4 ms·
It's ... very complicated. In most situations, as long as the transaction has a reasonable fee attached to it, you can proceed immediately (this is called a 0-
by CydeWeys 9y ago
It's ... very complicated. In most situations, as long as the transaction has a reasonable fee attached to it, you can proceed immediately (this is called a 0-conf transaction), as you can be pretty sure that it will be confirmed eventually. Of course, there are some transaction malleability edge cases that allow double-spends that are fixed with a new feature called segwit that hasn't rolled out yet, so if you are dealing with a potentially malicious party then 0-conf isn't good enough.
In theory, you should wait for a transaction to have at least six confirmations on it before truly trusting it. That has always taken an average of an hour from the transaction first going into a block. It's the "first going into a block" part that takes longer now, unless you attach a higher fee to ensure that it goes in quickly.
- annabellish 9y ago>as long as the transaction has a reasonable fee attached to it, you can proceed immediately (this is called a 0-conf transaction) Not true. A 0-conf transaction is a transaction which has not been confirmed at all, which is orthogonal to its fee. A transaction with a reasonable fee may not even be confirmed at all, as it only takes a few days to fall out of every mempool and average fees are currently unreasonable, so it is not safe to trust 0-conf transactions currently as they may never make it on-chain.
- CydeWeys 9y agoIf a transaction fails to be confirmed for several days, then its fee was by definition not reasonable; it was too small. A fee significantly smaller than the average fee on transactions making it into blocks is unreasonably small.
- rtb 9y agoBy that definition, your first comment was a meaningless tautology. If a "reasonable" fee is one that causes a transaction to be accepted, then your first comment can be rewritten as: "as long as the transaction [will be confirmed within several days], you can be pretty sure that it will be confirmed eventually".
- CydeWeys 9y agoYou can tell, based on the fee, whether it's sufficient for the transaction to be confirmed soon, and if so, accept it immediately. This isn't hard, and I don't believe that you didn't actually understand it. I don't understand what value your replies have added.
- grandalf 9y agoThe question to ask is why are the fees high? Because the demand for faster transactions is very high. While this seems like a technical glitch to some, it is easily addressed using traditional finance techniques or via side chains. Fees exist to incentivize miners to participate, and so "unreasonably high" fees should result in more miners participating and fees going down. Due to the scale of Bitcoin, adding non-trivially to the mining capacity takes a pretty massive investment, so we should expect a gradual correction. Overall this is a good thing because it enhances the overall cryptosystem significantly while clearly signaling (via the price) what needs to happen. While it is tempting to solve this technocratically, I'd argue that institutional stability (even if it seems a bit like calcification) is extremely valuable to the formation of long term incentives and risk-taking for the ecosystem as a whole.
- nas 9y agoMore miners will not make the fees go down. The limited resource is space in each block, currently 1 MB. Having more miners does not increase the block size. It would be nice to have a proper economic feedback mechanism on this, e.g. miners decide how big to make the block based on how high the fees are getting. However, the costs for big blocks are externalized and so I think miners would make blocks as big as possible to capture as many fees as possible. The cost of storing those blocks in perpetuity costs the whole Bitcoin ecosystem. I consider this a major crisis for Bitcoin as with current fees, the system is not very useful. The original thinking was that block sizes could be increased a lot and provide transaction rates that match what credit card companies can do. Current Bitcoin core developers and miners can't seem to increase the block size, each blames the other for inaction. Some suggest the core team is mostly controlled by Blockstream and their business model depends on expensive transactions forcing people to use their Lightning network instead. Miners are fine with high fees as long as the Bitcoin price doesn't collapse. I don't know how this will play out. Perhaps some clever idea will come forth to solve the scaling problems. If so, Bitcoin should continue to be adopted and rise in price. If things say deadlocked, I could see Bitcoin wither away as other crypto-coins do the same job but for lower transaction fees.
- grandalf 9y ago
- theparanoid 9y agoNot sure why annabellish's comment is dead. It's not wrong. One of the Darknet markets raised their min product price to $3 because of the transaction fee problem.
- isubkhankulov 9y agowaiting for 6 was published as part of the original whitepaper. the hash power is a different level now. i would argue waiting for 2-3 is fine.
- fmax30 9y agoDoesn't taking an hour or more to confirm a transaction basically make bitcoin useless for any real-time transactions ( buying something at a shopping mall, buying fast food/coffee etc) This makes bitcoin much less useful in my personal opinion.
- cyphar 9y agoThat's not the worst of it. The transaction fee is enormous, something like ~$5 and is even larger if you consider the amount of wasted mining power trying to mint a new block (that number peaked at ~$100 per transaction a year ago). IMO we really should be pushing for GNU Taler, which is a system that doesn't have proof of work, is confirmed effectively immediately, and has many more privacy properties similar to cash. It works by having a mint sell customers coins (using whatever standard method of payment you like), the customer spends coins on merchants and then the merchants can redeem the coins for "real" money. In particular, customers cannot be identified (nor can their transaction history) but merchants' income can be identified (for tax reasons). As the system doesn't require proof-of-work the speed problem is massively reduced as well as the transaction cost.
- CydeWeys 9y agoTaler isn't a decentralized currency though, so what's the point? It doesn't seem much better than using a credit card, but at least my credit card is already accepted everywhere.
- cyphar 9y agoYour credit card has a history of all of your transactions (and we know that data is used to profile you). Taler makes it so that your transaction history is private. In addition, Taler is _federated_ not fully decentralised. It works basically how cash works, except you don't need to be a new country to set up a new currency. In order for a particular mint's cash to be spent you only need that mint to be around. I don't get why "decentralised or bust" is the end goal. Federation with individual privacy is still an improvement over centralised credit card companies. Also, like it or not, but Taler has much better privacy guarantees than BitCoin.