3 ms·
This seems like a weird and hardly surprising piece. The idea that one of two political ideas is 'right' or that that even matters is utterly absurd. The whol
by zepto 9y ago
This seems like a weird and hardly surprising piece.
The idea that one of two political ideas is 'right' or that that even matters is utterly absurd.
The whole point of politics is to find solutions that resolve conflicting desires.
Polarization happens when the solutions simply don't do that.
The problem should not be framed as 'how to get people to change their desires and beliefs' to match a political ideology. The challenge is to come up with some new ways of looking at things that resolve the differences.
- WaxProlix 9y agoOr: "How to come up with a political ideology that better matches peoples' desires and beliefs," maybe?
- gnode 9y agoWhat exactly do you mean by 'resolve'? If you mean to harmonize or reconcile the desires, that's not how politics usually works. Often resolution happens by means of one side marginalising the other.
- zepto 9y agoPolitics used to work by kings beheading nobles deemed traitorous. More recently, as you say, it often works by having 'sides' that marginalize each other. I'm assuming that it's not going to be like that for the rest of human history, and suggesting that the polarization might not be a necessary outcome of people's desires, but rather an artifact of a politicians who don't know how to resolve them.
- xemdetia 9y agoI agree with this simple analysis as well, for whatever reason it became accepted to not reach consensus as just a political strategy. It's hard to tell if this is an expected outcome of the churn and burn design of the US political system's natural drift: popular candidates will stick while unpopular candidates will be replaced by popular ones and eventually the group consensus shifts one way or the other. At a certain point that's totally fine, but recently it just seems to be a consensus shift against reaching consensus which leaves us in this weird flux where there is an obvious majority and we are still frozen stiff. It potentially could just be the outcome of the two-party system needing referendum itself where the coalition democracy designs at least naturally require some level of consensus making from top to bottom.