3 ms·
> There’s been a lot of confusion about the recent Artifex v. Hancom case, in which the court found that the GPL was an enforceable contract. The author is rea
by tzs 9y ago
> There’s been a lot of confusion about the recent Artifex v. Hancom case, in which the court found that the GPL was an enforceable contract.
The author is reading too much into this. This was just a ruling on a motion by the defendant, Hancom, to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the "failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted" rule.
A 12(b)(6) motion essentially says "Let's assume for the sake of argument that every allegation of fact that the plaintiff made in their complaint is true. Under that set of facts, there is no way that a court could find that we are liable under whatever law plaintiff claims we have violated".
When a court rules against such a motion, it is not saying that the alleged facts ARE true, or that when those facts are applied to the laws in question the plaintiff will win. All it is saying is that they plaintiff has alleged everything that is necessary in order for it to be possible for the plaintiff to win.
So in this case all the court really found was that it is possible that GPL is an enforceable contract in the circumstances alleged by plaintiff, Artifex.
- microcolonel 9y agoRight, at best the case can provide analogy for a future case under substantially identical circumstances. It does say, though, that a court considered some provisions of the GPL, in the fashion that Artifex could be considered to have agreed, to be binding. That alone is no small thing.
- belorn 9y agoThis is true for every decision by a court except for the final judgment. A typical example would be a bail hearing, where they are not supposed to establish guilt. But like with many human system it tend to leak. Its not uncommon to hear lawyers say that the outcome of a motion will imply where the final decision will land.
- monochromatic 9y agoSometimes a motion is dispositive of the whole case (or nearly so). Failing to dismiss on 12(b)(6) isn't like that at all.
- Natsu 9y agoYeah, we're not very far into this case from my understanding. Might want to wait to see if it gets appealed and whether the court of appeals even addresses that question. That said, aside from the occasional FUD, I don't think many people have doubts about the GPL holding up.
- phkahler 9y ago>> That said, aside from the occasional FUD, I don't think many people have doubts about the GPL holding up. The GPL is more important in what it does rather than what it IS. It doesn't seem to matter whether it's a license or a contract, what matters is that someone who violates its terms have nothing to fall back on to defend their copyright violation. I think calling it a contract is actually a bad thing because breach of contract may result in compensation far less than todays penalties for copyright infringement.
- ncallaway 9y agoWhile your statement of 12(b)(6) is correct, I don't think your analysis of fact vs. law is deep enough. The kinds of facts that court assumes to be true for a 12(b)(6) motion are that the defendant _did not_ sign a contract. The court assumes that the defendant _did_ use the software in a manner that violates the GPL. However, determining that the GPL is an enforceable contract is a matter of _law_. That is not something that would be assumed to be true, and is a point that the court may make a decision on at this stage. That is, the court _assumes_ the defendant violated the GPL, but still needed to come to the decision that the defendant _was not allowed_ to violate the GPL. From my brief reading, the court has made the determination that—if the alleged facts are true—the defendant was not allowed to violate the GPL.
- stult 9y agoWell, that's not exactly a fair representation. The court found as a matter of law (not fact) that the GPL is an enforceable contract. 12b6 standards require the court to interpret the facts in the most favorable possible light for the plaintiff. The facts, but not the law. No factual evidence is required for the court to determine whether the GPL can be a legally enforceable contract, so the plaintiff-favorable burden of proof has no bearing on the legal conclusion which is the subject of all this news coverage. The decision being made as a matter of law in a 12b6 motion indicates that the outcome of this particular case still remains uncertain, but that the court would interpret any other GPL in any other case as a legally enforceable contract.
- emmab 9y agoIs this distinction equivalent to satisfiability of the contract wrt any case vs satisfiability of the contract wrt this case? How do you constrain "any case" to something reasonable, or does it need no constraining?