4 ms·
I don't understand why collective bargain is expected on the employer side and reviled on the employee side. If employers can band together to form a company an
by mikeash 9y ago
I don't understand why collective bargain is expected on the employer side and reviled on the employee side. If employers can band together to form a company and present a unified front to the people they pay, why can't the people they pay band together to form a union and also present a unified front?
Why do we trash the very concept of unions because bad ones want to tax robots and such, but don't apply the same standard to companies, when so many of them kill people and poison the planet? If unions are bad because the Teamsters abuse their power, what do entities like Koch Industries, Mylan, or BP tell us about companies?
- Jabanga 9y agoCollective bargaining is never mandatory on the employee side. The employee is not forced to work for a particular collective. The employer on the otherhand is forced, by law, to only hire people who are part of some government-recognized collective, known as a bargaining unit. In other words, employees can monopolize the employer's hiring options, using anti-free-market laws inspired by the 'labour' movement and socialism.
- mikeash 9y agoBeing forced to join a union looks like equality to me. If I want to work at a particular place, I have to join that company. I can't come in on my own, expect to get paid, but not be a part of the company that runs the place. Why should the union be any different? If an employee doesn't want to work for a particular company, they have to find a different place to work. If an employee doesn't want to join a particular union, they have to find a different place to work. Why is the former reasonable but not the latter? If an employer really wants to hire non-union labor, they can leave their company and join a different one that doesn't have a union. You're playing an interesting semantic trick here where you use "employee" to refer to the individual, but "employer" to refer to the company. You thereby paint the asymmetry as unfair, when in fact there's no expectation that they should be the same. Let's compare individuals to individuals (laborers to management, say) and groups to groups (companies to unions). Why do the arguments against unions not also apply to companies? Give me something where if I replace "union" with "company" the result isn't an equally compelling argument against not letting employers organize collectively.
- altstar 9y agoThe relationship between you as an employee and employer is totally different than you and a (potential) union. The one is paying you a salary for certain work done. The other is to (potentially) help you to negotiate better working conditions. You are absolutely making no sense at all.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> The one is paying you a salary for certain work done. The other is to (potentially) help you to negotiate better working conditions That's like saying that the role of elected officials is to represent their constituents and serve their interests, treating them all with full equality under the law. It's a nice statement, but it's completely idealistic and doesn't accurately describe what actually happens in practice.
- testrun 9y agowtf? You work for a salary and you join a union if you want better working conditions and believe that is the only way to get it. This is not rocket science. What does politics have to do with it?
- mikeash 9y agoAs an employee, the union is an organization you belong to which works to further your interests, and the company is an outside organization in a hopefully symbiotic relationship, where you provide them with things they want, and they provide you with things you want. As an employer, the company is an organization you belong to which works to further your interests, and the union is an outside organization in a hopefully symbiotic relationship, where you provide them with things they want, and they provide you with things you want. I am not saying that an employee has the same relationship with their union and their company. I'm saying that when you break it down into employee/employer and company/union, it becomes fairly symmetrical. Look at the individuals on both sides, and then at the organizations on both sides. If one side shouldn't band together, why should the other side do so?
- InclinedPlane 9y agoThat's not how unions work in the US.
- metaphor 9y agoFeel free to enlighten us anytime. The parent has accurately described my experience, and I'm in the US.
- metaphor 9y ago>> If employers can band together to form a company and present a unified front to the people they pay... How does this statement even make any sense? IANAL, but I'm interpretting this as deliberately conflating the term employers with people within a company whose duties include making hiring decisions--themselves employees.
- mikeash 9y agoUnion : worker :: company : _______. What would you like to put in the blank? I'm using the term "employer" there but I'm happy to switch to something better.