2 ms·
As visually appealing and nigh-brilliant as that is, there's a fatal flaw in it that means I'll never touch the stuff: It distorts the map to enhance meaningfu
by Groxx 16y ago
As visually appealing and nigh-brilliant as that is, there's a fatal flaw in it that means I'll never touch the stuff:
It distorts the map to enhance meaningful areas. All those images are of the same area, compare them to the normal map on the left at the top of the article.
Brilliant and deadly. I use maps because they're physically accurate, so I can estimate times / distances between things, and find alternate paths if needed, and know if I went too far. The distortion there is way too significant to do that sort of analysis, though.
I know I may very well be in the minority in that, but there you have it. I'd love to see a large comparative study between "real" people. Gut-feeling is that most would like it, though, because it seems few outside the geek world are efficient at information filtering.
- troels 16y agoIf you want objective accuracy, do you then use aerial photographs, rather than maps? The point of a map is exactly that it simplifies information, and exaggerating or downplaying certain features is a way of doing this.
- Groxx 16y agoAerial photograph maps are barely more informative than line-maps, and they're filled with much more misinformation. Colors are not correct, I'm on ground-level so I don't see buildings from the top, trees, cars, construction, etc are all incorrect as well by usually over a year, buildings aren't skewed like that (especially tall ones)... Besides, I'd only stated I use it for distances and paths, not color. Where the exaggerating / downplaying of features destroys the ability for comparative analysis of locations with other maps, I find I have little use.
- troels 16y agoBut you're picking one aspect (distance) and attributing a lot of importance to it. Depending on who you are and what you want to do, that may not be the most important thing. For example, if you want to drive somewhere, the exact distance may not be overly important, but the intersections with larger roads probably is.
- BenS 16y agoI think your objection is less about the type of person and more about the use case. Representative maps are best for showing relationships and directions. That's why public transportation maps (subways esp.) are drawn to show how various lines intersect vs. what lat/long coordinate you enter and exit. For your use case, a geographically accurate map may be better.