12 ms·
Sweden Has a Sub So Deadly the US Navy Hired It to Play Bad Guy (2014)
- dogma1138 9y agoSweden has a sub so small.... The US wanted to train against attack subs that are much smaller than what Russia is using since North Korea and Iran were developing small subs that can be used in effectively what would be suicide missions against US carrier groups. Sweden built a small sub because it cannot afford large ones and because it allows the sub to operate in shallow water and the narrow passes in the fjords. Since the US can't ask North Korea to play the red team since they do it in real life they've rented a Swedish sub as an agressor.
- bjelkeman-again 9y agoI don't think the Swedish navy needs a bigger submarine. The use case was only for defending Swedish territorial water and there wasn't need for a bigger one.
- csours 9y agoAlso, Sweden does not need a sub that can travel the world under its own power. From the article, a larger ship was used to move the sub from Swedish waters to the Pacific for these war games. Nuclear subs can go wherever they want, whenever they want. For Swedish use, however, the sub will never have to be far from home, so the tradeoff is worth it for them.
- Nokinside 9y agoUS wanted to train and test new sonars against against submarines that are more silent than nuclear submarines and US don't have any. Nuclear submarines can never be totally quiet. Turbines and pipes give out noise. Submarines with air independent propulsion can be totally silent when they stop and extremely silent when moving slowly. North Korean submarines are not a threat. Chinese diesel electric submarines are.
- valuearb 9y agoit's not the size. it's that AIP subs have advanced so far they've veckme super deadly.
- exabrial 9y agoNot mentioned in the title, but Sweden thinks they have surrounded an enemy sub in their territorial waters! Pretty crazy.
- dogma1138 9y agoRussian subs patrol those waters all the time they like pushing boundaries it's nothing new really.
- gech 9y agoThese kinds of activities are really immature for adults regardless of country
- synicalx 9y agoAssessing the reaction and capabilities of a country you might one day be at war against? Seems fairly sane to me even though I don't particularly like Russia nor do I want them to go to war with anyone.
- KC8ZKF 9y agoThat was in October of 2014.
- exabrial 9y agoDarn. I set that now. Any idea what the outcome was
- dosshell 9y agoSo, a small country develop their own high tech sub, airplane [0] , ships [1], special modification of one of the most advanced tanks [2], special order helicopter from EU project, advanced artillery [3] and light tank [4]. And I probably missed a few other expensive toys. So how good are their defense? ~1 week will it take to invade Sweden according to them self... With the help of the militia. [5]. My concern is that they basically just develop expensive military stuff because they want to feed the industry. A political dance with money. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_JAS_39_Gripen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_JAS_39_Gripen [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visby-class_corvette https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visby-class_corvette [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stridsvagn_122 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stridsvagn_122 [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archer_Artillery_System https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archer_Artillery_System [4] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combat_Vehicle_90 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combat_Vehicle_90 [5] https://www.svd.se/forsvar-med-tidsgrans https://www.svd.se/forsvar-med-tidsgrans (swedish)
- cc81 9y agoThe goal of the military is to be able to resist for a week and after that Sweden is dependent on allies helping. This of course refers to a full scale invasion from Russia. Sweden used to have a pretty decent military though. For example: > In 1957 Sweden had the world's fourth most powerful air force,[5] with about 1000 modern planes in front-line service. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_Air_Force https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_Air_Force However these days it is pretty crippled I think. Large budget cuts and a big transformation to a much smaller military that focused on missions abroad.
- aquadrop 9y agoWhy would Russia attack Sweden? What's the point?
- dogma1138 9y agoTo secure its passage into the Atlantic. Russia is (defacto) the world's largest land locked country. It possess no warm water ports which are open to the high seas. This reality shaped Russian expansion and regional and global geopolitics since the 19th century. A warm water port is why Russia invaded Korea(and Manchuria) 3 times, it's why it would go to a war with NATO over Ukraine and why it would not let Syria fall. Russia's only open port is in Vlodivostock and its closed for 4 or more months of the year and its on the other side of the world. To access the Atlantic Russia needs to cross the Great Belt and the North Sea, to access the Med it needs to cross the Bosphorus, Sea of Marmara and the Dardanelles. This means that to get anywhere it either needs to set sail from the other side of the world if it's not winter or pay a toll fee to NATO. Global warming might actually play into Russia's hands, they are far north enough not to be affected by the drought, they are a bread basket, rich in natural resources, have a small population, and will reap the benefits the northern passage and their eastern ports open all year round.
- sargun 9y agoThey mention that the submarine uses liquid oxygen. How are they storing this cryogenic liquid, and compressing it? I imagine that would take a ridiculous amount of equipment, and power in the first place?
- csours 9y agoI imagine that it is topped up by either a tender ship or at port. This sub was shipped to the Pacific in another ship for the war games, indicating that it is not practical for it to travel that far on its own.
- dogma1138 9y agoIt's not cryognic it's also not its primary power planet it provides limited power when the sub needs to operate dark. The size of the sub doesn't allow for battery storage sufficient for propulsion and using chemical fuel cells in a sub that small is likely to be too risky.
- bungle 9y agoCIA and Pentagon forced Finland to cancel this: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mir_(submersible) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mir_(submersible) (too good submarine)
- valuearb 9y agoit's wasn't the submersible, which only had extremely limited military uses, it was the transfer of advanced technology to the USSR.
- Theodores 9y agoI wonder what the shift arrangement is for the crew of 24. Do they have some laws in Sweden about working hours so that the vessel only needs six crew but has a staff of 24 to cover all shifts and weekends? If everything could be automated to video-game easy so that you didn't need someone to chuck more rods in the nuclear reactor or do things with bilge pumps, what would be the minimum complement for a submarine that played the deterrent role, lurking under the waves for months at a time? The problem (allegedly) with submarines is remote control drone submarines that are clever enough to know how to communicate. Apparently it is possible to program one submarine to follow another without having to carry 24 people plus their lunches, dinners and oxygen supply. There is a danger that mutually assured destruction assured by submarines with nuclear weapons could end.
- KC8ZKF 9y agoProbably something like 3 watch sections of 8 sailors, with additional working hours off-watch. (I don't know why anybody would want a weekend off aboard that bitty-little boat anyway.) At least in 'merica, the military is exempt from labor laws. Choose your rate, choose your fate.
- willvarfar 9y agoHere's a nice article on Air-Independent-Propulsion (AIP) submarines: http://www.hisutton.com/World%20survey%20of%20AIP%20submarines.html http://www.hisutton.com/World%20survey%20of%20AIP%20submarin... The Swedish Gotland class was the world's first purpose-built AIP sub.
- iambateman 9y agoIs there any requirement to disclose possession of a submarine like this? If it were I, as a military commander, I would rather enjoy having a few of these lurk until I had to play my had. then again, IANAGeneral ;)
- synicalx 9y agoSub's do sort of do that already to some extent, their whereabouts is not normally a matter of public record - they could be lurking anywhere. If you were ordering submarines around you'd more likely be an Admiral :P
- Scramblejams 9y agoI'm starting to think Aquadrop is a Russian astroturf account.
- aquadrop 9y agoAaaand we're in the personal attack area. Thanks for the attention, I don't have desire to discuss anything with you any more.
- Scramblejams 9y agoI don't mean to attack you, but the thought occurred to me because you're not rigorously engaging those who disagree with you. Multiple people are giving you detailed responses that are well-grounded in history and geographical realities, and you're just coming back with "far-fetched," "self-contradictory," and other content-free dodges. I'd be more convinced of your sincerity if you actually took the time to rebut others in detail. Edit: dogma1138's post in particular deserved a much better response than you gave. S/he's telling you of a dynamic that's been driving national strategies for literally thousands of years -- access to ports -- and you're acting like it just doesn't matter anymore. Why?
- eveningcoffee 9y agoThere are signals that you are right but if he is to be believed then more likely he is just influenced by the Russian cultural space.
- aquadrop 9y ago> and you're just coming back with "far-fetched," "self-contradictory," and other content-free dodges Those things were in the same one comment, and if you look at others, you can see that I actually take the time to rebut in details. And dogma1138's comment is just really far-fetched. It starts with saying that Russia is land-locked country... Port of Murmansk is Ice free and gives easy access to the Atlantic. Also Russia has fleet of atomic ice-breakers and north passage is not a problem. And if you think back, during WW2 there was no need in attacking Sweden for any passages etc... And even with all that, dogma1138 comment is only applicable in the even of large scale NATO-Russia war, do you think it's possible? It's suicide for Russia if only regular weapons are used and suicide for the whole world if nukes are used, so I don't see it happening.
- Guyag 9y agoDid anyone else think that the language used in this article was really hyperbolic and over-dramatic? Loads of unnecessary superlatives I thought.
- unlmtd 9y agoWhat a maniac!