6 ms·
You don't think you're jumping the gun here, maybe? Do you even know what the compensation will be? >Instead of paying their employees a living wage, or offer
by SilasX 9y ago
You don't think you're jumping the gun here, maybe? Do you even know what the compensation will be?
>Instead of paying their employees a living wage, or offering benefits befitting a delivery driver,
Obviously you can criticize Walmart's current practices. The issue is whether this policy is any worse than what they had before.
>they can offset all of the risk, deprecation costs, etc associated with delivering a package all for the low cost of what amounts to a tiny raise in their existing payroll.
Do you give the same objection to every other company that pays for mileage for work-related travel? Is that also "shunting off depreciation costs"?
Why are you assuming that they won't have an insurance policy for such deliveries or pay for mileage like every other company?
Edit: clarified which part was responding to what
- zorked 9y ago> You don't think you're jumping the gun here, maybe? Do you even know what the compensation will be? Walmart is known for high wages.
- x0x0 9y agoIf only we had some patterns of previous behavior towards employees at Walmart from which we could make inferences about whether the deal offered (well, eventually, this will be "offered" to employees, ie totally optional, unless you want to keep your job) will be a fair deal or exploitative.
- atom-morgan 9y agoI made a few dollars above minimum wage when I was 18 before I started college. Not much on my resume other than similar jobs expected of someone in highschool. I was very happy with my job there.
- downrightmike 9y agoAre you already zorked this early on a Friday? Then why are so many of walmart's employees on social benefits? https://www.thenation.com/article/walmart-wages-are-the-main-reason-people-depend-on-food-stamps/ https://www.thenation.com/article/walmart-wages-are-the-main...
- throwanem 9y agoSarcasm, I'm guessing.
- smileysteve 9y agoIf it is, then that needs to be clarified; because for its industry and the "local" general stores it is replacing, Walmart pays more per hour. For the Uber/Ubereats and other gig economy estimates, $11/hr is well above the industry take home. Walmart is in progress of raising it's minimum wage to $11/hr, 22% more than federal $7.25 minimum wage. The Times covered this in the past https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/20/business/walmart-raising-wage-to-at-least-9-dollars.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/20/business/walmart-raising-...
- choward 9y agoBefore graduating college, the most money I made was working for Walmart at a distribution center. I made $19.20 an hour which was pretty good considering minimum wage was just over $5.
- rbanffy 9y agoCan anyone actually live on $40 a day?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- smileysteve 9y agoThe poster's point is that $19.20 is significantly above the federal minimum wage and what Walmart is legally required to pay. I want to emphasize in this context (gig delivery) that the recent UberEats Stockholm posting indicated even less than $5/hr.
- phamilton 9y agoCertainly in a place like Boise, ID. That's $800/month, $704 after tax. Rent with roommates will run around $300/month. Food is $150/month ($5/day). That leaves $250/month for misc expenditures. It would absolutely be tight, but people can and do live on that much.
- lghh 9y agoHope you never get sick and have to call in, your car never breaks down, and you never have a medical emergency!
- mythrwy 9y agoIf you get seriously sick 3X (5 time even) that amount won't save you. But as things stand now you'd have free(ish) healthcare anyway. Car? What car? You are walking, biking, riding the bus. It's doable, barely, just barely and there will be troubles if anything comes up.
- hdhdjjdjd7773 9y agoBuild your life around Walmart, friends! It's more do it for the team, keeping people that already struggle from having time for other pursuits. It's manipulative of their desire to be a little better off, when they could be already if Waltons took some of daddies money and paid them better in the first place. Time is the most valuable asset a human has. And Walmart can manipulate the lesser haves to support their interests
- leggomylibro 9y agoYou're right that I don't know all the details, but I know how Walmart tends to behave with regards to their workers, and I know that the system their proposing looks unusually ripe for abuse, to the point where it seems like it must have been intentional. I'm tired of people wrapping shit in a pretty bow and trying to pass it off as a gift. It keeps happening, and people keep going along with it. Maybe this time we'll unwrap the policy to find a nugget of gold, but fool me umpteen times...
- aaron-lebo 9y agoWhat do you propose? I'm against exploitation of workers, too, but at the end of the day there is only so much you can do with jobs that require relatively unskilled labor. If a 15 year old can do your job as well as you can after a few months of training, it's not a safe job that you can expect anything out of. It's gonna get automated away anyway. But here Walmart (whatever their other faults), offers a way for workers to make money doing something they already have to (thus it has more utility than their normal role), and they're evil? If people's regular jobs paid a "living wage", people wouldn't have to Uber, but it's how the world works. Kind of damned if you do damned if you don't isn't it?
- sangnoir 9y ago> If a 15 year old can do your job as well as you can after a few months of training, it's not a safe job that you can expect anything out of Yet there is a world of a difference between Walmart jobs and Costco jobs. Unemployment in the US is lower than some countries with better worker's rights. > If people's regular jobs paid a "living wage", people wouldn't have to Uber, but it's how the world works No, not the world, mostly just the US. For the rest of the world, the line between employment and unemployment is not so bad that you have people with full-time jobs and still need food stamps. I feel that setup is a covert government subsidy to corporates. But hey, we shouldn't mess with the "job-creaters", right? Or else.
- oxide 9y agoIf you work at Walmart, you've got fuck all to show for it. Working at Costco sounds like a dream in direct comparison. Benefits, decent pay, etc. Hell, they have an entire wall dedicated to employees of the month that go way back. It's funny how a little goodwill towards your workers seems to have a ripple effect, making shopping at Costco a lot less stressful since the workers are relaxed and happy, willing to small talk while they ring ya up, the managment is roaming around managing, etc. Being treated like a suspect for visiting the pharmacy without a membership card is my big gripe with Costco. However we just transferred my grandparents stuff to a better, more competent pharmacy. Now I have no gripes.
- Spooky23 9y agoThey currently don't use retail employees to deliver stuff. So you can't compare these practices. As someone who is probably a professional salaried employee somewhere, it's hard to think about why this is bad. When you're stuck in one of these gigs, you need to be in good with the floor managers to get hours -- those folks control you because they have the power to starve you out with limited hours or "on call" shifts (i.e. you wait around and be ready to report to work within 15-20 minutes), or just fuck you over by assigning you impossible shifts and firing you for attendance issues. So it's pretty much a given that if you are that guy who doesn't agree to deliver crap on the way home, you're not going to be around for long. They are replacing UPS/Fedex/USPS for a reason -- cutting corners on things like insurance, depreciation, etc allows them to make an incredible inefficient operating model cheaper.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoFrom further down this thread: https://techcrunch.com/2017/06/01/walmart-begins-testing-using-store-staff-for-last-mile-deliveries/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/06/01/walmart-begins-testing-usi... Workers also have to ... provide proof of insurance. This is exactly the same as everything else gig-economy, the money is made by offloading risk onto the unsuspecting.
- maxxxxx 9y ago" You don't think you're jumping the gun here, maybe? Do you even know what the compensation will be?" Judging from the way most companies compensate their employees for extra work I bet it won't be much. Just a guess.
- a3n 9y ago> Why are you assuming that they won't have an insurance policy for such deliveries or pay for mileage like every other company? The fact that they're piggy backing on employees going home, regardless of extra pay, tells me that they're doing this on the cheap. If this part is on the cheap, there's no reason to assume that the rest isn't. Win win!
- lkjasdsdf7877 9y agoDon't be naive; it's the Walton's and a corporation with one of the worst track records of abuse towards their employees. They have highly paid number crunchers figuring this out. HN exists in a decision bubble because they're not party do it. Guaranteed this is the cheapest option and they'll use the Uber model of letting the employee swing in the breeze if things go wrong for them.