3 ms·
Interesting perspective. The statement about youths is certainly borderline in terms of disparagement — it's designed to show that there's a fine line between d
by gnicholas 9y ago
Interesting perspective. The statement about youths is certainly borderline in terms of disparagement — it's designed to show that there's a fine line between descriptiveness and disparagement in some cases. It is an indisputable fact that young people have less life experience than older people; it is a logical leap to say that younger people ought not be able to vote because of this.
The last two statements, which target ethnic/religious minorities, were structured differently to be crisp — but I think that if you create analogs to 1-3 using these groups, the result would be the same:
1b) "Black celebrity X shouldn't try to compare her life experience to that of poor urban whites — her opinions are uninformed and irrelevant."
2b) "Hijabs create distractions in an education environment and should not be worn in public schools" (as is the case in France)
3b) "Old people are more likely to have dementia and should have to take a cognitive test before allowed to vote"
These are structured like the original 1-3, and I think each would elicit a very negative reaction from many people (including those who work at YouTube). Do you think the policy offers a rationale for treating 1b-3b differently from 1-3?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Do you think the policy offers a rationale for treating 1b-3b differently from 1-3? Potentially (assuming, arguendo, that all are viewed as being disparaging, which I still think is dubious in all 6 cases—if they aren't, then there is no basis for different treatment and none are actually problematic under the policy), and I already explained the reading that the policy language admits that supports this in the grandparent post.
- gnicholas 9y agoI guess we have different senses of what is considered disparaging. Appreciate seeing your perspective!