4 ms·
No. Their goal is simply to go back to the previous status quo. Which was when communication was capable of being monitored when there was a reasonable suspicio
by threeseed 9y ago
No. Their goal is simply to go back to the previous status quo. Which was when communication was capable of being monitored when there was a reasonable suspicion of a crime about to be committed.
Now I don't believe this makes any sense in this era (criminals will have crypto, ordinary people/dissidents/journalists etc will not) but I can very much appreciate where they are coming from. It's not a simple issue.
- chillwaves 9y agoThat's not an honest representation of the argument given there is no parallel you can make between today's world of electronic communication passing over centralized infrastructure to however people communicated before. There was no ability for the government to read everyone's (or anyone's) mail at once in the past.
- threeseed 9y agoIntelligence services absolutely had the ability to read people's postal mail and intercept their phone calls. For example, the CIA in a declassified report from 1976 opened over 215,000 physical letters: https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/document/0001420864 https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/document/0001420864
- andy_ppp 9y agoI guess that's a very small sample. We are talking about them making copies of every letter ever sent...
- shusson 9y agoWhat about telephone wire tapping? e.g https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Assistance_for_Law_Enforcement_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Assistance_for_...
- izacus 9y agoThere is a huge difference in scale. Phone wiretapping required explicit targeting and was not possible at scale modern measures allow.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoThank you for pointing this out. It's a key point to make that it's kind of a complex issue. It's obvious to me that cryptography shouldn't and realistically cannot be outlawed. That doesn't make any sense. On the flip side, I think that most people would accept that targeted surveillance of criminal suspects is a reasonable tool. The thing is, if it becomes the default for all messages to be encrypted end-to-end – obviously a good thing – then this effective tool becomes useless. I think any proposals to restrict cryptographic software are obviously wrong and doomed to failure, and I will continue using such software regardless of what laws are passed in the UK. But it is a complex issue, and I wish there was some more acknowledgement of how the field of surveillance has changed.
- sbov 9y agoIs it complex? Even with crypto authorities have more ability to surveil us than any other time in human history. Crypto seems like a very small loss when looking at the way things have trended the last 10 years, much less 100.
- ianopolous 9y agoEven with end to end encryption they can still hack any current OS. We're a long way from having provably secure operating systems for current devices.
- subway 9y agoprovably secure? I'd almost settle for theoretically secure these days.
- confounded 9y agoThe Manchester attacker was reported many times as an extremist, and had the ISIS flag on his car. To suggest that he would have been caught if only the Food Standards Authority has constant read-access to your drunk teenage loveletters is ridiculous. We need more actual police officers to do more actual police work.
- 9y ago
- tempodox 9y agoDoes that mean you open people's letters to make sure they don't commit a crime?
- brians 9y agoYes. The overt statements of HMG say they want warrants and court orders and individual targeting, not kibozing or grepping the gmail spool.
- Symbiote 9y agoThey already grep phone conversations and SMS messages, and whatever Internet traffic they can. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempora https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempora
- rimliu 9y ago> capable of being monitored when there was a reasonable > suspicion of a crime about to be committed. The thing is: they knew about the Manchester attacker, and today on BBC was also a report that law enforcement was informed about one of the London attackers. If they cannot act on the intelligence they already have what's the point of diluting it with even more data?
- type0 9y ago> criminals will have crypto, ordinary people/dissidents/journalists etc will not Does is imply that politicians will have crypto?
- thriftwy 9y agoYou can't go back to the previous status quo any more than you can ask your mother to "bear you back" because you don't like living outside. Trying to pretend you can is one of the most dangerous things a politician can ever do.
- Quarrelsome 9y agoyea, its a rejection (a lack of understanding) of the technology of internet. It clearly states in their manifesto that they want to treat the internet the same as the physical world without appreciating that this is impossible. I look forward to whenever politicians work out that people not under their legal jurisdiction can muck about on their internet thereby making their intent of constraint irrelevant.