3 ms·
Lots of confusion in all the posts about OneLogin - they are not a password manager like lastpass, they are a Single Sign-On (SSO) and Identity Provider, meanin
by manigandham 9y ago
Lots of confusion in all the posts about OneLogin - they are not a password manager like lastpass, they are a Single Sign-On (SSO) and Identity Provider, meaning they integrate with other services, maintain a master directory of all users, and provide a single login UI for all connected apps.
Companies use OneLogin so employees have 1 service to enter their credentials and can then use federated access to apps like Google, Office 365, Salesforce, etc without signing in again, most often connected via SAML which uses public/private keys. The identity provider can also be external, so for example users can sign-in via the OneLogin UI but the username/password are actually authenticated against Office 365 Active Directory instead.
- jeffnolan 9y agoit's a semantic argument. You are not storing passwords in an SSO service, but it is passing tokens to authenticate access based on the asserting/relying relationship between IdP and app. The reason I say it is semantic is that while you are not storing passwords, you are sitting on a trove of access credentials. What is different about an SSO app that is of huge value is that cutting off access is not a function of changing passwords at the app level. I think we agree on all the major points here, but I would not diminish the significance based on the fact that OneLogin is not a password vault.
- manigandham 9y agoIt's a purely informational comment about what the service is, not about the significance of the security breach. Any identity related service, especially one that also includes password manager and desktop login functionality along with secure notes, etc. being involved in something like this is a major issue. We were looking at using them but have decided to stick with Google instead.
- EduardoBautista 9y agoOneLogin also stores passwords like 1Password. I used to work there.
- idunno246 9y agoThe other big thing is lots of saas companies don't implement multiple users per company initially, so you end up with a google doc with all the shared passwords of things like analytics/ads providers. This way you get a unique login, acls, etc by hiding the shared password inside onelogin I've used these, but refused to put more important things like aws in there.
- sbarre 9y agoFrom reading many articles, it seems that OneLogin does have a service called "Password Cache", which sounds to me like a cache for passwords, perhaps for storing credentials to sites that do not have SSO.. See here: https://support.onelogin.com/hc/en-us/articles/201175264-Password-Management https://support.onelogin.com/hc/en-us/articles/201175264-Pas... If they are storing the password and pushing it to the connected service on the user's behalf, then they have to be able to decrypt it somehow, and if the bad actor was able to intercept and decrypt data within the platform, then that may have included passwords stored using this mechanism perhaps
- stcredzero 9y agoIf they are storing the password and pushing it to the connected service on the user's behalf, then they have to be able to decrypt it somehow By storing so many passwords in one system, they made that system a high value target, all while not having the security chops they thought they had. Password vaults should be distributed. This prevents the conglomeration of password secrets that creates a high value target. They would've been wise to have a series of password vault apps that are integrated with their system. They could have done this by leveraging Password Safe.
- jacquesm 9y agoThis is by far the best argument for decentralization of almost anything that is not meant to be public. You probably will lose some of it but at least you won't lose all of it.
- danbruc 9y agoIf they are storing the password and pushing it to the connected service on the user's behalf, then they have to be able to decrypt it somehow [...] But not necessarily all of them all the time. The decryption key could be derived from the master password of each user and only kept around while the user is logged in.
- sbarre 9y ago