6 ms·
Defense Contractor Left Sensitive Pentagon Files on Unprotected AWS S3 Bucket
- danso 9y agoIt's really confusing how they ended up in this predicament. S3 buckets are private by default. You have to manually configure them to be public-read. Given the scope of Booz Allen's work, it doesn't seem like they needed any of the S3 buckets to ever be just public. I wonder if they're using software or maybe even just copied a script in which the default assumption for S3 configuration and uploads is to set files to be public?
- QuinnyPig 9y agoI'm wondering if they were bitten by the semi-common "any authenticated user" misunderstanding. That maps to any user in all of S3, not just your account.
- unclesaamm 9y agoMuch more likely for it to be the ole "Download it quickly and I'll make it private" Edit: After reading the article, I have no idea what could explain this. They had a dozen passwords in there as well..
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- conorh 9y agoWe had this issue previously as one of our clients was using cyberduck to upload files and it had default read access for public for uploads. [1] https://forums.aws.amazon.com/thread.jspa?messageID=213248 https://forums.aws.amazon.com/thread.jspa?messageID=213248
- jamiesonbecker 9y agotinyS3 used to do this as well: https://github.com/smore-inc/tinys3/issues/44 https://github.com/smore-inc/tinys3/issues/44
- danso 9y agoYeah, this is also something that can be set using Transmit (my OS X GUI of choice). I guess I assumed that, given the size of the data they have to manage, they have something more sophisticated than file-management-by-click-and-drag but...maybe I'm giving them too much credit in terms of dev ops.
- empath75 9y agoThis happens surprisingly often.
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoWho knows what dumb GUI they used that configures the bucket with public access by default.
- sevensor 9y agoThe really interesting question for me is why the government would award new contracts to Booz Allen after the Snowden leaks. (While I applaud Snowden, I deplore the government's inability to prevent his leaks.) Booz Allen demonstrated that they were unable to enforce appropriate practices for handling classified data. So what's the rationale for ever awarding them another contract? What capabilities do they have that the government doesn't have or can't develop?
- jbooth 9y agoThe question is more, "what capabilities do they have that other companies don't", and I suspect the answer is "extreme proficiency at the federal RFP process".
- uncoder0 9y agoYour answer would be correct, at least in my experience... the amount of times my DARPA RFP's have been shot down by some minor box that didn't get ticked in the RFP process is a bit absurd. We even had a dedicated contract officer who used to work there to help with the process.
- tssva 9y agoHow would you have them decide who is allowed to deviate from the documented RFP process and by how much? Also not checking all the boxes during the RFP process sends a signal about your ability to do so once the work is awarded.
- uncoder0 9y agoIn the specific cases I'm talking about the 'ticking all the boxes' was rather subjective and not adequately explained in the RFP.
- BearGoesChirp 9y ago>Also not checking all the boxes during the RFP process sends a signal about your ability to do so once the work is awarded. A false signal that people would be wise to ignore. There are a multitude of examples showing that companies that learn how to check all the right RFP boxes pay no mind to checking any of the 'do a good job and product a good product' boxes. It shows they are good at checking only the boxes that make them money, and the current process is that doing a good job is not a box one's pay depends upon. Is there any similar evidence that people who fail to check all the RFP boxes also fail to check the "do a good job and deliver a good product" boxes?
- kelvin0 9y ago<Tin-Foil-hat> Well that could also be construed as a 'oups my bad' kind of way of leaking documents, instead of going the (painful) whistle-blowing route ... </Tin-Foil-hat>
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- atemerev 9y agoSometimes when I read such things, I really hope that it was a planted leak to seed disinformation to The Russians (tm). But then I realize that this is the US government we are talking about...
- tuna-piano 9y agoFor those wondering how this can happen - AWS' command line tools and SDKs by default upload files as private. Scarily, some other libraries set uploads to public by default, for example: https://www.smore.com/labs/tinys3/ https://www.smore.com/labs/tinys3/ For those who say cloud isn't less secure than on-prem... that may be true. However, the cloud is generally just one incorrect click or setting away from being completely open. Anyone know how the security researcher found the public bucket? Does he just crawl for buckets made up of common words? Does AWS not limit the amount of crawling from one IP?
- raesene9 9y agoThe idea of crawling for S3 content has been around for a while (see this post from 2011 https://digi.ninja/blog/whats_in_amazons_buckets.php https://digi.ninja/blog/whats_in_amazons_buckets.php for one example). Also google can end up indexing content in places like S3 or Azure file stores if there's a link there from another piece of content that it indexes. (for example https://community.rapid7.com/community/infosec/blog/2013/03/27/1951-open-s3-buckets https://community.rapid7.com/community/infosec/blog/2013/03/...)
- lazaroclapp 9y agoCloud isn't less secure than on-prem if you are your average software startup or non-tech company, which, for many reasons, is unlikely to go all out on on-prem security. Commodity cloud should be less secure than on-prem, if you are fucking Booz Allen...
- FooHentai 9y ago>Cloud isn't less secure than on-prem if you are your average software startup or non-tech company Even that's hard to argue, unless you rely on a fundamental incompetence within that startup or an often-unprovable competence level on the part of cloud providers. There have been enough cloud-hosting provider security facepalms hitting the front pages now so 'cloud providers are better at security than small shops' is starting to be called out as the blind falsehood it has always been. Fundamentally it has always really been 'We're unable to see what these guys are doing behind the curtain so we'll assume good faith', and little more. The emperor may have clothes, or in many cases has been utterly balls-out naked, but up until now groupthink has been that not knowing = must be secure. I am biased though, I spend most of my work hours analysing service providers big and small, self-hosted and cloud, and have probably developed a suitably sceptical view in that time.
- oval-atom 9y agoRetired as govt engineer. Reported a security violation, employees sharing passwords/account on a secured network. The 2 contractor ITs claimed to know nothing about it. At most only a handful of employees have access to the network and at most, but rarely 3 work on the network at the same time. If the contractor ITs were not aware, and they never are more that a few feet of the activity, they should have been fired. Management moved me to an isolated area and began the slow process of retaliation, so as not to look like retaliation. To their surprise, I walked away from my job. BTW, the supervisor I was reassigned too, told me not to report any more observations. I am not a fan of contractor support, and I see no reason to use such infrastructure such as Amazon to store any data, especially sensitive data.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoThe US is seriously blundering by using contractors for military operations, and instead needs to hire more military personnel and civilian employees. This fixation on not having more government staff (and on funneling money to private sector contractors) is endangering the US government's operation. In-house staff aren't a panacea, but in-housing critical capabilities has always been the prudent decision. Of course, much the same can be said about contractors and off-shoring in the private sector as well. At this point, the US is cannibalizing its future for short-term gains. Of course, the people making the decisions generally won't bear the costs, and have convinced much of the populace that such a strategy will benefit them through wishes and pixie dust.
- random3 9y agoSo docker registry credentials and auth to a "datacenter operating system". I wonder if they use Mesos and Mesosphere's DC/OS :)
- nthcolumn 9y agoKids these days have it easy. You young whippersnappers! We didn't have google dorks you have today! Hell we didn't even have google! Back in my day if you wanted to hack the Pentagon you actually had to hack the Pentagon!!! And there was no tor hideurass neither... times like this makes me think the internet is just one big honeypot...