'm not sure how many were originally there). My other core assembly is a 16K board for some kind of a minicomputer or mainframe, made in the early 1970s. It even has a few surface mount components on it, plenty of thru-hole components, a few ICs (mainly line drivers), and the core memory module (which is actually protected by a metal cover - I've never opened it, so I don't know what it looks like underneath). My wife and I have it hanging in our dining area, next to our periodic table, stirling engine, and Tesla coil (yep). The whole board measures about 16 x 16 inches, and includes some metal frame stiffeners soldered on as well. The actual core assembly measures about 6 x 6 inches. In either of these, physical shock wouldn't do much (other things would break long before the core assemblies). That said, in actual construction they were typically protected in some manner; either in a case of some sort (in the case of the larger unit I have) or behind a metal plate (as in the board I have). This was mainly done to prevent fingers from poking where they shouldn't go (as well as prevent issues with tool slippage or dropping).
- sengork 9y agoI know that this is entirely off-topic but I wish Google made their services a lot more visible than they are. For example I completely forgot about sites.google.com until I saw this link and the service has been there since ~2009.
- meowpants 9y agohttps://www.google.com/intl/en/about/products/ https://www.google.com/intl/en/about/products/
- kwhitefoot 9y agoBrilliant work!
- owenversteeg 9y agoThis is pretty cool by itself of course. But I'm wondering, is there any reason at all to use core memory today? I know EMP/disaster resistance has been said in the past, but a small modern durable chip encased in a bunch of protection should work better right?
- moftz 9y agoThere are plenty of rad hard memory solutions out there that have modern interfaces and take up no space relative to the size of core memory. Core memory is a thing of the past and shouldn't ever really be part of anyone's modern designs. You can get rad hard RAM, EEPROM, and NV Flash today for space and military applications, for a price [1]. If you want disaster-proof offline backup, a below ground water-proof storage locker bolted to the foundation with a faraday cage inside is more than enough. Dig deeper if you want it to survive a nuke. [1] http://www.3d-plus.com/product.php?fam=8 http://www.3d-plus.com/product.php?fam=8
- VLM 9y agoThe only competitor core has for eternally non-volatile low tech near radiation proof infinitely rewritable electrical data storage is latching relays and each bit of latching relay is huge in comparison to core. Also latching relays unlike core has moving parts that will eventually wear out. A million cycles sounds like a long time for a latching relay to live, but as a register or memory for a computer at 0.1 Hz thats only two months or so. So if you want to use latching relays you're limited to applications where the system will never perform more than a couple hundred thousand bit flips. The marketplace for eternally non-volatile low tech near radiation proof no moving parts infinitely rewritable data storage is roughly nil, unfortunately. Maybe a space probe to the worst parts of Jupiter or as part of a nuclear missile warhead. "In the old days" they had to make the ferrite cores, then characterize them, then wrap them into memory units by hand, but I would imagine given enough money one could find a way to 3-d print cores around taut stainless steel wires then fire the core ceramic, automating the process. Given a very large budget of course. Its probably cheaper in practice to ship very large amounts of flash wrapped in lead shielding.
- 9y ago
- flavio81 9y agoObligatory quote from "Real Programmers Don't Use Pascal": Your typical Real Programmer knew the entire bootstrap loader by memory in hex, and toggled it in whenever it got destroyed by his program. (Back then, memory was memory -- it didn't go away when the power went off. Today, memory either forgets things when you don't want it to, or remembers things long after they're better forgotten.) http://web.mit.edu/humor/Computers/real.programmers http://web.mit.edu/humor/Computers/real.programmers
- Fjolsvith 9y agoI used to be an electronic technician (305x4) in the Air Force and spent 3 years on one of the old 490L Overseas AutoVon phone switches right before the DOD phased them out in 1987. This telephone system originally had a ferrite core memory and it was NOT non-volatile. Every few milliseconds the system had to run through each bit reading them and then re-setting them, as the magnetic field collapsed over time. The system used 50 volts.