3 ms·
I strongly agree with all that. In fact, being FOSS could be a huge advantage. The #2 kernel ACIS by Spatial is massively held back by albatross round its nec
by delhanty 9y ago
I strongly agree with all that. In fact, being FOSS could be a huge advantage.
The #2 kernel ACIS by Spatial is massively held back by albatross round its neck - ie. the parent company Dassault who have foisted there own IMO inferior kernel CGM on them in the bizarre belief that it is a technical marvel.
Dassault is also the albatross round the neck of another subsidiary: SOLIDWORKS [1], and is famous for the $6.18 billion cost overrun when Airbus transitioned the A380 from the Catia V4 kernel to the Catia V5 kernel, which is essentially CGM. [2]
My point was that it is very difficult for OpenCASCADE with its setup to compete with 450 person-years of core dev work on essentially $0 funding.
[1] "One of the non-technical issues with CGM will probably be licensing costs. DS (and, hence, Spatial) is “proud” of CGM, and will be pricing it higher than ACIS."
http://www.3dcadworld.com/spatial-acis-cgm-and-the-future-of-geometric-modeling-kernels/ http://www.3dcadworld.com/spatial-acis-cgm-and-the-future-of...
[2] http://calleam.com/WTPF/?p=4700 http://calleam.com/WTPF/?p=4700
- nickpsecurity 9y agoGood points. Sad that the potential of the others were wasted to that degree, too.
- delhanty 9y agoYeah - sad! IMO that's the reason that OnShape exists at all though - the rockstar team that founded Solidworks finally got fed up with Dassault and decided to write Solidworks for the cloud. ShapeManager by Autodesk is probably the technical #2, and is doing well. You can't buy it easily though. It powers Inventor/Fusion360 and is also in Revit and AutoCAD.
- nickpsecurity 9y ago"the rockstar team that founded Solidworks finally got fed up with Dassault and decided to write Solidworks for the cloud." The hacker spirit in action. Roll up one's sleeves, write some code, and give a big FU to the establishment. :)