3 ms·
If something had enough inherent interestingness to end up at the #1 position (as this submission is right now), then I'd argue that its taking a number of atte
by derefr 9y ago
If something had enough inherent interestingness to end up at the #1 position (as this submission is right now), then I'd argue that its taking a number of attempts to do so is an indictment of the ranking algorithm for burying it before, rather than an indictment of the author for persisting.
Certainly, if someone persists in trying and the thing just never gets popular, that's just spam. But if "the right timing" was all that was needed to cause the sumission to hit #1? Maybe "the right timing" needs to be a concept built into the submission queue.
- troydavis 9y agoIt's an interesting question. I could see it being a mix of that and a poor-quality ranking algorithm, so that it's too easy for articles to end up buried. Most examples of this are one person submitting daily articles from their own site or sites they're paid to market. Sometimes even those end up near the top of the front page, and often when that happens, if one looks at prior submissions from that same person and site, the article that made the front page seems like it would do worse than prior articles. I could see all of this as an indicator that the ranking/voting doesn't do a great job of letting interesting stuff get a shot, nor of penalizing folks who constantly submit posts on their own site (for months - different than this situation). The "New" page is easy enough to ignore that I could imagine few visitors looking at it regularly, so the profile of visitors to that page is different than to the home page.