3 ms·
I didn't exactly invent a feudal power structure from whole-cloth, here. It's also important to remember that this society operated upon a consistent legal fram
by vkou 9y ago
I didn't exactly invent a feudal power structure from whole-cloth, here. It's also important to remember that this society operated upon a consistent legal framework - a framework of property rights and contracts.
Incidentally, the fact that we can't enter indentured servitude anymore is much maligned in some libertarian circles. (Mostly among people who think that they will be the masters, rather then the other way around.)
- narrowrail 9y ago>I didn't exactly invent a feudal power structure from whole-cloth, here. No doubt. You did posit it as the alternative, however. Mentioning the idea that some people are ok with indentured servitude (freedom to relinquish your freedom) and try to claim that liberty is the ultimate virtue of these same people seems quite odd.
- gnaritas 9y ago> You did posit it as the alternative No, he posted it as a snarky example of why you simply can't always find compatible beliefs. His point had nothing to do with feudalism or indentured servitude. He was simply making the point that when one group wants to oppress another, there are no compatible compromises to make when the oppressed don't want to be oppressed. Live and let live only works when you don't try and control others but most of our conflict comes from those trying to control others and those others resisting. Abortion would not be an issue if those who didn't like them didn't get them and left everyone else alone. Religion wouldn't be a problem if the religious didn't continually try and impose their morals on the non-religious; don't like gays, don't be gay, but trying to cure other people from gayness is trying to control others. This could go on and on, trying to control others leads to conflict and that's mostly what politics is about, resolving those conflicts.
- cjsthompson 9y agoThey have to impose it, it's "impose or be imposed" since there is only one law and one culture for everyone in a centralized nation-state.