9 ms·
Coal plants emit more radioactive waste than nuclear plants (2007)
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAn interesting discussion about how burning coal concentrates trace amounts of uranium and thorium in coal and leaves it in fly ash (the remaining particulates). It makes me wonder how much of each element you could extract by "mining" fly ash dump sites.
- Laforet 9y agoPeople have already looked into extracting rare earth elements from fly ash. >Average total REE content (defined as the sum of the lanthanides, yttrium, and scandium) for ashes derived from Appalachian sources was 591 mg kg–1 and significantly greater than in ashes from Illinois and Powder River basin coals (403 and 337 mg kg–1, respectively). The fraction of critical REEs (Nd, Eu, Tb, Dy, Y, and Er) in the fly ashes was 34–38% of the total and considerably higher than in conventional ores (typically less than 15%). http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.est.6b00085 http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.est.6b00085
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAnd as has been pointed out to me offline the article compares 'radioactivity release' of an operating nuclear plant to an operating coal plant. Clearly a properly designed nuclear plant emits no radioactivity at all. On the plus side I offer the following report from the USGS in 2016 : https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/1997/fs163-97/FS-163-97.html https://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/1997/fs163-97/FS-163-97.html which talks about the levels of uranium and thorium in fly ash (0 - 4 ppm).
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAnd for the curious (and since I was wondering about the potential for mining fly ash for uranium), according to Wikipedia, in 2008 the US coal plants generated 131 million tons of fly ash per year[1], so at 4ppm that is 4 tons of uranium per million tons of fly ash, or ~500 tons of uranium per year. According to this site[2] a 1000Mw nuclear plant produces roughly 27 tonnes of 'spent fuel' per year. (be careful of the metric tonnes vs imperial tons variations in sources). Since the EPA in the US requires coal plants to recover and dispose fly ash it could, in theory, be post processed as a source of uranium but also according to Wikipedia it gets used in lots of places. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fly_ash#Present_production_rate_of_fly_ash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fly_ash#Present_production_rat... [2] http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-cycle/nuclear-wastes/radioactive-waste-management.aspx http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fue...
- femto 9y agoBuilding on your "lots of places" comment: I've got memories of an experiment we did in undergraduate physics labs, which involved a directional array of Geiger tubes. Pointing them at the view through the window gave a low count, but pointing them at the concrete structure of the building gave an elevated count. My understanding at the time was that it was due to naturally occurring uranium and thorium in the raw materials of the concrete. Given that fly ash is a common component of concrete [1], I wonder how much of the elevated radiation from concrete can be put down to the concentrating effects of coal combustion that you mentioned in one of your comments? [1] http://www.cementaustralia.com.au/wps/wcm/connect/website/bulk/Bulk-Home/our-products/fly-ash/ http://www.cementaustralia.com.au/wps/wcm/connect/website/bu...
- femto 9y agoI just did a guesstimate: Combustion concentrates radioactivity by a factor of 5x to 10x [1]. Fly ash can replace 25-50% of cement [2]. A typical concrete is 16% cement (1 part cement, 2 parts sand and 3 parts gravel) [3]. Hence a concrete might be 4%-8% fly ash. If the ratio of fly ash is 'A', the concentrating caused by combustion is 'C' and the background radiation of other concrete ingredients is uniformly taken to be 'B', then the radiation count of concrete without fly ash will be: B and the radiation count of concrete with fly ash will be A.C.B + (1-A).B Plugging in values for A (0.04 to 0.08) and C (5 to 10), we find that fly ash increases the radiation from concrete by a factor of 20% to 70%. That strikes me as a significant proportion of the radiation from concrete. [1] https://phys.org/news/2015-09-radioactive-contaminants-coal-ash.html https://phys.org/news/2015-09-radioactive-contaminants-coal-... [2] http://www.theconcreteproducer.com/how-to/concrete-production/whats-the-allowable-fly-ash-limit_o http://www.theconcreteproducer.com/how-to/concrete-productio... [3] http://www.cementaustralia.com.au/wps/wcm/connect/website/packaged-products/home/hints-and-tips/FAQ-Working-with-Concrete/ http://www.cementaustralia.com.au/wps/wcm/connect/website/pa...
- KerrickStaley 9y agoThe title is extremely misleading. The article says that the amount of radiation released into the environment by a coal power plant is more than the amount of radiation released by a comparable nuclear plant. This is because coal ash is radioactive, and although it's (obviously) far less radioactive than radioactive waste, there's no effort to contain its radioactivity, so it results in more radiation exposure to people living around the plant.
- astrodust 9y ago"Coal plants emit more radioactive waste than nuclear plants" is a better translation here.
- vilhelm_s 9y agoOr "than nuclear plants emit during normal operations". I would have liked to see a comparison about how much radioactivity is released per kWh by a coal plant versus a nuclear plant, if you divide Chernobyl and Fukushima by the total amount of nuclear energy produced in the same timespan.
- astrodust 9y agoTo get a better average you'd need to compute the total radioactive emissions of all nuclear plants divided by their operating time and compute per GWh versus coal plants on the same scale. Chernobyl and Fukushima are two exceptional events. There are hundreds of reactors out there both civilian and military that have never had catastrophic faults.
- dang 9y agoWe've changed the title to that. Thanks!
- IanDrake 9y agoThis isn't very useful information. I'm sure Chernobyl and Fukushima have released more radioactivity than every coal fired plant that has ever been or ever will be.
- _jal 9y ago...So, if I told you the number of deaths per year due to car assembly accidents, you'd call it not useful, because car crashes cause way more deaths? To be clear, my suggestion would be to google "category error".
- astrodust 9y agoThere are a lot of coal plants that constantly emit a lot of waste into the atmosphere. Nuclear events are, thankfully, quite rare and have been largely contained. Plus, as bad as radioactive incidents can be, they don't affect the climate. Once the radiation dies down or is mitigated through clean-up efforts there will be no lasting impact on the world. In other words, with the right insurance policy you can recover from a disaster. Hiroshima and Nagasakia were both deliberately targeted by nuclear weapons and are still inhabited. Cleaning up the mess can be expensive, but it's not impossible. Cleaning up the mess made by a coal plant is basically impossible, the effects are too far reaching.
- tibarun 9y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/mar/09/fukushima-nuclear-cleanup-falters-six-years-after-tsunami https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/mar/09/fukushima-nucl... Seriously? "Expensive but not impossible"?
- astrodust 9y agoThere's a huge difference between cleaning up the surrounding landscape and dealing with the broken reactors themselves. Eventually we'll figure out how to fix those. Nothing an X-Prize contest or two can't help address if things get truly desperate. I'd take a contaminated room any day over a whole planet slowly cooking itself to death.
- tibarun 9y agoCan we focus on renewables and stop trying to sell people hazardous waste that can last for millenia? You do realize that you can't actually guarantee what will happen in 10, 20... 50 years time. Earthquakes, Tsunamis, tornados, terrorist attacks, wars, neglect, malfunction, human error... How can you guarantee that a certain place is safe to store millions of tons of radioactive waste for thousands of years if we can't even guarantee what will happen tomorrow? We need to stop this nuclear madness!
- electricEmu 9y agoWell, damming rivers turned out to be a bad idea in cases so (Washington State)[https://relay.nationalgeographic.com/proxy/distribution/public/amp/2016/06/largest-dam-removal-elwha-river-restoration-environment https://relay.nationalgeographic.com/proxy/distribution/publ...] is undoing them. Wind turbines require surmounting large technical hurdles with storing energy. Solar takes a lot of resources/space. Heck, in 50 years we might be in a dust bowl and solar doesn't even work. Why would you suggest we prevent using all appropriate options at our disposal? Why not push for using a different type of fuel instead? I didn't grow up during the nuclear scare times. Fukushima wasn't great, but it wasn't so horrific either. If it gets us off coal and natural gas then I'm down.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- philipkglass 9y agoI think that the Scientific American article somewhat distorts the original article by paraphrasing it. Let's go back to the source. You can view the original Science article via sci-hub.cc if you want to see all the numbers or if you suspect that I've made mistakes with my own commentary. http://science.sciencemag.org/content/202/4372/1045 http://science.sciencemag.org/content/202/4372/1045 DOI: 10.1126/science.202.4372.1045 First look at tables 2 and 3. The raw radionuclide release from the reactors, measured in curies, are far greater than those from the coal plant. Both reactor types release thousands of curies of xenon isotopes and hundreds of curies of krypton isotopes. The PWR also releases thousands of curies in the form of tritium. The coal plant releases less than 2 curies of all radionuclides combined. Next look at table 4. The maximum whole body dose commitment, e.g. the dose that somebody might be exposed to if they lived 500 meters from the sources, just beyond the plant boundary, is highest for the boiling water reactor (4.6 mrem/year), then coal (1.9), then the pressurized water reactor (1.8). But if you look at table 5, average population dose within an 88.5 km radius, you see that the population dose commitment over the whole region is lower for both pressurized and boiling water reactors (given the assumption that 100% of the food people eat is grown in the same region). Table 6, "Population dose commitments from the airborne releases of model 1000-MWe power plants as a function of food intake", is the most interesting table in the article. It shows what parameter is most key to which power source produces greater population exposures: percentage of food eaten that is grown within the same region as the population. At 50% or more local food consumption, which is assumed in table 5, coal always exposes the regional population to a higher radionuclide dose than nuclear reactors. If people were eating 30% or less locally grown food -- which admittedly does not seem likely -- then the region's population could be exposed to more radiation from a nuclear plant than from an equivalent coal plant. Why do nuclear reactors initially emit so much more than coal plants, measured in curies of radionuclides, yet generally expose human populations in the region to less of a body burden? Why does the relative population exposure ordering of nuclear power and coal change depending on how much locally grown food those populations consume? The answers lie in the chemical and biological behaviors of the different radionuclides that respectively dominate emissions from reactors and from coal plants. "Radium-226 and radium-224 are the major contributors to the whole-body and most organ doses from the coal-fired plant. Assuming that the deposited radionuclides could enter the food chain, ingestion is the main exposure pathway for the population dose commitments from this plant (93 to 96 percent for the whole body and most organ doses, 83 percent for the bone dose, and 62 percent for the lung dose). ... Carbon-14 is the main contributor to the whole-body and most of the organ doses from both nuclear plants. Ingestion is the major exposure pathway." Radium is chemically similar to calcium, so it is taken up by plants via the same pathways that take up calcium. It gets stored in the bones of exposed humans. Carbon of course is a major part of human and plant dry mass and also gets stored in organisms. These key isotopes are chemically available to plants and processed as nutrients in the bodies of both plants and humans. Those thousands of curies of noble gases initially released by the nuclear plant? They matter orders of magnitude less when it comes to human exposure. Those gases can't chemically react with anything and diffuse throughout the whole volume of the atmosphere. Plants don't concentrate them and the human body can't store them. The much less significant exposure route, "immersion," basically means exposure to radionuclides in the air all around you. Under most assumptions the immersion route will deliver a lower exposure to a regional population than ingestion via food. But if people in the exposed region are eating 30% or less locally-grown food, then the immersion route can become dominant and can lead to higher population exposure from nuclear power than from coal power. The Scientific American article does not touch on any of these interesting points. It paraphrases the original in a way that actually introduces mistakes. It does not explain why some reasonable assumptions lead to lower population radionuclide exposure from nuclear power than from coal power. The broad summaries remain similar but the mistakes and simplifications lend the Scientific American article an unfortunate air of "here's a nice simple conclusion to bash your friends with the next time they fret about radiation from nuclear power."
- raz32dust 9y agoIt is slightly disingenuous. Although it might be true that a coal plant emits more radioactive material overall, the concern with nuclear plants is the radioactive emission in the event of an accident, not the emissions during regular operation. Just wanted to bring up an important distinction. I personally still support nuclear energy.
- ajross 9y agoIt's also almost certainly wrong in practice, given that the 2007 data in the article wouldn't include the Fukushima meltdown.
- hexane360 9y agoEven accounting for Fukushima and Chernobyl, coal has emitted more radiation per MWh.
- a_imho 9y agoNo one can deny when fission goes wrong, it goes really wrong. Statistics are often ineffective influencing emotions.
- ageofwant 9y agoWhen Naki was evacuated on ground of radiation levels that was orders of magnitude lower that that found naturally at Guarapari beach not a single person died. One year later the suicide count due to the emotional trauma caused by forced eviction exceeded 1000.
- efaref 9y agoBut coal and oil, working correctly, are destroying the planet.
- a_imho 9y agoTo clarify, I'm pro nuclear. I mean it is very hard to fight irrational fears with logic. Like how flying is safer than driving per miles, yet many people are more afraid of planes than cars.
- basicplus2 9y agoI think if you add up all the coal power stations and add up all the nuclear power stations, nuclear power stations emit millions of times more radiation than coal fired power stations.. just look at fukashima Not to mention the waste fuel containing stuff that never existed before being produced in a nuclear power station
- 0xfeba 9y ago> I think if you add up all the coal power stations and add up all the nuclear power stations, nuclear power stations emit millions of times more radiation than coal fired power stations.. just look at fukashima No. Coal spews out constant radioactivity. Nuclear emits nothing during normal operation. Even counting Nuclear disasters, emitted radiation and deaths per kW/h are lower for Nuclear. It is the safest per kW/h, period. > Not to mention the waste fuel containing stuff that never existed before being produced in a nuclear power station Which is much easier to contain then fly ash.
- unlmtd 9y agoNot when there's an accident. And you still need the reactor to build bombs.
- afterburner 9y agoThat's nice. Now let's talk about costs. Not idealized costs, but actual, non-hidden costs of building, maintaining, and decommissioning nuclear power plants (oh and storing the waste in effective perpetuity). What's that you think decommissioning would be too expensive and want to keep running the plant extra long with upgrades? Oooops, that's how you get Fukushima. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/22/world/asia/22nuclear.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/22/world/asia/22nuclear.html
- Toast_ 9y ago>oh and storing the waste in effective perpetuity The only reason we aren't upcycling the 'waste' is because of an order issued by Jimmy Carter to prohibit the proliferation of Plutonium; we could be using it as fuel in other reactors.
- obstinate 9y agoYou get Fukushima by building backup generators right next to the ocean on an island prone to being hit by tsunamis.
- pdkl95 9y agoBuilding next to the ocean is fine. Japan has a lot of experience in protecting their shorelines. The seawall that covers over 40% of their coastline is very impressive. However, as the 2011 tsunami demonstrated, all defenses eventually fail. While some blame lies with TEPCO avoiding recommendations to upgrade the seawall, it's hard to defend against the insane[1] power of over 4m of moving water. This is why the real lesson is to build defenses in depth, with enough variety to protect against common mode failure. Fukushima Daini - only 12km away from Fukushima Daiichi - suffered similarly from the earthquake and tsunami, but a single surviving pump (and the skill and effort of the staff) was enough to prevent Daini from suffering the same fate as it's sister powerplant. Good engineering asks questions like, "Are we safe when (not "if"!) the entire bank of backup generators fail?", or "Can a single event cause catastrophic failure?" [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IKIazZc-a8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IKIazZc-a8
- _pmf_ 9y agoSame for neodymium processing for wind turbine production.
- s0me0ne 9y agoIf you believe in nuclear power so much, please keep the nuclear waste in your state where it's created instead of sending it elsewhere
- Turing_Machine 9y agoIf you believe in "green" power so much, start using it for everything in your daily life. Also, stop importing energy from other states, while essentially banning energy development in your own (cough... Calfornia).
- 0xfeba 9y agoOver having a coal plant spew out shit all day long? Gladly. Too bad everyone else is being irrationally NIMBY like yourself.
- ajuc 9y agoI'm fine with that as long as people opposing nuclear power keep the radioactive ashes from coal powerplants needed to replace the nuclear baseload in their states. As well as all the other toxic wastes. Not mentioning the side-effects, including global warming, starvation, migrations, and wars caused by that. Instead so far they seem to push the externalities to others by either using coal and spewing it all into air, or not using coal, but buying balancing power from elsewhere, where they do use nuclear power or coal power :). I think we can agree both of these alternatives are morally dishonest.
- stmfreak 9y agoComparing the momentary release of coal combustion with the 10,000 year waste management issues of nuclear in the way only "science" journalism can.