4 ms·
So, if, let's say, one knows all the relevant mathematics, how much is left as the (theoretical) physics proper? I mean, sure, we have all these fundamental con
by Koshkin 9y ago
So, if, let's say, one knows all the relevant mathematics, how much is left as the (theoretical) physics proper? I mean, sure, we have all these fundamental constants and elementary particles to learn about, but is there anything else that is essentially physics and not math?
- sidlls 9y agoThere is the entire half of physics that is the empirical verification of the hypotheses left, for example. Theoretical physics cannot be separated from that, in my view.
- Koshkin 9y ago> Theoretical physics cannot be separated from that Sure, but books on theoretical physics seem to rarely mention empirical verification. It's mostly math, and I am not sure what is left if you remove it (as known).
- ice109 9y agoas physics student you quickly come to figure out that physical intuition is not the same as mathematical intuition. there are many hacks (for lack of a better term) in physics that a mathematician would've never been able to come up with because they're physically intuitive but not mathematically (a famous example is the Feynman path integral)
- Koshkin 9y agoRight, we know that much of mathematics grew from physics, but the question remains: what is there in the known theoretical physics that is not (applied) math? (Well, I think I may already know the answer: nothing; but it does not matter, because science is not about what is known...)