5 ms·
> Rather than talking of an open architecture, we might do better to talk of a modular architecture. The IBM would be a sort of computer erector set, a set of
by walterbell 9y ago
> Rather than talking of an open architecture, we might do better to talk of a modular architecture. The IBM would be a sort of computer erector set, a set of interchangeable components that the purchaser could snap together in whatever combination suited her needs and her pocketbook.
Has this been achieved with software components in any niche? Other than early IETF protocols, software mutation tends to challenge interoperability. Containers are making progress in this direction.
On the hardware front, http://www.opencompute.org http://www.opencompute.org has increased choices for those who can buy servers in large quantity. But small business has less choice these days. Even Dell, pioneer of build-to-order PCs, now favors pre-configured PCs.
On a positive note, it is now possible to buy some PCs without a Windows tax. Dell offers Linux and HP offers Linux/FreeDOS on select models. Is there room for PC OEM/ODMs to innovate in (free, non-bloatware) software components to increase the value of their mix-and-match hardware components?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- badsectoracula 9y ago> Has this been achieved with software components in any niche? Isn't this what "programs" and "files" do? There used to be a time when computers were really one (or few) trick machines but since the time when anyone could install any program on their computer and have programs work with any file (regardless of which program originally made it), software on the whole is as modular (if not more modular) as hardware. (which is also why i dislike the trend that iOS created with software being isolated both in terms of execution and file access, except a few preapproved holes here and there)
- digi_owl 9y agoUnix style pipes as well. Frankly all that is needed is a defined IPC protocol that the market sticks to. But sadly that has been an hard sell when devs see such protocols more like a ball and chain.
- jacquesm 9y ago> Frankly all that is needed is a defined IPC protocol that the market sticks to. We had one, and then we botched it. So now we went from HTML->HTML+JS->JS->webassembly. These are all steps back, not forward, soon we'll be simply using HTTP to ship application binaries that you no longer have any rights at all to, it is in many ways a situation worse than the one where everybody bought shrink wrapped software.
- pjmlp 9y agoAnd it will be coded everything in free software, hidden away behind server virtual walls, without a dime or any kind of compensation being given back to the original developers.
- jacquesm 9y ago> There used to be a time when computers were really one (or few) trick machines You mean the time when programming was done with plug boards? Computers have been more or less universal since the time RAM was used to execute the programs, the fact that files are a convenient way to organize data does noes not detract from the fact that the internal structure of a file needs to be known if you want another program to make sense out of it. In that sense the text file is the most enabling element here, and binary files with unknown structure the least. The ability to quickly load a program quickly (rather than to load it in through elaborate means such as plugboards, switches, punched cards, paper tape or magnetic reel-to-reel tape) definitely has had a lot of effect on the universal application of computers but that doesn't mean they weren't universal machines. And even in the time of plug boards there were tricks that would keep multiple programs active by means of switching out an entire bank or segment of configured boards for another. Software is as modular as the hardware it runs on permits, but it can also very effectively restrict or expand that modularity, a nice example of this is virtual machines which present a machine entirely different than the one that the original hardware embodies.
- laumars 9y ago> Computers have been more or less universal since the time RAM was used to execute the programs, the fact that files are a convenient way to organize data does noes not detract from the fact that the internal structure of a file needs to be known if you want another program to make sense out of it. > In that sense the text file is the most enabling element here, and binary files with unknown structure the least. text files haven't always been universal. There used to be different text encodings (ASCII hasn't always been universal) and even different sizes of byte (eg some systems would have 6 or 7 bits to a byte). And even if two machines you're wanting to share data between were both an 8bit ASCII system; there's no guarantee that they would share the same dialect of BASIC, LISP, Pascal or C.
- jacquesm 9y agoASCII isn't universal even today (the page you are reading is UNICODE), but all text was much more readable and in general easier to process with ad-hoc filtering or other manipulation than binary formats. This is what underpins most of the power of UNIX, but at the same time is something of a weak point: good and error free text processing is actually quite hard.
- lmm 9y ago> (which is also why i dislike the trend that iOS created with software being isolated both in terms of execution and file access, except a few preapproved holes here and there) It seems to be the way consumer software is going though. It's a bizarre truism that we still aren't very good at sending files from one computer to another, even as we've got a lot better at specific cases like sharing photos or collaboratively editing documents. Maybe the lowest-common-denominator file model isn't good enough?
- digi_owl 9y agoIn large part because we can't dial a computer like we dial a phone. This in part because everything consumer is sitting behind a NAT to try to stretch IPv4 as far as possible.
- organsnyder 9y agoOn the software side, I'd argue that a SOA/microservice model accomplishes this: boundaries between services are defined by APIs based on open protocols and formats (HTTP, JSON, XML, graphQL...); new functionality can be achieved by writing a new microservice that mixes and matches functionality from existing services. Regarding hardware: There are still plenty of companies selling build-to-order PCs, and sourcing parts is extremely easy. In fact, I'd argue that in some segments (such as gaming), DIY builds are much more common than they were 20 years ago. Of course, these machines aren't truly "open" for every definition of the word, but that has never been the case for the modern PC market.
- douche 9y agoIt's probably easier today to buy a bunch of components and snap them together to build a desktop tower than it is to put together an erector set. If I recall, the trickiest part of the whole process was putting the right amount of thermal paste on the CPU before attaching the cooler. Software, unfortunately seems to be going hard in the other direction. Half the time I can't even get copy/paste to work between apps on my smartphone. Just think of all the trillions of dollars that have been spent over the years trying to glue together different enterprise systems into Dr Moreauvian monstrosities.
- bluedino 9y ago>> It's probably easier today to buy a bunch of components and snap them together to build a desktop tower than it is to put together an erector set. You don't even need many components these days. Right now you can put a PC together with: Motherboard CPU RAM HDD/SSD Power supply In the old days you needed these additional parts: Video card Sound card Disk controller card Printer card Serial card Hard disk drive Floppy disk drive
- Zardoz84 9y agoAnd dot forget to set the jumpers and config the BIOS settings of the hard disk!