2 ms·
My understanding is that the point of US nuclear submarines is strategic, rather than tactical. They aren't there to be "soldiers" in the naval theatre; they're
by derefr 9y ago
My understanding is that the point of US nuclear submarines is strategic, rather than tactical. They aren't there to be "soldiers" in the naval theatre; they're there to be
1. hidden CIC nodes the enemy doesn't know to attack;
2. unpredictably-roving nuclear ICBM launch platforms which no amount of reconnaissance can paint as targets for pre-emptive strikes;
3. "sleeper agents" that can just enter a projected battlespace (e.g. foreign coastal waters) carrying medium-range missiles for quick engagement, then sit around for months in case said battlespace goes active, ready to throw those missiles out at a moment's notice.
#1 can be achieved by short-submersion vessels. #2 can, theoretically, as well, but it's much more costly (more boats in shorter shifts) and less effective because change-outs are the weak link for discovery and predictability. But #3 just can't work for non-nuclear AIPs—and it's one of the major keys to strategic deterrence.
- gozur88 9y agoYour #3 isn't completely accurate. Nuclear attack submarines have a primary tactical role in that they're expected to destroy enemy ships and submarines with torpedoes. In peacetime they spend a lot of time shadowing vessels belonging to other countries collecting emissions and position data. And the land attack role isn't really about deterrence - that's what the boomers are for. Though I agree if you want to operate subs in far-flung seas you pretty much have to go with nuclear propulsion. Diesel subs (of which AIP are just the latest iteration) just don't have the legs. They're also not magical, as some people seem to think. You can detect them.