10 ms·
The young Japanese working themselves to death
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Nearly a quarter of Japanese companies have employees working more than 80 hours overtime a month, often unpaid, a recent survey found. And 12% have employees breaking the 100 hours a month mark." This is not uncommon in the US either, in the finance industry, at startups, at much bigger competitive companies, in medicine. I'm actually surprised there isn't more suicide, burnout, and depression from overwork in the US, or maybe the people just aren't as open about it in the US as they are in Japan.
- wapz 9y agoWorking in Japan for a Japanese company I hope to give some insight. I find most people in America that worked overtime felt that it was necessary to work because of all the tasks that needed to be completed. In Japan the overtime seems more "required" just to work overtime (not always the case of course). I think Americans get a lot more self-satisfaction when they finish their overtime shift (although they don't like it they know it was something that needed to be done). I think there's a lot of stress and depression in the states from overwork (not as much depression from my group of friends), but not as much as Japan for a few reasons. One guess is that I find people in America more social than Japanese. Most of the "friends" relationships I see in Japan are more-so forced as they are coworkers who just go together and drink. I could be completely wrong here but I feel like they don't share their feelings and talk to reduce stress/depression as much as Americans. One last thing about overtime is I feel most US companies have bursts of overtime when work needs to get done. Japanese companies often just have "permanent" overtime setting the mentality that they will be doing it forever.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoWhat would happen if, as an American, I came into my job in Japan, worked my 40 hours a week, and went home each night at 5?
- bruxis 9y agoThat's probably not a fair question, given that you're an American. There's immediately some difference in expectations. A better question is what happens if a young college grad in Japan chooses work no unnecessary overtime?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoRight! What happens in this scenario? How does this cycle get broken?
- patio11 9y agoWhat happens in this scenario? N=1 anecdote from a traditionally managed Japanese company. If you (a twenty-something Japanese man) happen to say お先に失礼します。(announcing you're leaving) at 6:00 PM in front of the company's CEO during a site visit, and the CEO says, in a shocked voice, "I suppose you have somewhere more important to be right now.", and you say "Yes, I'm going on a date.", you can look forward to six months of nuclear-tipped ostracism from your colleagues and, when you complain to management about it, they will tell you "[Foreign employee] is more Japanese than you are; ask him."
- glandium 9y agoThe interesting thing is that this kind of scenario (young people wanting to leave early for $reason) happen more and more, and older people put that on the Yutori education. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yutori_education https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yutori_education
- laurieg 9y agoBest case scenario: passed over for promotions, cut out of important work discussions, generally ostracized. Worst case scenario: outright abuse. Just to give you a taste of this: In a previous job in Japan there was a work party on the weekend. I told my boss "I can't got, I have something to do" (A very normal way to refuse something in Japan. The expectation is that no one will ask what your vague reason is). This boss tries to pin me down on exactly why I won't be spending my day off on this event. This leads to 6 months of going over my work with a fine tooth comb, review periods and so on.
- nandemo 9y ago> This is not uncommon in the US either, in the finance industry, at startups, at much bigger competitive companies, in medicine. Is it anywhere near 25% of the US companies, though? I doubt it. Finance and startups are high-risk, high-return endeavors. It's one thing to work 80 hours of overtime as a trader/VP/software engineer earning good money, having a sense of autonomy and accomplishment, etc. And if you quit or your startup fails, you can always get another job, change fields or even take a break. It won't be a black mark against you. It's a very different thing to work 80 hours of unpaid overtime as a courier [0], with no autonomy and virtually no career progression. Sure, you can quit. But the perception is, "why would I quit if the alternative is just a different delivery sweatshop?". FWIW professions/companies that have strong unions tend to have less problems with unpaid overtime, but they're a minority. [0] http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2017/03/04/business/corporate-business/yamato-cough-unpaid-overtime/ http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2017/03/04/business/corpora...
- vatotemking 9y ago> "If you don't quit you have to work 100 hours. If you quit you just can't live." Perhaps the root of the problem is the high cost of living, no?
- kentt 9y agoI think it's more cultural than efficient. Working more than 60 hours for most people results in no added outputs.
- Paulods 9y agoRarely as a Japanese businessman can you quit a job and find another job at either the same or higher pay grade. The market here revolves around hiring university graduates up to a year before they graduate and then training them from the start in whatever position you want them to do. Very few people change jobs and if you jump from jobs every 3-5 years its seen a negative sign on your CV.
- guy_c 9y agoA few thoughts as a foreign worker in a Japanese startup: * Foreigners get more leeway. I have colleagues that do a strict 40 hours/week. * The overtime culture isn't strictly enforced. It comes about organically. Your team agrees to deliver a task with a tight deadline. You can go home early, but your colleagues will unquestioningly pick up the slack. Instead of them leaving the office at 10pm, now they stay to midnight. It is easy to feel guilty about leaving at reasonable time. * There is a lot of praise and admiration for the employees that demonstrate hard work. * There seems to be an unwritten rule that you stay till your boss goes home. Teams where the boss works a reasonable schedule, also seem to work reasonable hours. If you have a workaholic boss with no personal life then you are in trouble. * For a lot of young Japanese it appears their colleagues are their only social circle. * There is a lot of after-work demands on your time. It is common to have work-related dinners and drinks.
- mathattack 9y agoI've experienced a lot of the same. Work and social life blend. And it's a loss of face to one's family to come home early every day. (Not important enough to work hard?)
- winter_blue 9y ago> Not important enough to work hard? That's a fascinating (but sad) cultural value. Normally (in most prosperous countries) if you cared about your family, you'd come home early to spend time with them. Your spouse and kids put far more value on the time you spend building your relationship with them, hanging out/chilling with them, over any extra material/monetary gain you could bring them. After a certain point, money doesn't bring you any happiness. If you have enough money to cover basic expenses, then your happiness is mostly going to be determined by the quality and depth of your human relationships, your social life, your community, etc. I feel that this line of thinking (excessively working for your family) is something that makes sense in poorer/developing countries like India and China, but it seems like a bad cultural artifact/holdover in relatively wealthy country Japan.
- 9y ago
- malydok 9y agoPersonal anecdote. Last month my japanese friend in his late 30's collapsed from a stroke. He is a freelance (!) Web developer I collaborated with and I didn't know that before the accident but he used to work overnight without any sleep. Given his chain-smoking, drinking hectoliters of coffee and a sedentary lifestyle it's hard to miss the causes but still I wonder if just getting sleep could have prevented it to some degree. Now after 3 weeks of induced coma he's slowly regaining consciousness, though how much he will be able to is still unknown.
- foota 9y agoI'm sorry about your friend, I wish for them a good recovery.
- zhemao 9y agoAll of the government's attempts to address this excessive overwork just seems lackluster. > Earlier this year the government introduced 'Premium Fridays', encouraging firms to let their employees out early, at 3pm, on the last Friday each month. They also want Japanese workers to take more holiday. That's a single digit number of hours every month. It's meaningless if workers are still doing massive amounts of unpaid overtime. > Earlier this year the government proposed limiting average overtime to 60 hours a month though firms would be allowed to up this to 100 hours during "busy periods" - well into the karoshi red zone. And suddenly every period is a "busy period". > Critics say the government is prioritizing business and economic interests at the expense of the welfare of workers. Not even. I'm sure they could actually be more productive if they weren't literally working their employees to death. Here's an idea. Make companies pay extra compensation if employees work overtime. I guarantee you companies will be literally pushing their employees out the door at 6 PM then.
- meric 9y agosingle digit number At least it's likely a high single digit.
- patio11 9y agoMake companies pay extra compensation if employees work overtime. This is the standard practice at many (but not all) Japanese companies with an overtime culture. "Service overtime" (サービス残業) -- uncompensated overtime -- is widely perceived to be abusive, and the abusiveness of this practice is deployed by defenders of the status quo as "We're not abusive; we paid every one of those 80 hours at time and a quarter." It's priced into the expectations, literally -- my offer letter from my previous employer in Japan had two columns in it, the "formal offer" and the "offer assuming overtime pay[+]", with the number quoted at me being the total salary inclusive of their estimate of overtime. (30 hours of compensated overtime a month.) (This was... ahem... an optimistic estimate.)
- rimliu 9y agoI was going to ask "optimistic-in what way?" but then I realised that 30hours a month makes for about 1.5hour a day, so the number of overtime hours was most likely very underestimated…
- euske 9y agoThe story is doubly sad because a) the family often couldn't prevent their children's death, and b) the companies don't want to admit how bad Japanese productivity is and keep resisting the changes.
- charia 9y agoObligatory posting of the best piece of writing discussing Japanese workplace culture anywhere on the internet. http://www.kalzumeus.com/2014/11/07/doing-business-in-japan/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2014/11/07/doing-business-in-japan/
- patio11 9y agoThanks for the praise, though I think that might oversell my blog a bit.
- pcthrowaway 9y agoNot in the least, that piece has really stuck with me over the years. Thank you for writing it and thanks to OP for sharing it again.
- shaunling 9y agoJapanese are hardworking and produce quality goods & services. Sometimes they may overworked. Sad to hear that
- peterburkimsher 9y agoThis happens in New York as well. What if we could hear from the people suffering from this directly? We can. Earlier today, a post showed up here about John. It was flagged. I expect my comment to also be moderated, which will reinforce my feelings of being ignored by the world. https://github.com/yeukhon/suicide https://github.com/yeukhon/suicide I investigated what's happening to him, and empathise with a lot of his struggles. We're overworked, underpaid, ignored, and rejected by the government. https://twitter.com/y3ukhon https://twitter.com/y3ukhon He's got excellent work experience for Mozilla, and a good degree. Working for a tech company in New York. What's bad about that? - He's still asking for a second job on weekends just to make ends meet. May 22: "What part time job would allow me to work on Friday - Sunday with some rest in between? Need one so I can make up some cash." - He can't afford anything more than a tiny room: Apr 13: "if only @LifeOnPurple can release a full size mattress tonight I'd be able to purchase >_< my bedroom can't take a Queen size. #mattress" - He cares about the world, but it makes him poor (me too - refusing to work for weapons manufacturers or oil companies has seriously limited my scope of potential jobs) Apr 5: "I'd be interested in working at places where I can exercise social responsibility and making industry standard salary. Too hard." - He's bored at work, probably because managers don't give him enough to do, or don't care enough to simply talk to him. ] Mar 28: "When I don't seem to do much or making huge progress at work I wonder am I the new fossil at work? At age of 25? Really?" - He can't get insurance (me too) because of systematic mistreatment of foreigners by the government (me too): Mar 5: I write software so I am denied for vision coverage. I am Chinese so I am denied for liver coverage. #preexistingconditions
- majormajor 9y ago> - He can't get insurance (me too) because of systematic mistreatment of foreigners by the government (me too): > Mar 5: I write software so I am denied for vision coverage. I am Chinese so I am denied for liver coverage. #preexistingconditions Could you go into more details about this? Many of the others sound like very sad combo of really bad fit between city + job + goals, but the insurance stuff on an employer plan at a large company is news to me. Vision coverage usually isn't the most useful thing in the world (the expenses are too predictable), but I've still never been denied it and always have had employers that offer it, and I have no experience being foreign to speak to that, but again, even pre-Obamacare employer plans I saw for middle-class+ jobs usually had some level of preexisting condition coverage (generally along the lines of "if your insurance has lapsed for 3+ months, then there's a 6-12month waiting period for coverage specific to that condition") and my foreign co-workers didn't seem to be on a different set of plans than anyone else.
- shubhamjain 9y agoTo give a perspective, a Japanese corporation, as a part of country-wide effort to address the work pressure problem, had to give bonuses to make their employees leave early [1]. I don't know what drives the Japanese Salarymen but I believe they are insanely committed towards their job. It doesn't seem most of the Japanese salarymen even complain about the overwork. [1]: http://www.bbc.com/capital/story/20170413-we-had-to-give-them-bonuses-to-leave-early http://www.bbc.com/capital/story/20170413-we-had-to-give-the...
- laurieg 9y agoIt's a bit of a stereotype but: Unhappy home-lives. If you're going back to an abusive spouse, a crowded house with inlaws and kids, no privacy at all or other problems, I can see why some people might hide at work.
- zhemao 9y agoYour spouse hates you because you work all the time. You work all the time to avoid your spouse.
- watwut 9y agoDoes not even need to be abusive. If you are working that much and your spouse is all the time at home (e.g. completely different lifestyle, habits and everything), the relationship is bound to be hard.
- a_imho 9y agoI don't understand people working overtime. You sign a contract of typically 40 hours/week. Anything over that timeframe you can reject. Trying to force you or threaten firing you over it is not particularly legal. Showing up in court with a few emails demanding overtime goes a long way I would wager. Further, I would really like people sticking up more for themselves, putting up with this nonsense normalizes exploitation and makes it worse for everyone.
- zhemao 9y agoNo company would be stupid enough to explicitly tell its employees that they must work overtime or be fired. Instead, they create an environment in which you feel social pressure to put in more hours. People choose to work long hours because they get affirmation for it from their managers and colleagues. It's a cultural problem.
- a_imho 9y agoUntil it is given in written form, you can go home after clocked in your agreed worktime. Yes, social pressure can be toxic, still, it is entirely up to you whether you want to participate.
- tlear 9y agoSo many dark experiences and I heard more. But I contract right now at a Japanese company. 8 hour days, flexible time.. I work remotely from a different city, I come to office once in 2 weeks for two days staying at hotel. Many guys show up at office at 10-11am. Actually annoying since I prefer to work early in the morning. Also talked to couple other startups that have normal NA hours, their pay was crap though. Also some big web companies have some pretty reasonable hours. Having said that in lots of other places it is hell. Last data point I usually work from collaboration space. Heading home around 5-6pm. It is massive traffic jam around that time.. people heading back home. Maybe to drink? Last train is always hilarious experience, but nobody is mean drunk which is nice.
- iharhajster 9y agoI read somewhere on HN another article about how time management kills productivity, and conclusion was that the best companies integrate idle time in their schedule. The idea is that time is used for processing interrupts.
- wrp 9y agoWhat is described in the article and comments is the Japan I knew in the 1980s. Starting from the mid 1990s, I've heard a lot about how the changed economy caused business culture to shift significantly toward patterns of the West. Has Japanese business culture really not changed all that much?