3 ms·
> illegal, and very pathological Pathological, certainly; "illegal"?
by JoshTriplett 9y ago
> illegal, and very pathological
Pathological, certainly; "illegal"?
- bitwize 9y agoMost aspects of Tetris's appearance and gameplay are protected by copyrights and trademarks owned by The Tetris Company LLC. This includes trademarks on the shape of the tetrominoes, the suffix "-tris", and the use of the Russian folksong Korobeiniki in a video game. In their copyright-infringement case against Xio Interactive, a judge ruled that aspects of the game such as the dimensions of the game board (which the HATETRIS developer took pains to replicate) are protected by copyright. Tetris is one of the most aggressively defended game IPs out there. Any recognizable clone of it is potentially infringing.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoThere are thousands of clones out there, both for-profit and otherwise, and the vast majority have not been pursued. Trademarks on the shapes of "tetrominoes" are questionable (you can't trademark a purely functional element, though you could potentially trademark a particular stylization of it or use of it in a logo). Copyright on game rules is questionable as well, and whether it'd apply in any particular case would depend on both jurisdiction and any potential fair use claims; there's a long history of cloning games, without using any of the original art or other assets. Pretty much the only bit that's more clearly problematic is the use of "-tris" as a suffix; GNOME's version was renamed from "gnometris" to "quadrapassel" for exactly that reason. I certainly wouldn't give such aggressive behavior any unwarranted credence by presumptively calling a clone "illegal"; on the contrary, I cheer on creative developments like this.
- jacobolus 9y agoYour summary is what the developers of the iPhone app Mino thought (they were some friends of mine; I drew the graphics for the game, and got sucked into several hours of deposition for the case to explain how I had chosen the colors from first principles, etc.). But the judge ruled otherwise, as the GP poster described. Theoretically game rules cannot be protected in this way, but if you draw the wrong judge, too bad for you. Unless you have several years to kill and the $lots required to take a case up through every level of appeals where you still might lose in the end, I recommend against building a for-profit Tetris-like game.
- bitwize 9y agoAtari v. Phillips. Look it up. Games which are "substantially similar" to other games infringe copyright. It doesn't matter if the assets and code are all original, etc. This is settled copyright law.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoAlready familiar with it; doesn't make it right, or justifiable. And there's plenty of case law in both directions on reverse engineering and cloning; the exact boundary would depend heavily on the details of a specific case. In any case, it'd also be much harder to prove any harm caused by a variant like this, which is designed specifically to be un-fun, as difficult as possible, look nothing like the original, and not have any commercial interest at all. Which makes the presumption of illegality entirely inappropriate.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]