4 ms·
I wouldn't want to be in that office on 'bring your dog to work' day :-) I find these stories fascinating not by what they say about the technology but more wh
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I wouldn't want to be in that office on 'bring your dog to work' day :-)
I find these stories fascinating not by what they say about the technology but more what they say about the state of education in engineering these days and the ability to believe the impossible is possible. I wonder sometimes if someone told these people "if you can imagine it, you can BUILD it!" and they took that statement literally.
There has been a tremendous amount of work in energy harvesting from ambient sources which is really pretty amazing. There was a fun paper on harvesting sound for energy in 2013 [1]. The key of course is how much energy and at what efficiency.
The CEO's point was that if you can charge anywhere you don't need a full charge, you just top off. It would be interesting to see if it can charge while being used (so net positive charge). In the video at least you can see their device for showing the beam footprint.
I'm also wondering "why talk now?" clearly burned by previous skepticism, why not just wait until you have a fully realized product or are they doing a fund raising round and need some outside validation after their disastrous first go?
[1] http://www.enggjournals.com/ijet/docs/IJET13-05-06-118.pdf http://www.enggjournals.com/ijet/docs/IJET13-05-06-118.pdf
- jacquesm 9y agoIf they think they will be able to raise again at that level without proper due diligence then they are smoking some heavy stuff. Anybody worth their fee will come fully equipped to an on-site job like this and will walk out with the required info: a nice set of data points listing power in and power out at a sequence of increasing distances from the transmitter and if they are thorough they do it with two receivers at a 90' angle from each other, and one run with only one receiver dead center. If that delivers meaningful power within the typical usage envelope the tech is real. And of course you get to inspect the guts of the box to avoid 'gotchas' of the battery variety.
- gene-h 9y agoYou can actually buy commercial products that are powered by sound. Sound is actually a pretty great power source for wireless sensor nodes that monitor loud pieces of machinery. Sure, you don't get much power, but for a sensor node you don't need much either. Sometimes sound is the only source of power you can get for such things where it's too dark or parts need to move relative to each making wires difficult. Plus, sometimes you want to monitor the very same vibration that's giving your sensor power. Now the thing that really gets me is some work I saw on developing a vibration powered sensor for highway bridges. So the best power source they found was a small wind turbine. But when they tried them out on a bridge out in the middle of nowhere, the problem was they were just too much of an entertaining object for people to shoot. So they made this rather large pipe with a magnet on springs inside and were able to harvest energy from the low frequency vibrations of the bridge moving around. [0]https://www.microgensystems.com/ https://www.microgensystems.com/ [1]http://www.ni.com/white-paper/12128/en/ http://www.ni.com/white-paper/12128/en/
- jacquesm 9y agoThere even was a company that tried to produce windpower based on that principle (windbelt).