3 ms·
I'll support this if the US applies tariffs to European countries who don't honor their NATO spending agreements.
by mistermann 9y ago
I'll support this if the US applies tariffs to European countries who don't honor their NATO spending agreements.
- k-mcgrady 9y agoI don't think the two deserve comparison. One is about protecting the planet for future generations. The other is about going into countries to blow people up, for the most part, unnecessarily.
- mistermann 9y agoSo we should disband NATO entirely and Europe can fend for itself? I could get behind that as well, it would save the US a lot of money.
- mistermann 9y agoDownvotes.....shall I interpret this to mean that saving lives is not a byproduct of NATO? If that's the case, what's the point of it?
- celticninja 9y agoTo be honest the EU as an organisation has probably saved as many (if not more) lives than NATO has if we are saying that preventing wars is saving lives. I have nothing against NATO but it does seem like you don't understand the system and are taking your president at his (notoriously unreliable) word.
- mistermann 9y agoThe two are not mutually exclusive.
- celticninja 9y agoIt would not save the US a lot of money at all. http://money.cnn.com/2017/03/20/news/nato-funding-explained/ http://money.cnn.com/2017/03/20/news/nato-funding-explained/ >The North Atlantic alliance has its own military budget worth €1.29 billion ($1.4 billion), which is used to fund some operations and the NATO strategic command center, as well as training and research. But it is miniscule compared to overall spending on defense by NATO countries, which NATO estimates will total more than $921 billion in 2017. To be clear the vast amount of money spent by the US on defence (or offence) is not directly spent on NATO. There is a NATO operating budget that is approx 0.33% of the US annual spending on military. So if the US withdrew from NATO they would not stop spending all that money on defence, sure they may close some bases in Europe and around the world but all that will do is further weaken their sphere of influence. And if there was a Russian or Chinese invasion of Europe then it would be in the US's interests to assist in any fight because if Russia or China managed to takeover mainland Europe that would be it for the USA in terms of any sort of world leader status/influence which is pretty much accepted because of the support of its NATO allies as it currently stands.
- mistermann 9y agoWhat you've said is largely true, but asserting that the US military presence in Europe costs literally nothing seems unlikely. EDIT: I obviously misspoke using literally nothing, please replace with not a lot of money at all. The point that matters is: is it a non-trivial amount of money or not, and has it plausibly benefited Europe by decreasing the number of wars? The region does have a history of it after all. This apparent sentiment that my line of thinking is 100% wrong feels a bit offensive to me, if anyone cares about such things, and believes that perhaps feelings affect real world behavior.
- celticninja 9y agoThe placing of US military bases in Europe has not reduced the number of wars in Europe. That is directly related to the creation of the EU which was essentially set up for that specific purpose. I'm not saying that there is no cost to US bases in Europe. They are probably expensive to maintain, but in general they are there because the US wants them there and they benefit the US more than the host nation. Same goes all over the world, Japan, the Middle East, Korea. The bases are there to give the US some influence and clout, it is force projection. I would repeat for clarity that US bases in Europe have done nothing to prevent wars between EU nations, the credit for that goes to the EU.
- celticninja 9y agoVery different situation.
- desdiv 9y agoHere's the full text of the Paris Agreement[0] and here[1] is Secretary of State John Kerry signing said agreement on behalf of the United States in New York on 2016-04-22. Show me a text of this "NATO spending agreement", when and where it was signed by a Representative of the United States, and then we'll talk. Hint: you can't, because no such treaty exists. [0] http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2015/cop21/eng/l09r01.pdf http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2015/cop21/eng/l09r01.pdf [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Secretary_Kerry_Holds_Granddaughter_Dobbs-Higginson_on_Lap_While_Signing_COP21_Climate_Change_Agreement_at_UN_General_Assembly_Hall_in_New_York_(26512345421).jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Secretary_Kerry_Holds_Gra...
- mistermann 9y agoInteresting. I'd think NATO would involve some sort of negotiated terms, it's hard to believe that funding would be excluded from that, but who knows. I'm no expert on it, but it seems quite odd that this point of contention is a complete figment of the imagination of American politicians for several decades and European politicians never point out that it's completely made up. I now wonder if my perception of the military blanket of protection the US provides to Europe also a figment of people's imagination. Do they have military bases and personnel in the region, or am I imagining that also?
- celticninja 9y agoPlease see here: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/26/world/europe/nato-trump-spending.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/26/world/europe/nato-trump-s... The gist of it is that no NATO members are in arrears for the contributions that are required to NATO. There is a NATO goal that member states should spend 2% of their GDP on their own defence each year. This is where some countries are not meeting that goal but the money certainly is not owed to the United States. Further it could be said that given that the US is home to many companies that make weapons this is a way for the US to get NATO members to spend money on US goods. (NATO members are unlikely to buy weapons systems from Russia or China). So as I said there is a very real difference between the 2 systems and it is unfair to use them in conjunction with one another because the NATO one is a goal, a 'nice to have' if you will.