3 ms·
As was previously discussed when this was first rumored, this is just begging for an anticompetition lawsuit of gigantic proportions as Google is using their do
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
As was previously discussed when this was first rumored, this is just begging for an anticompetition lawsuit of gigantic proportions as Google is using their dominant control of web browsers to block their competitors' ads from working.
It is one of the most clear examples that the only way to remediate the differences between Google and a law abiding corporation is to break it up.
EDIT: I think the strong feedback from everyone I've seen when this was first rumored was that this idea was concerning and likely illegal, and yet Google is proceeding anyways. I feel that should dismiss any notion that Google or the industry as a whole has the ability to self-regulate.
To detail, I think Android and Chrome need to both be legally/forcibly detached from Google. Android could easily operate on funding from the OEMs that use the platform and the Play Store, which would go with it, and Chrome could use Mozilla's model, including letting companies like Google and Yahoo bid for the default search. (And obviously, would be prohibited from picking Google Search if it isn't the highest bidder.)
Dominant platforms being tied to dominant services is just too large a conflict of interest.
- MichaelGG 9y agoAndroid being beholden to OEMs seems like a big loss for end-users though. At least Google is forcing a bit of decency, bit by bit.
- matt4077 9y agoIt will be illegal only if and when they actually treat competitors' ads differently than their own. A good case study is AMP, which allows embedding ads and was, from the beginning, made to be integrated with competing ad networks. The potential for anti-competitive behaviour is so obvious, that Google probably takes a lot of care to crossdot all its legal i's and t's.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoBut bear in mind: They're largely responsible for setting the standards by which these ads will be treated. Therefore, the standards will obviously be set in a manner that all their own ads will comply, and other businesses must change their business to suit Google's expectations or be blocked. Bear in mind, ads are like over 95% of Google's business, they would not be doing this if they thought it would impact their own ads at all. And since, by design, the standards will never go after Google ads, as a site owner, your best bet to not have your ads blocked will be to 'just' go with Google as your ad provider.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]