4 ms·
And as has been pointed out to me offline the article compares 'radioactivity release' of an operating nuclear plant to an operating coal plant. Clearly a prope
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
And as has been pointed out to me offline the article compares 'radioactivity release' of an operating nuclear plant to an operating coal plant. Clearly a properly designed nuclear plant emits no radioactivity at all.
On the plus side I offer the following report from the USGS in 2016 : https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/1997/fs163-97/FS-163-97.html https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/1997/fs163-97/FS-163-97.html which talks about the levels of uranium and thorium in fly ash (0 - 4 ppm).
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAnd for the curious (and since I was wondering about the potential for mining fly ash for uranium), according to Wikipedia, in 2008 the US coal plants generated 131 million tons of fly ash per year[1], so at 4ppm that is 4 tons of uranium per million tons of fly ash, or ~500 tons of uranium per year. According to this site[2] a 1000Mw nuclear plant produces roughly 27 tonnes of 'spent fuel' per year. (be careful of the metric tonnes vs imperial tons variations in sources). Since the EPA in the US requires coal plants to recover and dispose fly ash it could, in theory, be post processed as a source of uranium but also according to Wikipedia it gets used in lots of places. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fly_ash#Present_production_rate_of_fly_ash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fly_ash#Present_production_rat... [2] http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-cycle/nuclear-wastes/radioactive-waste-management.aspx http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fue...
- femto 9y agoBuilding on your "lots of places" comment: I've got memories of an experiment we did in undergraduate physics labs, which involved a directional array of Geiger tubes. Pointing them at the view through the window gave a low count, but pointing them at the concrete structure of the building gave an elevated count. My understanding at the time was that it was due to naturally occurring uranium and thorium in the raw materials of the concrete. Given that fly ash is a common component of concrete [1], I wonder how much of the elevated radiation from concrete can be put down to the concentrating effects of coal combustion that you mentioned in one of your comments? [1] http://www.cementaustralia.com.au/wps/wcm/connect/website/bulk/Bulk-Home/our-products/fly-ash/ http://www.cementaustralia.com.au/wps/wcm/connect/website/bu...
- femto 9y agoI just did a guesstimate: Combustion concentrates radioactivity by a factor of 5x to 10x [1]. Fly ash can replace 25-50% of cement [2]. A typical concrete is 16% cement (1 part cement, 2 parts sand and 3 parts gravel) [3]. Hence a concrete might be 4%-8% fly ash. If the ratio of fly ash is 'A', the concentrating caused by combustion is 'C' and the background radiation of other concrete ingredients is uniformly taken to be 'B', then the radiation count of concrete without fly ash will be: B and the radiation count of concrete with fly ash will be A.C.B + (1-A).B Plugging in values for A (0.04 to 0.08) and C (5 to 10), we find that fly ash increases the radiation from concrete by a factor of 20% to 70%. That strikes me as a significant proportion of the radiation from concrete. [1] https://phys.org/news/2015-09-radioactive-contaminants-coal-ash.html https://phys.org/news/2015-09-radioactive-contaminants-coal-... [2] http://www.theconcreteproducer.com/how-to/concrete-production/whats-the-allowable-fly-ash-limit_o http://www.theconcreteproducer.com/how-to/concrete-productio... [3] http://www.cementaustralia.com.au/wps/wcm/connect/website/packaged-products/home/hints-and-tips/FAQ-Working-with-Concrete/ http://www.cementaustralia.com.au/wps/wcm/connect/website/pa...
- pmiller2 9y agoBut how radioactive is concrete compared to a similar volume of bananas? I would like to know this, but I'm on my phone at the moment. :)
- femto 9y agoAn interesting question! Typical banana dose: 0.1 μSv per banana [1]. Typical concrete building dose: 100μSv per year [2] ie. 1 year in a concrete building = eating 3 bananas a day. I'm not claiming that fly ash laden concrete is going to kill anyone, but I think it's interesting that (given my assumptions) the concentrating effects of coal combustion are causing a decent proportion of concrete's radioactivity (even if the total is still negligible). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_equivalent_dose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_equivalent_dose [2] https://www.euronuclear.org/info/encyclopedia/r/radiation-exposure-building-mat.htm https://www.euronuclear.org/info/encyclopedia/r/radiation-ex...
- pc2g4d 9y agoI believe this is the stuff they put on the roads in PA during the winter. Other places put down sand or gravel when it snows; PA put down ash. It was gross.
- astrodust 9y agoEverything is naturally radiactive to some degree, so it will emit some radiation, but ideally at or lower than background levels.
- colechristensen 9y agoI think it's important to compare the actualities instead of idealizations. Airplanes and cars aren't designed with a certain death rate in mind, but it's good to compare the actual bad outcomes. It's true that coal plants are "designed" to emit a characteristic amount of radioactive material, but they also don't suffer from catastrophic or significant accidental releases so it's appropriate to compare actual historical outcomes. The failure rate of nuclear power is an important part of the consideration. (and it still ends up on top)
- coredog64 9y ago> Airplanes and cars aren't designed with a certain death rate in mind. Not entirely true. The NHTSA can promulgate safety regulations, but if the cost of implementing exceeds the societal cost of not implementing then the regulations don't need to be followed.
- Ermenwyr 9y ago> don't suffer from catastrophic or significant accidental releases In 2008, 1.1 billion gallons of coal fly ash slurry was released from Kingston Fossil Plant in Tennessee. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingston_Fossil_Plant_coal_fly_ash_slurry_spill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingston_Fossil_Plant_coal_fly...
- zamalek 9y ago> also don't suffer from catastrophic or significant accidental releases We've had a countable number of catastrophes and are getting better at building safer reactors (G IV reactors are modulated by physics). Regardless, Chernobyl is estimated to be currently claiming 4000 lives per year worldwide[1], while coal power plants are claiming 7500 lives per year in America alone.[2] Nuclear meltdowns are very scary events. Merely running a coal power plant is a far scarier. [1]: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/releases/2005/pr38/en/ http://www.who.int/mediacentre/news/releases/2005/pr38/en/ [2]: http://www.catf.us/fossil/problems/power_plants/ http://www.catf.us/fossil/problems/power_plants/
- C4K3 9y ago
- sundvor 9y agoWell, here in Australia we are lucky - we've got Clean Coal™! /s http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-05-30/clean-energy-funding-could-be-directed-to-coal/8573010 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-05-30/clean-energy-funding-c...
- Gibbon1 9y agoThe ridiculous thing about all of this is plain topsoil has between 0-4ppm of uranium and thorium. Means fly ash is roughly as radioactive as dirt. However pointedly in modern coal fired plants fly ash it scrubbed[1]. Deal with Uranium and thorium is normal geological processes aren't very efficient at concentrating either. Which means commercially exploitable ores are rare and the element remains widely distributed. [1] It's a bit more tricky since part of the radioactivity from uranium and thorium is due to decay products, some of which probably escape out the stacks. (See radon).
- biafra 9y agoDoes the articles calculation include the nuclear waste that needs to be taken care of after it has served its purpose of producing energy? Or is this article only counting the radioactive emissions during power production?