2 ms·
> At my university (SFU, in Canada) admission to most faculties is based on high school grades Do you not interview the applicants though? I think the best thi
by chrisseaton 9y ago
> At my university (SFU, in Canada) admission to most faculties is based on high school grades
Do you not interview the applicants though? I think the best thing to do is to set a basic requirement for grades from their highschool, then get people in and ask them to take your own tests and give them an interview with one of the teaching staff to make your own judgement about whether they're suitable or not.
Accepting someone to be your student for four years without ever having met them is as crazy as any other problems.
- cperciva 9y agoWe're a public university admitting over 7,000 students per year. There simply aren't the resources to interview students... not to mention the fact that SFU competes with other institutions and would likely lose a large number of students if we required them to come in for interviews.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoif you don't have the resources to interview them how can you have the resources to teach them?
- barrkel 9y agoAs we all know, people never judge based on looks or accent or verbal word choice. We select for talent even if it's from someone with a different culture and social mileau to us, right?
- chrisseaton 9y agoWell there's no need to be so sarcastic and snarky. I did say some universities administer their own tests, so that's as objective as a test normally can be (not perfect), and probably more objective than one administered across different schools as people have already said. I don't think it would be unreasonable to combine that with an interview. Teaching is a personal thing - academics will want to check that they can teach you and you're able to learn from them. The best university interviews I did were like a short teaching session and I came away with an opinion about who I wanted to learn from as much as I presume they had an opinion about who they wanted to spend their time teaching.
- yorwba 9y ago> Teaching is a personal thing May I ask where you had that experience? Throughout my undergraduate degree, most classes had hundreds, some more than thousand students. There was barely any opportunity for individual interactions.