3 ms·
The second number is entirely moveable depending on the source of energy. I would argue that (energy?) efficiency doesn't matter when dealing with energy extra
by epistasis 9y ago
The second number is entirely moveable depending on the source of energy.
I would argue that (energy?) efficiency doesn't matter when dealing with energy extracted from the ground or from the sun or wind; what matters is the cost. The article doesn't mention the cost of extracting a ton of CO2 from the atmosphere, other than to say they have a ways to go on that front.
The "cost" of carbon emissions is estimated from $25-$125/ton (Social Cost of Carbon), and financial planning from fossil fuel companies like Exxon use a cost of $80/ton. (For some more familiar numbers, $80/ton equates to about $0.80/gallon of gas, or $0.035/kWh for combined-cycle natural gas electricity).
One could imagine carbon emitters paying for capture, or paying society for the costs that they impose on the rest of us. However, once you add that extra $35/MWh for natural gas electricity, renewables start to look pretty good. (For comparison, wind subsidies in Texas are around $24/MWh, so natural gas is getting a carbon subsidy than wind power gets. And unsubsidized wind and solar in the proper sites are extremely competitive cost wise.)
In any case, within the next few decades at least, it's going to be cheaper to use solar+wind+storage than it is going to be to burn coal and then extract the CO2.