4 ms·
Poor Delicious. They were a victim of web 2.0. Much like Digg. Delicious vs Pinboard was basically Digg vs Reddit. The one who focused on the basic core useca
by dmix 9y ago
Poor Delicious. They were a victim of web 2.0. Much like Digg.
Delicious vs Pinboard was basically Digg vs Reddit.
The one who focused on the basic core usecase over flashy features and modern/trendy design won.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoBy the time pinboard was popular delicious was effectively dead. It was delicious that changed, Pinboard basically just took the interface and features it abandoned. They never really competed directly like Reddit and Digg.
- dmix 9y ago> They never really competed directly like Reddit and Digg. Even so that wasn't my core point here. The analogies between the two are still plentiful. Digg didn't die because of Reddit's 'competition' either. Digg shot themselves in the foot while Reddit largely did nothing and won because of it. Both Digg/Delicious made big mistakes by doing their social network era redesigns, while Pinboard and Reddit were built around simple designs and staying true to a core concept. That's the point.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoThis is an unfair and incorrect assessment. It's all situational and contextual. Reddit was pretty much seen as a copycat failure that sold to a large corp because they couldn't figure themselves out. It was only after Digg messed up on their own they enjoyed their run. Pinboard is great, but it never competed against Delicious. In fact it came out long timer after people stopped using Delicious.
- kenko 9y ago> Pinboard is great, but it never competed against Delicious. In fact it came out long timer after people stopped using Delicious. It got a HUGE boost when the announcement of Delicious' sunsetting came out.
- myth_drannon 9y agoI remember the announcement and the huge exodus from delicious to pinboard. That's when I heard of pinboard first. The import feature was under heavy load and from what I remember it took a week(or couple of days? ) to import your bookmarks from delicious or was it from an exported file...
- gsylvie 9y agoHere's the blog entry Maciej wrote about the exodus: https://blog.pinboard.in/2011/03/anatomy_of_a_crushing/ https://blog.pinboard.in/2011/03/anatomy_of_a_crushing/ My favourite line comes from the tweet storm (http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2010/12/the-small-exodus-from-delicious-to-pinboard.html http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2010/12/the-small-exodus-from-...): > "there are worse things than being DDOS'ed by people trying to give you money"
- dmix 9y ago> Pinboard is great, but it never competed against Delicious. I used both products from the early days of each and this is entirely false. Whether or not Delicious continued down the social bookmarking path in it's original incarnation doesn't mean they weren't competing. I only completely switched from Delicious after their awful 'redesign' and still having an outstanding need for a cloud-based bookmarking service when Pinboard came around. Same with Digg/Reddit. I used both but ditched Digg when they did the misguided v3 relaunch, like everyone else.
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y ago> Reddit was pretty much seen as a copycat failure [by whom ?] as they say over in en.wikipedia ... Don't know the numbers, but Reddit always sported a more "in" crowd, who looked down on the Digg unwashed.
- zem 9y agoas an early reddit user, i saw it as "slashdot, but with a better comment engine". digg had more of the feel of a generic news aggregator, not really focused on the slashdot crowd at all; i checked it out briefly but was never really engaged by it.
- janfoeh 9y agoslashdot, but with a better comment engine ... but worse moderation. While rose-tinted glasses may be involved and /. never was Metafilter, if I had to design a community policing system today, Slashdot would be where I would start. Hot grids and all.
- stevekemp 9y agoPresumably you meant "Hot grits"? Those and other things, like Natalie Portman, really take me back.
- gman83 9y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9853651 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9853651
- Kiro 9y ago> The one who focused on the basic core usecase over flashy features and modern/trendy design won. Wouldn't call Delicious flashy or modern. The design is almost as brutalist as Pinboard. I don't like either.
- jlarocco 9y agoNo, I don't agree with that analogy at all. Yahoo bought Delicious and completely mismanaged it, even worse than they did with Flickr. The original Delicious interface was simple and easy to use. Not quite as minimalist as Pinboard, but nowhere near the crap they released later.
- est 9y agoFunny you mentioned reddit, reddit started off as social bookmarking, it's much like Delicious or https://pinboard.in/popular https://pinboard.in/popular but with comments.
- joshu 9y agoNo, it didn't. It was a forum with voting.
- dood 9y agoIn the early days, Delicious and Reddit were often talked about as being in the "social bookmarking" space since they both centered around sharing links with other people. Remember Reddit didn't even have comments for a long time! The distinction was in Delicious you tagged links, in Reddit you voted on links. I visited both regularly to get my social link fix. I'm sure from your POV Reddit has always been an entirely different beast, but (and at the risk of teaching my grandmother how to suck eggs) as an early user of both I saw them as have a lot of similarity, both forging a similar and exciting new future of people collectively making the web more discoverable. I actually tried to build a product which attempted to combine the best of both: a tool for communities to organize links. I still think there is room for something like that, but countless people have tried and none have taken off, so it seem it is way harder to get something like that to catch on than it seemed in those heady days of web 2.0.
- joshu 9y agoYou misremember. Digg said it was "social bookmarking" for a while which caused me no end of headache, but Reddit never did and I don't remember anyone ever talking about them in that context. Neither Reddit nor Digg offered actual bookmarking, so if you thought they were similar to Delicious you didn't really understand the product.