4 ms·
> Capitalist, so called "meritocratic" And again, HN continues to connect all the ills of the society to that mythical 'capitalsim'. Do you have any knowledge
by golergka 9y ago
> Capitalist, so called "meritocratic"
And again, HN continues to connect all the ills of the society to that mythical 'capitalsim'.
Do you have any knowledge, for example, of how were promotions and salary raises distributed on a typical soviet factory?
Edit: since HN' genius anti-spam system prevents me from posting new comments after a couple of downvotes, I will use this comment to reply instead. (If you're annoyed at this, welcome to the club).
> You shouldn't prop an utterly corrupt system built by perverting an impossible fantasy as proof that we can't do better.
Let's put aside the argument that "USSR wasn't communist/socialist" (which is bullshit, but for different reasons). Let's imagine that USSR was, actually, something else - because it sure as hell wasn't capitalism.
From that, we can infer that the same problem with promotion and corruption happened in vastly different economic and social systems, and, therefore, is not specific nor especially connected to the idea of capitalism.
> I am not in any way related to HN (I am just a regular user), but it's a stab at the claim of some that there is "meritocracy", or that these things are somehow valued, when in fact, they are not.
Being a user makes you related to HN in a sense that you make up HN community - which is exactly what I was referring to.
> In many ways, the societies were less meritocratic, and in some ways more equal
They certainly were - that's exactly what I hate about them and why I embrace capitalism instead.
- Asooka 9y agoA typical soviet factory was a completely different beast. Yes, "real socialism hasn't been tried" is a tired trope, but it's true. Soviet factories ran on promotions by corruption. How loyal are you to the party doctrine? Upper-vice-chief-inspector-of-the-inspecting-of-buttons loyal or just button-maker loyal? You shouldn't prop an utterly corrupt system built by perverting an impossible fantasy as proof that we can't do better.
- js8 9y ago> And again, HN continues to connect all the ills of the society to that mythical 'capitalsim'. I am not in any way related to HN (I am just a regular user), but it's a stab at the claim of some that there is "meritocracy", or that these things are somehow valued, when in fact, they are not. Can't speak for Soviet, but I can somewhat speak for communist Czechoslovakia. In many ways, the societies were less meritocratic, and in some ways more equal. I like to say that whatever was good about communist regime (you would find couple things) was mostly copied from the West in the 50s and 60s. For example, research institutions where there was a big freedom to spend time on research, without being constrained too much by grants and academic performance. (Actually the similar thing was true in the industry, because of the essentially lifetime employment.) Some used it to do good research, some used it to slack off, sure. But it certainly provided somewhat an option to spent a lifetime in one field only, if we return to the topic of the article.
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoOn one side, meritocracy is overstated. Low social mobility being the proof: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socio-economic_mobility_in_the_United_States#/media/File:The_Great_Gatsby_Curve.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socio-economic_mobility_in_the... On the the other hand, increased meritocracy is double edged sword, at least depending on what really "merit" is.
- js8 9y agoI eventually concluded that people don't actually want meritocracy. They just use the word when it happens to suit them. For example, no one would want to have their salary decreased based on current performance. Yet it would be meritocratic. A true meritocracy would be perceived by most people as a cold psychopathic dystopia.