3 ms·
Yes, now we can also do best L^1 approximations. IIRC -- I'm in a hurry this morning -- it's a linear programming problem or some such but I haven't thought abo
by graycat 9y ago
Yes, now we can also do
best L^1 approximations.
IIRC -- I'm in a hurry this
morning -- it's a linear
programming problem or
some such but I haven't
thought about that in
decades.
You bring up a lot of stuff
I've never reviewed.
> but that does not mean it is a suitable performance metric to use.
If the plane do the L^2 projection
on is really close, then the
error is really small, and what's
not to like? Really close is
good enough for me.
Right, there are three biggie
choices, L^1 (minimize the
sum of absolute values of the
errors), L^2 (minimize the sum
of squared errors), and L^infinity
(minimize the worst error).
L^2's fine with me, good enough
for government work, okay
first cut, day in and day out.
If in some particular case
L^2 has some problems, then
maybe something like regression
is not the right tool for the
problem.
Gee, we do a lot of L^2:
We get orthogonal components
so that we can get L^2
cafeteria style, just pick the
components we want.
E.g., in filtering stochastic
processes, we take a
Fourier transform -- that
is finding the coefficients
of the sample path on
the sine-cosine orthogonal
components. Or we
do a convolution, which
is the same thing in the
end. The approximation
we get is an L^2 approximation.
So, with JPG -- sure, it's L^2.
Right, JPG does funny stuff
nearly lines. Life's not
perfect!
For some things, sure we
want L^infinity: E.g.,
if we want to use a
quotient of polynomials
to approximate the
usual special functions,
then we want to minimize
the worst error and do
what is called Chebyshev
approximation, but this is
very specialized.
- srean 9y ago> it's a linear programming problem Indeed it is. Lets catchup more sometime. Here's my email again srean.list on gmail Totally agreed there is lot to like about L2 but there are plenty situations where it is terrible (in fact some of them are on one topic of your interest: monitoring server farms). In some of those situations L1 or a combination of L1 and L2 helps a lot.