5 ms·
According to the NUKEMAP, the survival rate at 10 miles of a 1 megaton bomb should be pretty good: https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ https://nuclearsecrecy.c
by mikeash 9y ago
According to the NUKEMAP, the survival rate at 10 miles of a 1 megaton bomb should be pretty good:
https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/
That gives 2.5km as the lethal radius for radiation, 3km as the 100% lethal radius for blast, 7km as the radius for "injuries are universal, fatalities are widespread" and 12.6km as the radius for 3rd degree burns from thermal radiation. At 16 km you'd still get badly burned if you were exposed to the flash and you could get killed by a collapsing building if you weren in something sturdy, but you'd have a decent chance of surviving.
On another note, did you account for the fact that it's only a half sphere since the bomb explodes near the ground? I might have just missed it.
(Incidentally, this is why they used to teach "duck and cover." At this sort of distance, your chances of surviving are much better if you're on the ground and under something sturdy when the shockwave hits. I never understood why "duck and cover" ended up with such a bad reputation.)
- cxcorp 9y agoI think that the reason why people dismiss "duck and cover" is that they think it's issued as a recommendation for surviving inside the lethal radius.
- sjg007 9y agoDefinitely less silly than get inside the fridge.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I never understood why "duck and cover" ended up with such a bad reputation. Because in the the probability of being in a location where it would make a difference to even short-term survival was minimal, and, in the event of a major superpower exchange (the main plausible scenario when those drills were common for anything that would include attacks on US population centers) short-survival was widely perceived (with some good reasons) to most likely buy you a long, painful death from a combination of the effects of fallout and those of the effects of the collapse of organized society.
- mikeash 9y agoThe probability of being in a location where it would make a difference was high. Huge parts of major cities would be in that zone. Duck and cover dates from the 1950s, where the US's end of nuclear war would have looked much closer to a strangelovian "hair mussed" than the total apocalypse you describe. The Soviet Union didn't have the capability to cause that level of damage to the US until the mid 1960s or so.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Duck and cover dates from the 1950s The bad reputation of duck and cover does not, however. > The Soviet Union didn't have the capability to cause that level of damage to the US until the mid 1960s or so. The bad reputation dates from later than the 60s, AFAICT. It's not like duck and cover went away then: we were doing duck and cover drills in my elementary school in the 1980s, and classrooms in community colleges I saw had duck and cover instructions posted prominetly in the 1990s.
- mikeash 9y agoThe bad reputation applied retroactively, though. People think it's stupid it was ever taught.
- daxfohl 9y agoPer thermal radiation, does that mean essentially light? So if you see the explosion, no time to get out of the way, already burned?
- wayn3 9y ago- if you "see" the flash, thats the last thing youre ever going to see. will blind you. - thermal radiation is, in fact, light, which travels at the speed of light - but you should not imagine the entirety of the thermal energy to be released by a nuclear weapon to be released instantaneously in a radially travelling sphere. that being said, youre not going to outrun such an explosion. where you are at the time of detonation pretty much determines your odds of survival.
- daxfohl 9y agoTrying to figure out the most rational thing to do at each distance. In fireball, say goodbye. Sounds like shock wave isn't that big of a deal on its own far beyond the fireball region, beyond eardrums, but obviously shrapnel and collapses will get you indirectly. But thermal radiation seems to extend much farther per the website and there's no escape. So is that what actually kills the most people? (Though it's 2017, who ever goes outside anymore?) And then of course fallout, but I guess you can flee or shelter from that.
- mikeash 9y agoThe thermal pulse lasts several seconds for a large bomb. If you can immediately throw yourself into a ditch or behind a wall or otherwise shelter from it, you may greatly reduce the burns you receive. What kills the most people depends on the size of the bomb. For really small ones (like the US Army's nuclear bazooka from the 50s) the prompt radiation has the greatest lethal radius. For medium sized ones like Hiroshima, blast is the major one. For really big ones, thermal effects reach the farthest.
- daxfohl 9y agoIn the latter, do you mean thermal radiation or thermal conduction? I guess it doesn't make a huge difference because radiation hits you before you cam do anything about it, and conduction is impossible to get away from. But curious anyway.
- wayn3 9y agothe bomb does not explode "near" the ground. the relatively small bombs of hiroshima and nagsaki exploded about a mile above ground. the goal here is to make the shockwaves double up near the ground, causing more destruction. i'd assume that bigger bombs would detonate at higher altitudes to achieve the same effect further out.
- mikeash 9y agoTrinity was on top of a tower, and Fermi was 10 miles away. A half sphere is much closer to that situation than a full sphere.
- pavement 9y agoI do believe that the altitude of detonation is a tactical decision, based on target selection. A commander might attempt to destroy some types of hardened bunkers by penetrating the ground before detonating, or completely destroy a fleet of armored vehicles or a single specific building with a direct strike on the fleet itself, or upon the building's roof. Destroying population centers, or industrial zones is another matter, where an airburst maximizes above ground damage distributed across an area. The blast wave doesn't precisely "double up" as much as it smashes downward, and plows outward, with a reflection of the sphere bouncing back upward. This effect does result in two waves, above a certain height, closer in, near ground zero, with harsher effects on tall buildings, if there are any. But the angle of the reflection grows more acute, as distance from the center of the sphere increases, and the equator of the blast sphere widens. So, once you get out past a few miles from ground zero, unless your in a building taller than 200 feet (66 meters), it's still really just going to be a single front that slams the structure you're occupying. Furthermore, while airbursts do take advantage of the principle of reflected force, peculiarities of the target terrain also play a role, in terms of both ground texture (stone vs. soil) and topography (hills and valleys). A city center with lots of concrete and asphalt will be highly reflective, but rural targets surrounded by agricultural soil will be absorbent and inelastic, and produce a distorted, lower fidelity reflection. Topography, meanwhile, will produce additional distortion and blurred shadows, behind and around corners, so targets, set back, behind the crests of hills, or behind many layers of tall buildings, might enjoy a lateral shadows from both flash heat and blast forces, but not ambient heat after the wave passes.
- albemuth 9y agoI'm reminded of Ender's Game playing with this.