5 ms·
> My favorite anti-portfolio example is Airbnb. Michael Siebel (Y Combinator Core CEO) emailed me their deck before they joined Y Combinator and I couldn’t help
by hn_throwaway_99 9y ago
> My favorite anti-portfolio example is Airbnb. Michael Siebel (Y Combinator Core CEO) emailed me their deck before they joined Y Combinator and I couldn’t help but think “Wow, air mattress rental? That’s a terrible idea!”
I've heard this sentiment repeated a lot ("Everyone thought AirBnB was a horrible idea"), but I honestly can't imagine why, and it makes me think AirBnB must have just had a bad initial pitch deck. At the time AirBnB was founded, Couchsurfing was already really popular, and HomeAway had received some gargantuan investment rounds. Is it really that much of a stretch to say people would want a safe, secure way to rent out private accommodations?
- abecedarius 9y agoMaybe a big part of the reason is that investors and VCs are rich. I wondered about this too.
- princeb 9y agoyeah, if you've never ever had to couchsurf, you will never figure out the appeal of airbnb. I've used airbnb once - to rent a serviced apartment for several months. i'd never use airbnb to rent a room.
- sirspacey 9y agoThe reason AirBnB was so tough to fund, at least from Fred's post, is because it represented a change in cultural norms. Investors are very resistant to ideas that change people's behavior - particularly if the investor can't picture making that change in their own lives.
- shanev 9y agoAlso the website back then was airbedandbreakfast.com, way too long and complex of a domain. Couchsurfing was huge, and I guess investors didn't think a paid version of it would take off if a free version existed. At least that's how I thought about it when I rejected Joe's offer to work on the site in 2008.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoBut my point is that there was plenty of evidence at that time that lots of people were willing to rent out "non-professional" private accommodations.
- showerst 9y agoAt the start, AirBnb was focused entirely on renting out individual rooms in your place, while the host stayed there (sometimes including cooking breakfast!). The ability to rent a whole place came later. Even in hindsight, that's a quirky idea to build a company around.
- PatentTroll 9y agoI ran into the AirBnB guys around the time they were in YC. It was a bad idea then, and it is still a bad idea. They were pitching a for-profit couchsurfing clone. And that idea never did take off, really. What happened is they persisted and were positioned to pivot to vacation rentals and then create a new segment of pseudo-hotel operations at a time when real estate values crashed and the economy was down. The combination of lots of investment real estate under water and a down economy is what made the hotel idea take off.
- graeme 9y agoWhat was wrong with "for profit couchsurfing clone"? That's still a good chunk of airbnb's listings today, and it was a big part of the site in the early years when it was gaining traction. I used to do couchsurfing and I've used airbnb a lot, and there's a lot of overlap in the experience when renting a room. (The whole apartment rentals are different of course, which are a unique hybrid, not even really like a hotel. More like short term furnished apartment rentals, of the kind that formerly worked on a monthly basis for corporate travelers)