4 ms·
I think a fair question is whether all that additional expense results in better outcomes. I certainly understand the experience is better for patients, and the
by hn_throwaway_99 9y ago
I think a fair question is whether all that additional expense results in better outcomes. I certainly understand the experience is better for patients, and there is little or no wait time, but is there evidence that health outcomes are actually better?
I wonder if it's like the difference between taking coach vs. a private jet. The private jet is more convenient and comfortable, but safety ratings are considerably better on major airlines.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoI wonder if it's like the difference between taking coach vs. a private jet. The private jet is more convenient and comfortable, but safety ratings are considerably better on major airlines. That's probably what it is, accidents are more likely in general aviation but still rare, however if you must fly commercial you get to face the TSA perverts every single time you go through security.
- sologoub 9y agoI think another way to look at this is minimizing risk/resulting guilt. The broken leg example seems to support that - the father is paying for the best possible care for his son, even if the outcome is the same (leg heals properly) as the ER doctor, the father has obsolved himself of the risk that he didn't do enough and allowed the leg not to heal properly. In other words, the (I'm guessing) relatively slim chance there is a complication with the broken leg is not worth it to the wealthy father to take.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y ago> In other words, the (I'm guessing) relatively slim chance there is a complication with the broken leg is not worth it to the wealthy father to take. In medicine, though, there have been a lot of recent studies recently that have shown that too much care can be harmful (especially in the orthopedic realm). Sometimes the best thing to do really is nothing, but when you're paying 40k a year, my guess is you, and more importantly your doctors, would rarely take that point of view.
- atemerev 9y agoBuses are probably safer than cars, but many people still prefer cars, and willing to take the risks (and these risks are not insignificant). I have survived a near-fatal car crash (as a passenger), but I still drive a car, because in my Bayesian model of reality, convenience just outweighs the risk. The same goes for private jets (which I can't yet afford), or private medicine.
- pauljohncleary 9y agoThis is a really important point, having seen both public and private systems I think it's quite valid. In this case I probably would not want a head of orthopaedics to treat a relatively straightforward leg break- I would want a practitioner who has a significant amount of recent experience in this area. The ER doctor likely sees hundreds of these a year, so may actually be the best person. Of course if my case is particularly challenging, I want a consultant with a significant amount of experience- but it doesn't seem right for that person to pushing their skills to the highest bidder, regardless of patient need. I also don't want a steak with my meal, nor do I care for a fancy waiting room, as they aren't going to fix my leg.