18 ms·
UK PM wants to ban crypto: here's what it would cost, and why it won't work anyway
- dTal 9y ago>there's no back door that only lets good guys go through it. Much as I agree with the general principle, this argument is flawed (except insofar as 'good guys' do not remain 'good'). What exactly is a crypto key, if not a "back door that only lets X go through it"?
- beojan 9y agoEvery single implementation of cryptography would be required to encrypt the message both with the original key and separately with the government master key, and store / transmit both. The master key suddenly becomes very valuable, and the incentive to crack it is enormous. In addition, there would be an enormous amount of ciphertext available that's encrypted with that key, and it would likely be shared widely across government. Also, wouldn't this require severely limiting the number of permitted encryption algorithms?
- dTal 9y agoA clever system would easily mitigate your first point, probably with some sort of rolling key + key hierarchy (much like SSL and certificate authorities). As to your second point, yes. It would require severely limiting a great deal of things. Consider that "impossible" at your peril.
- zxcmx 9y agoI think what gets missed is that communcations interceptors are an entire platform (not just a key somewhere). There are lots of computers glommed onto the network to make the capability happen and humans to manage them. The hard part is managing keys, access, storage, networking etc. The security on a lot of "lawful access" systems for cell networks is not as great as one would hope, and the LI system is sometimes the goal of attackers in a telco. Just the capability (click n clone or tap to disk) is dangerous even when turned off. Of course, no one actually makes a telephony system without LI...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- BrandonMarc 9y agoTypical politician: never waste a crisis. Oh, was there an attack? Okay, let's cram through some wholly-unrelated policy change that we couldn't normally get away with. Simultaneously, let's completely ignore anything related to the actual attackers.
- nickbauman 9y agoI'd give her a chance to retract this anyway, but otherwise PM May has revealed that she is either a fool or an autocrat. Either should get her voted out of office.
- robotmay 9y agoShe has been after this for years, there's absolutely no chance of her retracting it, unfortunately :(
- Latty 9y agoUnfortunately, the public doesn't understand this. They just hear someone is "fighting the terrorists" and don't care the policy is insane.
- taobility 9y agoActually the normal care more about the safety than what you said privacy. You can choose what you called freedom and privacy, but I also have the right to choose safety. Why you would say your choice is prior than my choice?
- jodrellblank 9y agoBecause choosing privacy gets privacy, but choosing safety by handing over the keys to your life to other people, strangers, working for their own interests, for commercial interests, for power and money, does not get you safety. Because an individual choosing privacy implicitly chooses privacy for everyone, but an individual choosing 'safety' (in this context) implicitly chooses no privacy for everyone else, and implicitly unsafety for people who needed that privacy while not actually doing anything illegal. (Or maybe doing something technically illegal but still just or reasonable or morally right). It's an "I have nothing to hide, so you cannot hide anything", "I'm alright jack", "everyone should trust the people I trust because I agree with them" approach.
- k-mcgrady 9y agoThe 'safety' choice is misinformed. People have allowed what they see in the media and what politicians are saying to cause them fear - fear which is completely irrational. I noticed this during the Question Time debates in the UK the other night where Jeremy Corbyn was hounded on nuclear weapons. Some people in that audience seriously believe we are on the brink of nuclear war and want someone in charge who has no issues dropping nukes on other people. I was pissed off watching it until I realised they genuinely seem scared. But their is almost no rational behind that other than things they've heard on the news. The terror attacks in the UK in the last 3 months have been devastating - but the number of deaths and even the number of injuries needs to be kept in perspective when choosing to give up rights as important as privacy. One choice is informed by logic and reason, the other by exaggeration and lies.
- pmoriarty 9y agoOne word: Steganography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steganography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steganography
- firethief 9y agoI don't see how that applies. Steganography cannot be used to hide encryption on a large scale because all steganography techniques depend either on the obscurity of the technique or on disguising encrypted data as other opaque encrypted data. You couldn't e.g. use steganography to hide that you're accessing a website via TLS because the client needs to know how to communicate with the server, and there's no way to make that possible for arbitrary citizens but not for government agents.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gaius 9y agoThink of something you don't do yourself, but would like to see banned. Could be guns, drugs, fox hunting, cars, eating meat, religion, anything, it doesn't matter. Now consider there are people who feel exactly the same about your thing as you do about theirs. Civilisation absolutely requires that for them to leave you alone, you must be willing to do the same.
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoThis reduces to "no-one should restrict the right of anyone to do anything". Why draw the line where you've done? Why shouldn't we also allow explicit torture of animals? Why shouldn't we legalize the making of death threats? Etc.
- CamperBob2 9y agoA good place to draw the line is one that places responsibility on the tool-wielders, and not on the mere existence or possession of the tools themselves. Many of us object to gun control on that basis, and the same reasoning can be applied to encryption. In fact, there's really not a lot you can say about one that you can't say about the other. No private citizen "needs" access to encryption so strong that even intelligence agencies can't break it, any more than any private citizen "needs" to own a weapon whose only purpose is killing. Right?
- yomly 9y agoI can see your point, but I think you are glossing over nuance that is specific to tech. The Internet is pervasive and technology is ubiquitous. With a single gun, a man can only kill as many people as he can see with the number of bullets on his person. With a computer and a connection to the internet, his reach and potential scale is much greater. That is why such powerful encryption is required for your average citizen.
- CamperBob2 9y agoWith a computer and a connection to the internet, his reach and potential scale is much greater. That is why such powerful encryption is required for your average citizen. I wonder if the encryption dilemma will ultimately be resolved with blockchain-like techniques. Cryptocurrencies work because their underlying trust processes are deliberately designed to require ever-increasing amounts of CPU time. They can be attacked, but only by spending enough resources to out-mine the other nodes. While possible in theory, it's simply not worthwhile for an attacker to marshal the kinds of resources that would be required to attack Bitcoin or similar blockchains. So, while back doors for government access are stupid and unworkable for all of the reasons that people have stated, what about requiring a hypothetical encryption standard with no known backdoors or attack surfaces, but that is just strong enough to be broken by agencies like the GCHQ or NSA who can throw gigawatt-hours of computer time at the problem? Basically, if the government really wants to read my mail, they can, but it will cost them. It might take them hours to discover a given key, while nobody with a room full of GPUs or even a botnet could do it in less than several years. In such a scenario, we'd be sufficiently safe from attack by cybercriminals, and most of the time, from our governments as well. Governments would still be able to target anybody, but unlike the case where a back door is mandated, they wouldn't be able to target everybody. That could limit the amount of harm that bad actors in the government could do. It would be similar to the rationale of banning ownership of high-capacity magazines, except unlike that sort of feel-good measure, it might actually work.
- firethief 9y ago> Theresa May says there should be no "means of communication" which "we cannot read" The article focuses largely on the technical difficulties and implementation risks that make this goal impractical. I would like to point out that the goal in question is explicitly Orwell-style surveillance.
- theossuary 9y agoThat seems to have been the UK's goal for a while now
- threeseed 9y agoNo. Their goal is simply to go back to the previous status quo. Which was when communication was capable of being monitored when there was a reasonable suspicion of a crime about to be committed. Now I don't believe this makes any sense in this era (criminals will have crypto, ordinary people/dissidents/journalists etc will not) but I can very much appreciate where they are coming from. It's not a simple issue.
- chillwaves 9y agoThat's not an honest representation of the argument given there is no parallel you can make between today's world of electronic communication passing over centralized infrastructure to however people communicated before. There was no ability for the government to read everyone's (or anyone's) mail at once in the past.
- threeseed 9y agoIntelligence services absolutely had the ability to read people's postal mail and intercept their phone calls. For example, the CIA in a declassified report from 1976 opened over 215,000 physical letters: https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/document/0001420864 https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/document/0001420864
- andy_ppp 9y ago
- jimnotgym 9y agoThis is a good primer on the technical side of this madness. It is quite accessible and therefore a good one to share with people who don't yet realize that what May is trying to do will mean the end of the internet and tech industry in the UK.
- jimnotgym 9y agoLots of discussion earlier here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14480758 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14480758
- cJ0th 9y agoThe list which the author introduces with the words "This, then, is what Theresa May is proposing:" sounds mad to anyone who knows anything about cryptography but they (Theresa May doesn't differ much from her western colleagues here!) really mean it! So even though they will not be able to fully succeed in reaching their goal, they are going to make our digital lives very, very miserable if we don't find a way to short-circuit such insane plans asap!
- IvanK_net 9y agoIf I had to explain the basics of "information" and "communication" to average people, I would say something like this. There is no difference in the communication over the internet, over the letter mail, or verbal communication with voice. The encryption can be used in any form of communication. And the problem of banning it is always the same. Banning the encryption is impossible simply because detecting the encryption is impossible. When you see two persons on the street, one says that the weather is nice, and the other responds that the grass is green, you can never know if there is some hidden message in their communication. Encrypted information can always be "tunneled" through unencrypted channels. Even if you ban all computer apps with encryption, you ban people from making own apps, make every person wear a microphone and a camera 24/7, there will always be a way to deliver information from one person to another without anybody else knowing about it. Actually, banning encryption apps may be good for privacy, because you never know if the app maker made some backdoors in their encryption method and he already sells your information to somebody.
- 6Typos 9y ago>Actually, banning encryption apps may be good for privacy, because you never know if the app maker made some backdoors in their encryption method and he already sells your information to somebody. IMHO, the answer to this lies in Open Source + reproducible builds/compilation. Not in banning/not using apps that promise privacy. If what you're trying to achieve is awareness about the possible false sense of security (when not appropriate), then the answer is educating people about it. EDIT: Typos/Grammar.
- age_bronze 9y agoThis propaganda about good guys backdoors being impossible again. This is cryptographic bullshit of the highest degree. We've had the DUAL_EC scandal, for once, as an example of NSA backdoor which as far as was proved, only the NSA could crack. And with the fact that the NSA had so many bad leaks, yet still everyone except the NSA can't crack it, proved that backdoors are not only possible, but were going on behind our backs. Don't get me wrong - I'm completely against backdoors. But when you shift the argument into "we won't do it because it's impossible", you're already agreeing that it should be done, while your argument won't hold because it is in fact possible. There's three kinds of people: 1. Non-technical people (theresea may) that want backdoors are don't care about whether it's possible or not. 2. Technical users, with a vague general knowledge of cryptography, and the imprinted thumb rule of "backdoors are bad" 3. People with actual knowledge in cryptography which had already been doing research about why it is possible for years. Just a teaser: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kleptography https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kleptography Of course, the real issue would be the scale and the distribution of access to the backdoor to various agencies.
- dTal 9y agoI just posted a similar, if much less comprehensive comment. I'm troubled you've been downvoted for this. Your second point in particular is highly significant. In general, "it's impossible" should be avoided as an argument when one's true objections are ethical. You don't want to be left standing naked because of some clever engineering.
- jimnotgym 9y agoIt depends what you mean by "it's impossible" when you are discussing 'good-guy backdoors'. I don't think the article was saying its impossible just because it is technologically hard. The article discussed at length that what was impossible is that the keys would be guaranteed to stay in the hands of good guys, and that the good-guys would always be good. I think it is perfectly reasonable to say that that is impossible.
- martindevans 9y agoI couldn't agree more. Saying that it's impossible to backdoor encryption in a "secure" (so long as you trust the government holding the 3rd key) is a very dangerous stance to take. It just sends this message to people who might campaign against backdoors that we don't need to bother - after all it's impossible.
- brian-armstrong 9y agoYou can hide meaning in plain English just by making it hard to read your intentions or the context that the sentence is given in. Take double entendres for example. Should we ban any grammatical construction that could possibly hide some second meaning?
- dTal 9y agoIt won't be necessary to ban ambiguity directly - the effect will be accomplished by harshly policing any problematic potential hidden meaning as "subversive" or "hate speech". It will then be wiser to avoid such constructions. Of course it raises the question of what constitutes forbidden speech. To answer that I would look towards the opinions you are already frightened to voice publicly.
- ue_ 9y agoIsn't hate speech more of a different matter? I can't really see how it relates except under the umbrella of restricting speech, and I'd argue that there are various good reasons for restricting some speech, for example assault and shouting 'fire' in a crowded theatre.
- schoen 9y agoI'd like to encourage people who mention the "shouting 'fire'" thing to have a look at Ken White's comments on this: https://www.popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-hackneyed-apologia-for-censorship-are-enough/ https://www.popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-ha... (brief excerpt from a much longer piece: "Holmes' famous quote comes in the context of a series of early 1919 Supreme Court decisions in which he endorsed government censorship of wartime dissent — dissent that is now clearly protected by subsequent First Amendment authority. The three cases in question arose from socialist criticism of conscription during World War One. The criticism at issue, to modern tastes, was a clearly protected and rather mild expression of opinion.")
- avaer 9y agoNon-technical person's reply: Don't be silly! I understand the interpretation of information in a conversation; if someone were doing this I could tell. But I don't understand cryptography mathematical mumbo-jumbo. Therefore these two situations are nothing alike. Let's ban crypto.
- stesch 9y agoFur fubhyq ona greebevfz.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- joshpadnick 9y agoI'm also deeply concerned about "backdoors for the good guys". Beyond just worrying about who else could get access, the "good guys" really just means government, and my comfort level with the current Trump administration using their "good guy" backdoor for a noble purpose currently sits at zero. All that being said, how do we the tech community solve Theresa May's problem? Her philosophy is "if we knew more, we could have prevented this." Is that the right philosophy? Is there some other mechanism to authorize "legitimate" access to encrypted data?
- nyolfen 9y ago>All that being said, how do we the tech community solve Theresa May's problem? Her philosophy is "if we knew more, we could have prevented this." Is that the right philosophy? Is there some other mechanism to authorize "legitimate" access to encrypted data? there's absolutely nothing substantiating her claim. terrorists seem to have done just fine in the absence of encryption -- the bataclan attackers coordinated with ordinary sms. governments still make this push _all the time_, witness the doj going after apple after san bernardino. the UK is literally the most surveilled society in the history of the world in terms of communications of its inhabitants intercepted by its own government, comparable perhaps only to the stasi. this is mode of action is not working. two attacks in two weeks, and their answer is "the same but more"?
- cJ0th 9y ago> there's absolutely nothing substantiating her claim. yes, and this is very weird. She must have a chain of reasoning going on in her head before opening her mouth, right? We always only get the conclusion, that is: "we need more access". Any normal person looking for a solution to a problem would generate loads of ideas and then, when pitching an idea, present the pros/cons of their various ideas to finally argue why they have chosen solution x. We don't see any of that wrt to this topic.
- sametmax 9y agoThe chain of reasoning is: - I want more power/money/whatever - suerveillance can give it to me - I just need to pass the bill once to get it to work for years in my favor - they have to reject it at every attempt I try to pass it - therefor I should try to pass it everytime the news let me do a bold claim - nobody is going to do shit against it anyway
- alkonaut 9y agoThis is obviously nonsense - but I'm not envious of someone who has to stand at a podium and say something that will make voters believe you'll sort this problem. Nigel Farage just suggested internment camps (on Fox News). That's where we are now. I don't think May's suggestion has any way of ever working - but her listeners don't understand that. This is populism in its purest form.
- mhh__ 9y agoIt would seem we've been able to see the real Nigel Farage, now that he has moved away.
- blazespin 9y agoThe solution is a drivers license to use the internet. No more anonymity. Can't create backdoors(that'd be like removing the steering wheels from cars), but the internet is a public space like our highways. You can cause a lot of damage there, so you should have a license or passport. Controlling speech or disabling crypto is very Orwellian. obfuscating crypto is trivial. God Kay must either be as dumb as Trump acts or think we are all stupid.
- akersten 9y ago> The solution is a drivers license to use the internet. No more anonymity. That's not a solution, that's a failure and a regression. There is nothing wrong with the way the internet works right now.
- blazespin 9y agoWow, really? The internet is very very broken. I believe in privacy, but I am also a very very big believer in accountability. Anyways, disabling crypto is super stupid. We all agree on that. Terrorists will just embed crypto in images. Kay also wants to restrict access to pron but that's her hang up.
- akersten 9y ago> Wow, really? The internet is very very broken. It works fine for me. I view the pseudo-anonymous nature of the Internet as a feature, not a bug. I think we agree fundamentally that attempting to ban or restrict math is ridiculous. For the sake of discussion - what specifically about the current structure of the Internet is broken? You allude to accountability, but it's fairly easy for law enforcement to track someone down (in the "not-using-7-proxies" case - and even then, just repeat step 1 below): * Subpoena a site for IP records * Subpoena their ISP for subscriber information Now, whether that person is actually located somewhere actionable is another question - but that's a geopolitical problem, not an Internet problem. The first point - sure, maybe a site doesn't keep IP logs. Are you saying it should be mandatory to track the source of posts? (Should it be mandatory for physical establishments to log the biometrics of visitors? If the answer to these questions is different, why?) How would your proposal for tying Internet access to physical identity (e.g. drivers' licenses) impact access for those in developing nations? There are already a lot of hoops for them to jump through to get online. Edit: I didn't downvote, by the way - I do still believe in the HN ethos of only downvoting spam/meme posts. People should have a chance to read both sides of a discussion.
- hughw 9y agoWhy even permit people to have secrets of any kind? The real "problem" is not encryption, but people keeping secrets. Encryption is just one way of keeping a secret. With a law banning private secrets, they could throw anyone in jail for not answering a question. If the government has a back door to read all your messages, they are saying they don't want you to have any secrets at all -- but electronic messages are the only ones they know how to pry open.
- dualogy 9y ago> Why even permit people to have secrets of any kind? The real "problem" is [...] people keeping secrets You might be on to something! To lead the way to a secret-free world, they might wanna start by dissolving MI5, MI6, etc..
- kwhitefoot 9y ago> hey could throw anyone in jail for not answering a question. if the question is "What is the key to this encrypted disk?", then they can already do that which surely already means that the keeping of secrets is illegal whenever a policeman says it is.
- danieltillett 9y agoOnce upon a time society functioned that way - a strong belief in God acts in practice to make secrets impossible. I am not sure that a society without any secrets would be a bad thing - it certainly would be very different.
- foreigner 9y agoIt helps to give non-computer people a non-computer analogy: This is equivalent to requiring the walls of the houses we live in and the clothing we wear to be made out of special material which is opaque to us but see-through to the police. This will keep us all safe! Anybody got a problem with that?
- hughw 9y agoEvidently, most people don't have a problem with it, because that describes the situation at U.S. airports very well.
- alerighi 9y agoWhen I hear people say that backdoors are a good thing, I say to them: so you wouldn't mind either if an agent breaks into your home without permission, reads and copies all your mail and documents, installs microphones and cameras in every room, puts a GPS localizer in all your clothes so you are constantly tracked. Surely you don't want that, well, and if they make the same things through a backdoor in your phone, is it ok ?
- taobility 9y agoI am all right with that, as I don't think my privacy is sensitive to the agent, my email just normal email, no terrorism, no child porn, no drug etc, why I would care they check it or not. Apple, Google, Microsoft already scan all your online activities, why would they better than the government? You guys always trying to mix the privacy and security. for the iPhone case, in case the police need to unlock the iPhone to save hundreds of people's life, are you guys still insist that Apple shouldn't unlock the iPhone for the cops?
- sebmeister 9y agoEven if you do not care about the complete loss of privacy, are you not wary about the methods for accessing the backdoors leaking to criminals and antagonist governments? Which has already happened, see Vault 7 and numerous other leaks.
- geff82 9y agoTo all my still-EU-cocitizens: you still have the possibility to leave your neo-facist country for another part of Europe. It will not get better, as the anglo-saxon world is currently destructing itself.
- 659087 9y agoIt really does seem that these people have lists of power grabbing desires ready and waiting for the next attack. I imagine this woman's first private reaction to the news of this attack was not sadness or concern for the victims, but joy/excitement about the possibility of exploiting the situation to achieve her political goals.
- logicallee 9y agoI don't want to make this too political, but I am really curious about people's perspectives. Please stay like close to the center in your response to my question, obviously it is easy to make a kneejerk response. (I address this at the end of this comment.) So, we heard about a recent terrorist that he was banned from his Mosque (for being too radical), reported by other Muslims, and that the FBI also reported him to the UK. What do you guys think that the UK should do in this case? I mean let's take an absurd example of a petition by 50 people from mosques and community saying, "Hey, this person is not a member of our community but is spouting radical nonsense and wants to commit terror." In this case what should be done? I am drawing a complete blank, because it doesn't take long to prepare terrorist acts but until you do them you aren't really a terrorist. The only thing I can think of is something that even I can see would be a joke. If the government came to me and said, "hey we received over 12 people asking us to watch you because you are a terrorist. We'd like you to voluntarily participate in civilization training to better understand why terrorism is wrong. You'll get £200 for participating." But I can hardly type that without it sounding like a joke. I mean there's politeness but this sounds just absurd. (I added the £200 part because I think there is no way they would agree otherwise. But if it's not voluntary then that doesn't sit right with me either.) So in this actual, real-world case, what should the UK have done? I don't think increasing surveillance so that you catch someone between the 45 minutes it takes them to inform themselves how to perform terrorism, and going and doing it. People are pretty strong and powerful and have a million tools of every kind, more surveillance couldn't possibly help here, I mean the reaction time would have to be like seconds from when someone chooses to start googling how to do terrorism to making a concrete enough plot to be criminal. It's just not a solution. So returning to my question -- for the case I mentioned, what should we done? Note: I understand that it is easy to make a flippant, knee-jerk response. For example, it is easy to say, "if someone reports a muslim for radical speech the reported muslim should be thrown in prison without a trial, and throw away the key". I really don't want to start a thread like that so please don't respond if you have attitudes like this: I've represented your response in this last paragraph and ask you please not to derail this thread on this subject. Yes, it is very easy to deal with if totalitarianism is okay. I specifically say this because I know people in real life who would make exactly this response or one exactly like it. That is not my question and I've represented this position in this paragraph, no need to repeat it, and you would just get downvoted. In this comment I am asking for people's practical ideas that are close to the center, if they have any. Thank you.
- age_bronze 9y agoThe real issue on putting backdoors, the way I see it, is that once you gave one government an access, you've already set a precedence and you can now be compelled by other governments to do the same. Giving other governments backdoors would actually hurt the original country more than the backdoor could ever help it. Segmenting the software according to which government is given backdoor will freeze the whole industry, and you would still have the unsolvable problem of imported protocols with different countries backdoors. If the problem was only "good guys"-"bad guys" it would be solvable, but there are no good guys. There are so many countries, and each of them trust only themselves.
- jaggi1 9y agoPoliticians are merely using Terrorism is an excuse to make their job easy while making out life miserable. This is indeed tyranny and totally independent of which party is in power. Only if people could unite.
- davidf18 9y agoThe truth is that Britain and the US has been funding Palestinian terror for years and PM May knows this but refuses to withdraw funding: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/02/world/middleeast/palestine-mahmoud-ab.. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/02/world/middleeast/palestin.... "The issue of payments to families of suicide bombers and others who commit violence has become a frequent complaint by Israel and its supporters. The Palestinian Authority spends about $315 million a year to distribute cash and benefits to 36,000 families".... Only last week the Palestinians named a women's center after Dalal Mughrabi who hijacked a bus on Israel’s Coastal Road and killed 38 civilians, 13 of them children, and wounded over 70. I feel the pain of the British from the terrorist attacks, but why don't they stop all funding to the Palestinians until we can be certain they are no longer funding terror nor glorifying terrorists? Why doesn't President Trump stop all funding if he is truly serious about combatting terror?
- meric 9y agoI don't think it's the Palestinians in this case, but you are right all foreign relations ought to be examined.
- davidf18 9y agoIt is very disturbing that people have down voted this implying the believe it is OK for US and British taxpayers to fund and incentivize Palestinian terrorists and funding a Palestinian government that names a women's center after a terrorist.
- lehi 9y agoYitzhak Shamir was the leader of a self-avowed Zionist terrorist group that directly orchestrated the murders of hundreds of civilians, politicians, policemen, and scientists. Israel made him Prime Minister and, in honor of his centenary in recent months, has named research institutes and hospitals in his memory to add to the streets and parks that already bore his name. How much funding and incentive has Israel received from US and UK taxpayers?
- 9y ago
- banku_brougham 9y agoI think by now our surveillance protectors already have total information awareness, well perhaps 90% of the information and not very great awareness. But i doubt lack of information is limitation on awareness. They could do a lot better even with less information, i suppose. So why demand ever more intrusive powers? I think its just an excuse, and that they dont have great ideas to preempt attacks.
- banku_brougham 9y agoI think by now our surveillance protectors already have total information awareness, well perhaps 90% of the information and not very great awareness. But i doubt lack of information is limitation on awareness. They could do a lot better even with less information, i suppose. So why demand ever more intrusive powers? I think its just an excuse, and that they dont have great ideas to preempt attacks.
- pier25 9y ago"Terrorists can discuss things in private at their homes so we are going to put cameras on every home" Same argument, just as ridiculous.
- pwm 9y agoGive it a few more years...
- amiga-workbench 9y agoConsumers are already willingly installing telescreens in their homes.
- awqrre 9y agoeverything should be public, especially Government secrets...
- kradem 9y agoImo this isn't about legislative of today, rather about the philosophy/politics of today responsible for the legislative of the future. Today's cryptography is like the ice sculptures art, we could show a lot, but on unstable timeline. The true art is going to come with the quantum computers and the governments will have to have legislative for someone sending messages to someone else because they won't have any other tool available.
- boyter 9y agoDo it May, I dare you. It will launch the geek equiilivelent of the Manhattan project to find the master keys, and whoever does find them will become incredibly rich and powerful.
- kikoreis 9y agoHere's an idea. Instead of spending the effort on a damaging, losing battle on the technology side.. let's invest in social inclusion, mental health and healthy foreign policy in the middle east. Catching the madmen on the wrong side of the curve makes much less economic sense.
- taobility 9y agolike what European people did, let's warmly welcome them into our civilized world.
- petre 9y agoNot really Europeans. Merkel did that. Go ask anyone in Hungary, Poland or Czech Republic, or even Romania who complies with migrant quotas and is generaly an EU cheerer, unlike Hungary or Poland.
- Symbiote 9y agoHave any of the recent terrorists been recent migrants? I thought most were from at least a decade ago, if not born here.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- taobility 9y agoisn't that just prove the idea is so ridiculous which trying to social inclusion, mental health
- petre 9y agoNot many but there's a recent wave of rapes commited by migrants that is downplayed and not reported my the EU cheering mainstream media. https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/9934/germany-rape-january https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/9934/germany-rape-january
- imron 9y agoMathematicians: 2 + 2 = 4 UK PM: We'd like you to make it so that 2 + 2 = 5. Mathematicians: That's mathematically impossible UK PM: You just need to try harder
- squarefoot 9y agoUsing fear to push for restrictive laws is not news, pretty much every government did it or will do it one day. It's just too tempting, people will accept the restrictions as a mean to fight terrorism/pedophiles/serial killers/$CURRENTENEMY etc. until the new laws will be slowly and silently used to quench dissent.
- id122015 9y agowhy not educating people instead of banning ?
- _0ffh 9y agoNo sane non-UK company will want to do any R&D or other sensitive stuff in the UK anymore, lest GCHQ leak their communications to their UK-based competition.
- a_c 9y agoAbout the Travelsentry locks, what happen if someone from the airport open your luggage, and tamper with the content? How can one be sure that the content their luggage has not been tampered with? I assume the answer is no but would love to hear otherwise
- lottin 9y agoVery nice of the author to spell 'Iphone' and 'Ios' in accordance with English capitalisation rules, refusing to submit to the idiotic dictates of some marketing department. Well done sir!
- AdeptusAquinas 9y agoMisses an additional point: they would need to ban software development. Or at least, dev by unapproved, unmonitored parties. Code to encrypt using one (of the many) algorithms shipped in .NET (which is open source right down to the compiler, and so hard to tamper with): RijndaelManaged RMCrypto = new RijndaelManaged(); CryptoStream CryptStream = new CryptoStream(NetStream, RMCrypto.CreateEncryptor(Key, IV), CryptoStreamMode.Write); Even if they banned everything else, people who want to create secure communications can do so with the aid of less than an hour of a capable developer's time.
- YawningAngel 9y agoIt's even worse than this, they have to analyse and attack every motherfucker's implementation of BogoCrypt under the sun. They can probably do this, but it's an impossibly time consuming task.
- tetha 9y agoOn top of that: How you you distinguish an encrypted document from a data serialized according to a proprietary format? As long as the algorithm to write the data is unknown and secret, this is essentially a cryptographic algorithm - you can't read the information on disk without the secret, unless you invest a lot of time. Weak crypto, mind you, because we'll probably be able to decrypt it in polynomial time. So suddenly, all storage formats need to be openly documented?
- laythea 9y agoEven if this was actually possible to do without compromising our security, it would not achieve anything as the bad guys will just use alternative methods to achieve their goals. End game: Society will be none the safer, and the government/puppet masters will have total surveillance.
- sleavey 9y agoTerrorism happened before the internet.
- wbillingsley 9y agoIt does not help that the tech companies preach a kind of false equivalence here. Part of their argument is that they are investing a lot in ensuring they can "take down" these posts quickly. So, the legal system in most countries is that if you post something explicitly (not in jest, or metaphor, but quite deliberately and with the intent of other people's death) asking people to murder other people, that is something that you perhaps ought to be charged with an offence over. Meanwhile Facebook, etc, essentially argue that ok, they posted a request for the murder of a lot of people, but hey, we took it down after only a few thousand people read it, and we've closed the account (until they open another one), so that's job done, no need to prosecute any further, you shouldn't ask us to cooperate with police, we've got adverts to sell here. Small wonder that governments are changing the law, when tech companies regard requests to kill people as something that, if really pushed, they'll treat as equivalent to how they handle copyright infringement, but actually there's less money in it for them so would you mind if it was a bit further down the planned feature list.
- jamesshorten 9y agoSo how should they proceed without fundamentally altering the way their platforms work?
- algesten 9y agoI seriously doubt a coordinated terrorist attack is done as a public facebook post. Isn't that a whole other issue?
- yodsanklai 9y ago> If you want a preview of what a back door looks like, just look at the US Transportation Security Administration’s “master keys” for the locks on our luggage Good point. I have the same issue in my building. The postman has a master key to open the mailboxes. Apparently, these master keys are now well-spread and I can't order packages anymore as they get stolen.
- jacquesm 9y agoYes, let's increase the size of the haystack. I've yet to see proof that having the ability to read each and every communication would have prevented any attack that from the last couple of years. For the most part the criminals communicated in clear text SMS or on open phone lines or in game chatrooms. If they needed advanced crypto that would prove at least that we have done everything else to make their lives harder, but so far it looks as if there is plenty of low hanging fruit. Suggestion: reduce the size of the haystack further so that limited manpower can be concentrated on those cases where it is actually useful rather than to chase each and every 16 year old with a twitter account or a facebook page.
- jsjsjsjsjsjs 9y agoIf they ban secure software it surely will work as terrorists are law-abiding citizens. Right?
- pacifika 9y agoPerhaps we should no longer assume that politicians 'do not understand the internet' and assume they are asking for changes in the full understanding that they don't achieve the goal for which they're introduced. As long as the situation that's being created is more favourable for them than the current one it's a net benefit. Short-term politics is the biggest threat to UK society at the moment and the current government is particularly good at it.
- daemin 9y agoI'd say the reason that the people in power want to be able to collect all information is not to protect the people, but instead to protect themselves and their friends in powerful positions. One of the main threats to these large organisations and the people at the top of them ate journalists and whistleblowers. Because those are two groups of people that can provide critical data and reasoning on bad and evil things that are done within such large organisations. So having the ability to find out who said what to whom will allow them to crack down or reporters and journalists before they can get their stories out. And it will allow them to trace and find out who the people are leaking sensitive information outside and deal with them. In some way this is about protecting the people, just not the people we are all thinking of.
- moomin 9y agoThe article is pretty sniffy about Hogwarts' security, but it's missing an important point: magic can detect intent. So yeah, it might be possible for Harry Potter to build what Theresa May is asking for, but a) he doesn't exists and b) I'm pretty sure it'd be against his progressive principles.
- jk2323 9y agoWhy do they want to ban crypto? Because of terrorism? Why does Poland or Hungary don't want to ban crypto and why don't they have terrorism? Easy solution: Ban Islam and Muslim migration.
- kukabynd 9y agoIf 99.99% of made transactions are not malicious in nature why should people who made those transactions suffer? There are other means to detect suspects that don’t ask for a cost of a privacy of the nation. On the whole other point of this don’t you think there’s a chance to the possibility that certain terror/cyber attacks were made by some intelligence agency? Timing on this is too convenient. Besides, there is no known method that can resolve all types of cryptographic methods thus it makes it useless spending of taxpayers’ money.
- microcolonel 9y agoMan, I really need to move to the U.S. Canada is becoming hostile to speech and the family with M-103, C-16, and Ontario Bill 89. Britain had to choose between a man who doesn't understand the nuclear deterrent and who would screw them in their biggest negotiation for decades, who would probably end up controlling the internet for antisemitic causes rather than ostensibly counter-terrorism causes; and a lady who doesn't understand any of the technical implications of the whoops-tyrannical policies she presents (in the middle of a campaign no less, are they all daft?). And because the UK Tories didn't do the smart thing and hang on to their popular moment for dear life to secure a supermajority, there's a hung parliament, which is only slightly better than the probably-antisemitic national socialist labour party getting a majority. Prime minister doesn't even pretend to be meritocratic, denigrates his cabinet by saying that they were picked for their gender. The Social Justice Tribunals (actual name of the institution, not hyperbolic slur) are out of control. At least the U.S. has a real constitution, which at least purports to protect freedom of speech, the right to petition, and the right of the people to keep and bear arms. Britain and Canada are sinking into the earth's core under smiling faces, and DJT is somehow making America better despite being a rough buffoon. Every day is opposite day.