4 ms·
I'm disappointed in how many comments here are just kneejerk reactions. Reaching for weird comparisons, getting angry at the idea of diversity and social justic
by viraptor 9y ago
I'm disappointed in how many comments here are just kneejerk reactions. Reaching for weird comparisons, getting angry at the idea of diversity and social justice, and many others.
This wasn't enforced from outside. It's the organisers who agreed: yup, that's not what we want to do (https://twitter.com/nmsanchez/status/870811022306574336 https://twitter.com/nmsanchez/status/870811022306574336)
Stop for a moment, think of how you'd organise a conference. Is it different? Will people find it inviting? Will they find it interesting? Go ahead, and organise it! Every community and group of organisers can shape the events they create the way they want to. ElectronConf organisers made such choice.
For the people that worry so much about speakers... I haven't done many talks (2 bigger events), but if I heard my talk was delayed so the conference can be rebalanced / less of a white sausage party, I'd be glad. Others may not share that opinion. But don't assume everybody will.
Edit: Yes, there are better and worse ways to go about it. Realising too late and reverting the original list was not the best. Reaching out to / inviting diverse groups rather than fixing balance later would be better. Hope they learned and will do it better next year. Organisers which care about it from the beginning somehow manage to get a decent m/f split - both in the audience and in the speakers. (see linux.conf for a good example)
Edit2: A few people assume that talks will be dropped / replaced as a result. I don't know what the organisers are planning, but there's always an option of adding another room/stream. Until any talks are confirmed as dropped, this is just baseless speculation.
- smokeyj 9y ago> but if I heard my talk was delayed so the conference can be rebalanced / less of a white sausage party, I'd be glad Maybe the solution is to stop being racist and sexist.
- viraptor 9y agoYou seem to imply that being happy to be surrounded with a more gender/race diverse crowd than the typical 90s IT conference is either racist or sexist. I just don't understand that argument.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoCalling something a "white sausage party" is racist and sexist, and if you said something equivalent against women or minorities on-line, you'd end up in a huge shitstorm. This assymetry is a big part of the problem.
- selllikesybok 9y agoThis is a common reaction, and it started from a misunderstanding of the terms. I recommend reading https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/racism https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/racism And then https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/sexism https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/sexism Of course, it's a complex topic, and there's a lot more great material which would help you get a better understanding. While particularly focused on a specific type of racism in the US, includes a decent 101 on racism generally - https://medium.com/@absurdistwords/how-to-discuss-race-with-black-people-faq-pt-1-2534db9e3409 https://medium.com/@absurdistwords/how-to-discuss-race-with-...
- julianmarq 9y agoIf you were going for discrediting calling something "a white-sausage party" as if it were a bad thing isn't racist by linking that, you failed. The very first definition in your own link on racism: > : a belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race Inherent inferiority, I'd assume, fits within that mind frame. As for sexism, the second definition. > : behavior, conditions, or attitudes that foster stereotypes of social roles based on sex Now you'll start thinking of ways to complaint to the dictionary so that those definitions can be changed in a way that it's only about "minorities", I'm sure.
- selllikesybok 9y agoI'm not sure how saying that a non diverse group is inferior to a diverse group is equivalent to saying that the specific elements making up the non diverse group is inferior? Like, saying all-white is inferior to mixed is not the same as saying white is inferior. Also, do recall usages b and c, and that they are important to consider, and specifically see my third link for better explanation of how.
- 2muchcoffeeman 9y ago> Edit: Yes, there are better and worse ways to go about it. Realising too late and reverting the original list was not the best. Reaching out to / inviting diverse groups rather than fixing balance later would be better. Hope they learned and will do it better next year. Organisers which care about it from the beginning somehow manage to get a decent m/f split - both in the audience and in the speakers. (see linux.conf for a good example) A couple other comments said that they did a blind review of the submitted papers. I can't think of a farer review process.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoIf the selection committee doesn't represent a diverse field, a blind review can still be biased. I write things in a way I find compelling, other people that find them compelling are likely similar to me.
- huffmsa 9y agoThe selection committee should only be "diverse" in so far as it contains a mix of people who understand what makes a good Electron topic and a people who understand what topics make good conference presentations. If in fact, the goal is to out on an enjoyable conference on the topic of Electron.
- viraptor 9y agoNo review process is more fair. But if you end up with all-X selections from a blind-review, you may be advertising to a very homogeneous culture. As a result, you may be limiting your pool of ideas to choose from and reaching only a local maximum. There are usually great non-X engineers, as long as you reach out to them. (they're usually have their own group - guess why?) Mixing multiple varied-X groups usually results in more diverse discussions and ideas, in my experience. On the other hand, not caring about it and accepting that you're just getting dominant group X submissions is not a terrible thing. But we're social creatures - if everybody nearby is similar but different from you, either you'll feel uncomfortable, or have a bard-level charisma. So by allowing your group to become almost entirely X, you're enforcing the limit on your submitted papers pool even further. (applies for many (all?) X, where X influences your life in any way)
- julianmarq 9y ago> Edit2: A few people assume that talks will be dropped / replaced as a result. I don't know what the organisers are planning, but there's always an option of adding another room/stream. Until any talks are confirmed as dropped, this is just baseless speculation. Yeah... If a second room were confirmed, your rationalizing by saying that talks wouldn't be dropped is baseless speculation.
- viraptor 9y agoIf I did say they won't be dropped, that would be baseless speculation indeed :) Simply saying: don't assume either way before it's announced. There are a few comments which did imply previous speakers will be bumped as a result: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14480993 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14480993 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14480918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14480918 and some others.
- Yver 9y agoI haven't read a single comment here from someone "getting angry at the idea of diversity." What I've read are comments expressing disappointement that speakers are being judged by the color of their slides, not the content of their presentation.
- viraptor 9y agoSingle example https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14480955 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14480955
- protomyth 9y agoI'm mad because this is a commitment to optical diversity and does nothing for actual diversity in our industry. It is approaching the problem from the exact opposite direction. Instead of giving a diverse audience the best possible information using a blind selection system, the organizers are now going to select based on something that is not part of the lecture. If the organizers actually cared about diversity beyond being optically correct to their peers, they would plan scholarships, flights, and lodging for a diverse population that cannot normally attend and event like this. Changing the speakers is the least effort, least effective method of adding diversity to our industry. They picked lazy and cheap over effective. Frankly, the thought that a minority population can learn more for like minorities versus the original presenters is insulting and promotes a stereotype that closes more doors. "white sausage party" - the thought you are advocating for diversity yet feel it ok to insult anyone's race / creed is troubling. People who insult others or make them uncomfortable with their slurs and jabs are the basis of the problem.
- viraptor 9y ago> Instead of giving a diverse audience the best possible information using a blind selection system, the organizers are now going to select based on something that is not part of the lecture. You're making an assumption here that the blind selection process will change or that added/substitute papers will not chosen by the same criteria. I'd wait for the followup, before judging the followup ;) I agree it could be done in a better way, but hindsight is 20/20 and all that.
- protomyth 9y ago> You're making an assumption here that the blind selection process will change or that added/substitute papers will not chosen by the same criteria Clearly they won't be because now diversity is part of the additional criteria. I don't have to wait for the follow-up as they've already given the information. Hindsight is 20/20, but we've had enough of these to actually analyze what the problem is. The organizers took the out the will require the least time and money but looks good on a brochure as opposed to furthers a goal. Having grown up and worked on a reservation, I am well aware of the nice photo op versus the effective program.
- gens 9y ago>(https://twitter.com/nmsanchez/status/870811022306574336 https://twitter.com/nmsanchez/status/870811022306574336) I usually hate doing this, but hey. From that twitter: >OG tech diversifier. GitHubber. Lecturer, UC Berkeley Haas School of Business. And her github is: https://github.com/nmsanchez?tab=repositories https://github.com/nmsanchez?tab=repositories Two repositories have only a README, with, more or less, one line in it. One has a document about, not surprisingly, "diversity in tech" (and a code of conduct, ofc). And one is a fork. Her contributions to other projects sing the same song. There is also a link there to her profile on https://medium.com/@nmsanchez https://medium.com/@nmsanchez >Lecturer at UC Berkeley Haas School of Business. VP of Social Impact @ GitHub. Founder of Vaya Consulting. Purveyor of fine race/class analysis. All this kind of behavior rubs me the wrong way so i won't even comment on it all. To be honest i never had a high opinion of electron as a piece of software, so i don't know why i am even here. Sorry, i guess.
- viraptor 9y agoIt looks like you expect a conference organiser to write open source code and put it on GitHub. Why?